The leaks (Why now? Who leaked them? Are they on CD? Comparisons to old demos)

[AxlFink]

fink and fortus can play what buckethead played on TWAT.  ITs amazing stuff but nothing is that hard.

[killingvector]

fink and fortus can play what buckethead played on TWAT.  ITs amazing stuff but nothing is that hard.

I would prefer Mr. Buckethead to come back and play for himself.

[Aero]

From several years up to now, I've heard Gn'R Musicans, Guest musicans, People working on the album...

Where are the orchestal arrangements on twat?
Where are the revolutionary album? These songs are parte of that?
Why all the songs has an ugly electronic intro? Bucket has gone come on...
Where are the complex Izzy fixes in the songs? this new music sounds very simple, all power chords...
Where are the queen style arrangements?
Where the fuck is the drummer? did you guys listen the drum tracks?
Why the bass plays nothing but tonics ?

I know this is a demo... but those songs are far, FAR away to be revolutionaries. Axl vocal melodies are great, and the solos sounds good... buy the rytmical parts are damn poor, and the whole songs are not what all the people over the years had told me 

I'm gonna wait for the album... few years more 

[BLS-Pride]

There are more songs on the album. And TWAT will sound nothing like the demo.. Its such a rough cut.

[Nytunz]

come on!! This is DEMOS! How do we know this is the way they sound on the album??

[nesquick]

They are basic demos converted in mp'3 (with a sound loss).

[rainX]

chill yourself

this is exactly why leaks like this are bad because people like you think they are final cuts

this shit is at least 3, 3 and a half years old

demos man

[BLS-Pride]

I picture some metal head stoner saying that..

Demos man, demos..

IDK.. dont ask.. weird cuple of days.

[Axl_GNR]

They sound great, I already consider TWAT one of the best songs ever....and Better too though we haven't heard the full version.

[AxlFink]

Twat is revolutionary.  It's fuckin amazing.  IRS is a rockin song that kicks ass!  Better sounds like it will be a really cool song. 

[Aero]

They are basic demos converted in mp'3 (with a sound loss).

I already said that... but drums SUCKS and bass SUCKS. rytm parts sounds very "korn"

Better and TWAT are supposed to be the big guns in the album, according to many interviews. These songs are supposed to be the "estranged" and the "Sweet child" of the upcoming album...

Compare the new tracks with appetite or UYI demos 


The songs are not bad... but they are not "revolutionary"

"revolution" were the beatles, not chinese democracy.

I'm tryin to say that the songs are not bad... but they are not what they sold me with interviews and comments.

[Neemo]

My reason has been used many times already so 

[WARose]

didn`t you read the posts prior to your second one???

noone knows if these demos represent the final product in a proper way...so wait for CD to make your negative judgements...

[oneway23]

They are basic demos converted in mp'3 (with a sound loss).

I already said that... but drums SUCKS and bass SUCKS. rytm parts sounds very "korn"

Better and TWAT are supposed to be the big guns in the album, according to many interviews. These songs are supposed to be the "estranged" and the "Sweet child" of the upcoming album...

Compare the new tracks with appetite or UYI demos 


The songs are not bad... but they are not "revolutionary"

"revolution" were the beatles, not chinese democracy.

I'm tryin to say that the songs are not bad... but they are not what they sold me with interviews and comments.

Not to repeat myself, but I'm assuming you've never heard the november rain demo?

[Neemo]

Not to repeat myself, but I'm assuming you've never heard the november rain demo?

Oooooohh good one oneway23 that is a sweet comparison, imagine if the songs prgress by that amount to the final mix!! Holy shit!!!! that would be freaking sweet

[gnr lives on]

Not to repeat myself, but I'm assuming you've never heard the november rain demo?

Oooooohh good one oneway23 that is a sweet comparison, imagine if the songs prgress by that amount to the final mix!! Holy shit!!!! that would be freaking sweet

u beat me to the punch..i was just about to say that...the NR demo sounded nothing like the beautiful song that we now know to be NR

[ppbebe]

I don't remember anyone from the GNR camp promissed  whatever revolutionary.

Anyway, what beatles song is revolutionary to you?

[Neemo]

I don't remember anyone from the GNR camp promissed? whatever revolutionary.

Anyway, what beatles song is revolutionary to you?

Revolution

[killingvector]

I don't remember anyone from the GNR camp promissed  whatever revolutionary.

Anyway, what beatles song is revolutionary to you?

me neither.

Is it good music? Does it give you pleasure? Does it mean something to you? These are the questions that should be asked of oenself.

btw, at no point do any of these songs sound like korn.  Typical haters.

[freddiebrph]

Not to repeat myself, but I'm assuming you've never heard the november rain demo?

Oooooohh good one oneway23 that is a sweet comparison, imagine if the songs prgress by that amount to the final mix!! Holy shit!!!! that would be freaking sweet

u beat me to the punch..i was just about to say that...the NR demo sounded nothing like the beautiful song that we now know to be NR

EXACTLY! That is the whole point I was trying to make. How can you listen to this version of twat and say it is ok, nothing special. Those early NR demos were nothing special. But NR is one of the best songs ever recorded. I think twat has that potential, I cant wait to here it on the album. I can almost see it being played live, (axl on piano, Slash standing on paino) Whoops, I forgot :-)