|
Title: The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: GNROSAS on March 07, 2004, 12:19:43 PM W. Axl. Rose (Excellent singer, frontman, composer)
Buckethead (extremely talented, with new ideas,experiments, great appearance) Slash (Excellent feeling, tone, solos, appearance) Izzy (Very Good simple guitar ideas) Duff (Punk attitude, appearance) Brain (V.good drummer, very tight with Buckethead, experiments) Dizzy (Cause it links with the others and especially Axl) 976 horns (I am Joking!!) Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: The Michelin-Man on March 07, 2004, 12:21:45 PM axl, slash, duff, izzy & steven
Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: HoldenCaulfield on March 07, 2004, 12:50:41 PM Axl
Bucket Finck Tommy Richard Brain Dizzy Chris Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: twitcher on March 07, 2004, 01:05:53 PM Finck
Bucket Fortus Tommy Dizzy Chris Brain & then all they need is a singer who could be arsed to turn up to gigs and release material and they would be the ultimate lineup, not just the ultimate GnR lineup. Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: rocktar81 on March 07, 2004, 01:15:27 PM Axl
Slash Duff Fortus Matt Dizzy additional: Izzy (to help writting some good songs) Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Lineker10 on March 07, 2004, 01:27:46 PM Axl
Slash Izzy Duff Steven Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: axl_rose_700 on March 07, 2004, 02:22:21 PM Axl
Slash Izzy Tommy Steven Dizzy Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Mikkamakka on March 07, 2004, 02:32:36 PM Axl
Slash Izzy Duff Matt It'd be a very creative line-up. In the past years all of them (except of Axl) proved his brilliant creativity, even Matt became a great songwiter. Dizzy is not needed. Gilby can help in songwriting, he is a very talented musician, just listen Cure me or kill me, Monkey Chow, Tijuana jail etc. Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Doc Emmett Brown on March 07, 2004, 02:41:43 PM Buckethead (extremely talented, Slash (Excellent feeling, tone, solos, appearance) Buckethead and Slash in the same band? Slash would feed the chickens to his snakes, and Bucket would shave off Slash's curls while he was sleeping at night. Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: jellyhead on March 07, 2004, 02:42:15 PM Axl Slash Izzy Duff Matt even Matt became a great songwiter. What? ??? I don't think his solo record or the riff from Set Me Free justify greatness. Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Timothy on March 07, 2004, 02:52:43 PM axl
slash izzy fortus duff tommy steven dizzy Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: blues_rock_axeman on March 07, 2004, 03:01:28 PM Axl Slash Duff Fortus Matt Dizzy additional: Izzy (to help writting some good songs) Fortus over Izzy? Are you crazy? There's no finer line-up for Guns N' Fuckin' Roses than Axl, Izzy, Slash, Steven and Duff. However, they'd probably be dead for the most part if what had happened didn't... Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: SwedeChildO'Mine on March 07, 2004, 05:43:35 PM Axl
Slash Izzy Duff Steven Tha Ultimate Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Fuckin' Gunner on March 07, 2004, 06:31:29 PM W. Axl Rose
Slash Buckethead Izzy / Fortus (the both are great, I'd put Izzy 'cause he's got more history into the band) Duff McKagan Dizzy Pittman (I think he's good, please respect my opinion) Josh Freese Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Captain P?l on March 07, 2004, 06:46:00 PM vox -seb. bach
bass -steve harris drums -nicko mcbrain guitar - ?ystein sunde guitar - that other norwegian dude wich is in the guiness book of record as the fastest player ever.... guitar - snake that would kick totaly ass!! :D i think... Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: just_one on March 07, 2004, 08:20:14 PM axl
slash duff gilby matt dizzy Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Dizzy on March 07, 2004, 09:15:11 PM Slash
Steven Adler Axl Rose Izzy Stradlin Duff McKagan And if necessary, Dizzy Reed. Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: bill213 on March 07, 2004, 09:34:46 PM Axl
Tracii Izzy Duff Rob Now there's a kickass lineup. huhuh Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Reinaldo on March 07, 2004, 10:39:03 PM Axl
BH Finck Fortus Tommy Steven Dizzy Chris Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: matt88 on March 08, 2004, 02:57:25 AM Only the originals for me
axl slash duff izzy steven, and if any song was gonna need an organ or piano then dizzy Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Death Cube K on March 08, 2004, 04:09:09 AM Axl
Bucket Robin Richard Tommy Chris Dizzy Brain Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Terminator on March 08, 2004, 04:33:42 AM Axl Rose
Slash Izzy Stradlin Duff McKagan Steven Adler And if need be, Mr. Dizzy Fucking Reed. Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: hackvresse on March 08, 2004, 09:24:29 AM Axl
Bucket Slash Izzy/Fortus Duff Matt Dizzy Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: PhillyRiot on March 08, 2004, 10:57:27 AM Axl, Slash, Izzy, Duff and Steven Adler. The original 5 will always remain the ultimate lineup for me. The new band plays the hell out of the old material, but the original 5 are responsible for the new material. I would judge new GNR material but.......
Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Doc Emmett Brown on March 08, 2004, 12:02:20 PM vox -seb. bach bass -steve harris drums -nicko mcbrain guitar - ?ystein sunde guitar - that other norwegian dude wich is in the guiness book of record as the fastest player ever.... guitar - snake haha that's funny! :D Well if Axl can replace all the Gunners, so can you! : ok: Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: St.heathen on March 08, 2004, 05:38:09 PM Axl
Slash Duff Gilby Buckethead Richard fortus Matt Dizzy Teddy big-bad- zig- zag greek on the harmonica lol (just for old times sake) Izzy (to co-write as i dont think he would want to tour) The Bhead/Slash clash theory maybe some truth to it now. But i think if they met under different circumstances they would jam well. Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: //JK75 on March 08, 2004, 07:47:29 PM Axl Rose
Slash Izzy Stradlin' Duff Mckagan Matt Sorum Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: tomass74 on March 09, 2004, 12:39:00 AM Axl
Slash Izzy Duff Steven Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: AxlN'Slash on March 09, 2004, 09:42:38 AM Axl-vox
Slash-lead Fortus-Rythem Izzzy-Rythem Duff-Bass Steven-Drums and if Dizzy is needed then that would NOT be the Ultimate lineup! Dizzy was the start of the end! :hihi: Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Malcolm on March 09, 2004, 11:03:09 AM axl
slash duff gilby dizzy matt Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: St.heathen on March 09, 2004, 11:15:08 AM Do you guys really think Steven would be a better choice over Matt?
I don't think he could do it justice anymore, looks pretty wrecked, from what i have seen. Maybe he could do the Appetite stuff. But i would want more than that, i would want Coma, Pretty tied up, Right next door to hell... all those beasty greats. Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: SLCPUNK on March 09, 2004, 04:51:09 PM The ultimate one to me is the one most likely to see perform now a days. So the current line up is just fine with me.
Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Dizzy on March 09, 2004, 06:17:03 PM Do you guys really think Steven would be a better choice over Matt? Yes. He's been playing the AFD stuff regularly at his Adler's Appetite shows, and everyone who's seen the shows say he still has it. As Izzy said, Steven had the swing that gave those songs their push and pull. Matt's a decent drummer but he was too much of a power player for GNR. GNR rarely ever played "Coma" live. Maybe twice. Most of the UYI songs were written and rehearsed (and some were recorded as demos) while Steven was in the band anyway, so I'm sure he could handle them. Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Slashly on March 09, 2004, 06:24:18 PM axl
slash duff izzy matt dizzy say no more Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Captain P?l on March 09, 2004, 06:40:04 PM Do you guys really think Steven would be a better choice over Matt? Yes. He's been playing the AFD stuff regularly at his Adler's Appetite shows, and everyone who's seen the shows say he still has it. As Izzy said, Steven had the swing that gave those songs their push and pull. Matt's a decent drummer but he was too much of a power player for GNR. GNR rarely ever played "Coma" live. Maybe twice. Most of the UYI songs were written and rehearsed (and some were recorded as demos) while Steven was in the band anyway, so I'm sure he could handle them. what about You Could be mine? and back off bitch.. ive heard steven version... matt is by far better... but everybody is entitled for they own opinions... Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Izzy on March 09, 2004, 06:45:50 PM Axl
Slash Izzy Duff Steven Title: Re:Tha Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: EVH on March 09, 2004, 07:11:49 PM Slash Steven Adler Axl Rose Izzy Stradlin Duff McKagan And if necessary, Dizzy Reed. I 2nd that Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: MR.BROWNSTONE on March 09, 2004, 11:27:39 PM Axl
Bucket Finck Tommy Richard Brain Dizzy Chris : ok: Title: Re:The Ultimate GNR Lineup Post by: Dizzy on March 10, 2004, 07:12:12 PM what about You Could be mine? and back off bitch.. ive heard steven version... matt is by far better... Matt must be given credit for the intro to "You Could Be Mine", that is a technically sound masterpiece of drumming, but the remainder of the song is repetitive and could easily be emulated by any competent drummer. I think Steven could learn the way Matt played the UYI songs and pull them off just fine. Just because we haven't heard him play many of them live doesn't mean he is not capable. |