*REDUX* GN'R songs ranked by HTGTH. Round 5: "The Spaghetti Incident?"

[COMAMOTIVE]

13        Since I Don't Have You
6          New Rose
15        Down On The Farm
14   +1     Ain't It Fun
4          Hair Of The Dog
3   -2   I Don't Care About You
5       Look At Your Game, Girl

[rebelhipi]

13         Since I Don't Have You
7   +1    New Rose
15         Down On The Farm
12  -2    Ain't It Fun
4           Hair Of The Dog
3           I Don't Care About You
5           Look At Your Game, Girl

[rebelhipi]

Btw.
What about adding Oh My God to the Chinese vote.

Good idea or not?

[arnarsi]

13         Since I Don't Have You
7           New Rose
15         Down On The Farm
13 +1    Ain't It Fun
4           Hair Of The Dog
1   -2     I Don't Care About You
5           Look At Your Game, Girl

[COMAMOTIVE]

Btw.
What about adding Oh My God to the Chinese vote.

Good idea or not?

They tried this with Shadow - adding it to the Appetite (wtf) which is not only the greatest hard rock album of all time, but that shitty little song beat Sweet Child - so unless you want to see OMG beat TWAT - I'd tred lightly on that one 

[allwaystired]

13         Since I Don't Have You
7           New Rose
15         Down On The Farm
13         Ain't It Fun
5  (+1)  Hair Of The Dog
1           I Don't Care About You
3   (-2)  Look At Your Game, Girl

[sakuL]

Btw.
What about adding Oh My God to the Chinese vote.

Good idea or not?

They tried this with Shadow - adding it to the Appetite (wtf) which is not only the greatest hard rock album of all time, but that shitty little song beat Sweet Child - so unless you want to see OMG beat TWAT - I'd tred lightly on that one 

If Chinese was released in 2000 (as 2000 Intensions) then it would make sense. But the releases are so much distant from each other that it is clearly noticeable in sound. I don't think it would be a good idea to include it.

It would be however interesting to have a bonus round with all the special singles (like Oh My God and Sympathy for the Devil), unreleased songs (like Crash Diet) and some other recordings - some of it released with the AFD remaster (like Jumping Jack Flash, Heartbreak Hotel).

[COMAMOTIVE]

Btw.
What about adding Oh My God to the Chinese vote.

Good idea or not?

They tried this with Shadow - adding it to the Appetite (wtf) which is not only the greatest hard rock album of all time, but that shitty little song beat Sweet Child - so unless you want to see OMG beat TWAT - I'd tred lightly on that one 

If Chinese was released in 2000 (as 2000 Intensions) then it would make sense. But the releases are so much distant from each other that it is clearly noticeable in sound. I don't think it would be a good idea to include it.

It would be however interesting to have a bonus round with all the special singles (like Oh My God and Sympathy for the Devil), unreleased songs (like Crash Diet) and some other recordings - some of it released with the AFD remaster (like Jumping Jack Flash, Heartbreak Hotel).

Agreed

I think we're all pretty much bored out of our minds so maybe add live covers to it as well (if more material needed)

[westcoast_junkie]

13         Since I Don't Have You
7           New Rose
15         Down On The Farm
14 +1   Ain't It Fun
5           Hair Of The Dog
1           I Don't Care About You
1   (-2)  Look At Your Game, Girl

Gotta give one to this fine duet with the great Mike Monroe!

[kunzerd]

13         Since I Don't Have You
7           New Rose
15         Down On The Farm
12  -2  Ain't It Fun
5           Hair Of The Dog
1           I Don't Care About You
2  (+1)  Look At Your Game, Girl

[alcapone_dudu]

13         Since I Don't Have You
7           New Rose
15         Down On The Farm
12         Ain't It Fun
6     +1  Hair Of The Dog
1           I Don't Care About You
0     -2  Look At Your Game, Girl c u

[AxlsMainMan]

13         Since I Don't Have You
5    -2    New Rose
15         Down On The Farm
13  +1   Ain't It Fun
6           Hair Of The Dog
1           I Don't Care About You

[Bridge]

13         Since I Don't Have You
5           New Rose
13  -2    Down On The Farm
14  +1   Ain't It Fun
6           Hair Of The Dog
1           I Don't Care About You

[PermissionToLand]

Wait, why were Buick Makane and Big Dumb Sex combined but IDC About You and Look at Your Game separated?

[thelostrose]

13         Since I Don't Have You
5           New Rose
13         Down On The Farm
12  -2    Ain't It Fun
6           Hair Of The Dog
2   +1    I Don't Care About You

[dsaddler78]

13          Since I Don't Have You
5            New Rose
14  +1    Down On The Farm
12          Ain't It Fun
4    -2     Hair Of The Dog
2            I Don't Care About You

[COMAMOTIVE]

Wait, why were Buick Makane and Big Dumb Sex combined but IDC About You and Look at Your Game separated?

About 2 minutes of separation I'd imagine

[Spirit]

Wait, why were Buick Makane and Big Dumb Sex combined but IDC About You and Look at Your Game separated?

GN'R incorporated Buick Makane and Big Dumb Sex into one single song, while the other two are clearly two separate songs. "Look At Your Game, Girl" was a hidden track.

[rebelhipi]

Btw.
What about adding Oh My God to the Chinese vote.

Good idea or not?

They tried this with Shadow - adding it to the Appetite (wtf) which is not only the greatest hard rock album of all time, but that shitty little song beat Sweet Child - so unless you want to see OMG beat TWAT - I'd tred lightly on that one 

If Chinese was released in 2000 (as 2000 Intensions) then it would make sense. But the releases are so much distant from each other that it is clearly noticeable in sound. I don't think it would be a good idea to include it.

It would be however interesting to have a bonus round with all the special singles (like Oh My God and Sympathy for the Devil), unreleased songs (like Crash Diet) and some other recordings - some of it released with the AFD remaster (like Jumping Jack Flash, Heartbreak Hotel).

Agreed

I think we're all pretty much bored out of our minds so maybe add live covers to it as well (if more material needed)

I like this

[Bridge]

What about adding Oh My God to the Chinese vote.

Maybe.

But what about "Silkworms"?     After all, its first line was "listen motherfuckers, to this song that should be heard!"