*REDUX* GN'R songs ranked by HTGTH. Round 5: "The Spaghetti Incident?"

[rebelhipi]

Im Gonna give my vote for today a little early. My last vote was on my time zone at 11pm and now its 2 pm

12        Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
12        Down On The Farm
8          Human Being
14        Ain't It Fun
7          Hair Of The Dog
6          Attitude
5          Black Leather
1    -2   You Can't Put Your Arms Around A Memory
10  +1  I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[allwaystired]

12        Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
12        Down On The Farm
8          Human Being
14        Ain't It Fun
7          Hair Of The Dog
4  (-2)  Attitude
5          Black Leather
2   (+1)You Can't Put Your Arms Around A Memory
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[BluesGNR]

12        Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
12        Down On The Farm
8          Human Being
14        Ain't It Fun
7          Hair Of The Dog
4          Attitude
6    +1  Black Leather
0    -2   You Can't Put Your Arms Around A Memory
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[coolman78SLASH]

10  -2   Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
12        Down On The Farm
8          Human Being
14        Ain't It Fun
8   +1  Hair Of The Dog
4          Attitude
6          Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[COMAMOTIVE]

Johnny Thunders tune tossed and I don't care about you still going strong
Wowzers - I figured that mess would've been the first one out after Since I don't have you - which is also hanging tough

Crazy

[PermissionToLand]

Why would SIDHY go out early? That intro lead is beautiful. I'm amazed at the dislike for Buick Makane and Black Leather, they're the most similar to Guns' classic rock style of all the tracks.

10        Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
12        Down On The Farm
6  -2     Human Being
14        Ain't It Fun
8          Hair Of The Dog
4          Attitude
6   +1   Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[Bridge]

10        Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
12        Down On The Farm
4    -2   Human Being
15  +1  Ain't It Fun
8          Hair Of The Dog
4          Attitude
6          Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[Walapino]

10        Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
12        Down On The Farm
4          Human Being
15        Ain't It Fun
8          Hair Of The Dog
5    +1   Attitude
4     -2  Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[COMAMOTIVE]

Why would SIDHY go out early? That intro lead is beautiful. I'm amazed at the dislike for Buick Makane and Black Leather, they're the most similar to Guns' classic rock style of all the tracks.

Great - the intro is nice.
And that somehow makes it a good song or one that doesn't sound completely forced in and out of place compared with the other selections on this album?

Agree with you on Buick and Leather though

[PermissionToLand]

Why would SIDHY go out early? That intro lead is beautiful. I'm amazed at the dislike for Buick Makane and Black Leather, they're the most similar to Guns' classic rock style of all the tracks.

Great - the intro is nice
The rest a poppy bubblegum cover of a bad 60's song that sounds exactly like nothing on the rest of the album, yet was forced in as the first song
Just not for me is all

But I agree with you 100% on Buick and Leather

But if they are most similar to Guns classic rock sound as you stated, why are you so appalled that someone would suggest Since I don't have you should get the boot?

Well, because it's musically interesting. I actually like when they go outside their comfort zone usually. Some of Slash's best solo material were his ballads. But punk has never really interested me anyway. Too much simplistic strumming of chords, it's all way too similar. Classic Rock is somewhere in between; not proggy to the point of being boring, but also not super simple to the point of being boring. That's what I like about Guns; they add a lot of stuff into their songs to make them interesting, but also know when to stop.

[COMAMOTIVE]

Why would SIDHY go out early? That intro lead is beautiful. I'm amazed at the dislike for Buick Makane and Black Leather, they're the most similar to Guns' classic rock style of all the tracks.

Great - the intro is nice
The rest a poppy bubblegum cover of a bad 60's song that sounds exactly like nothing on the rest of the album, yet was forced in as the first song
Just not for me is all

But I agree with you 100% on Buick and Leather

But if they are most similar to Guns classic rock sound as you stated, why are you so appalled that someone would suggest Since I don't have you should get the boot?

Well, because it's musically interesting. I actually like when they go outside their comfort zone usually. Some of Slash's best solo material were his ballads. But punk has never really interested me anyway. Too much simplistic strumming of chords, it's all way too similar. Classic Rock is somewhere in between; not proggy to the point of being boring, but also not super simple to the point of being boring. That's what I like about Guns; they add a lot of stuff into their songs to make them interesting, but also know when to stop.

I hear ya
Just don't think it works as an overall song or has any place on an album like this.
To each their own.

Not a punk fan either - worst part of every concert they played Attitude in was when they played Attitude

[Spirit]

10        Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
12        Down On The Farm
4          Human Being
15        Ain't It Fun
6   -2    Hair Of The Dog
5          Attitude
5    +1  Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[Nytunz]

10        Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
13  +1 Down On The Farm
4          Human Being
15        Ain't It Fun
6          Hair Of The Dog
5          Attitude
3     -2  Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[dsaddler78]

10        Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
14  +1  Down On The Farm
4          Human Being
15        Ain't It Fun
4   -2    Hair Of The Dog
5          Attitude
3          Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[PermissionToLand]

10        Since I Don't Have You
8          New Rose
14        Down On The Farm
2   -2    Human Being
15        Ain't It Fun
4          Hair Of The Dog
5          Attitude
4  +1    Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[Muerto]

10        Since I Don't Have You
6     -2  New Rose
14        Down On The Farm
3    +1  Human Being
15        Ain't It Fun
4          Hair Of The Dog
5          Attitude
4          Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
9          Look At Your Game, Girl

[westcoast_junkie]

10        Since I Don't Have You
6          New Rose
14        Down On The Farm
3          Human Being
15        Ain't It Fun
4          Hair Of The Dog
5          Attitude
5 +1     Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
7 -2      Look At Your Game, Girl

[sakuL]

10        Since I Don't Have You
6          New Rose
14        Down On The Farm
4   +1   Human Being
15        Ain't It Fun
4          Hair Of The Dog
5          Attitude
3   -2    Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
7          Look At Your Game, Girl

[Steve McKagan]

11  +1 Since I Don't Have You
6          New Rose
14        Down On The Farm
4          Human Being
15        Ain't It Fun
4          Hair Of The Dog
3   - 2  Attitude
3          Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
7          Look At Your Game, Girl

[FreddieJames]

12 +1   Since I Don't Have You
6          New Rose
14        Down On The Farm
4          Human Being
15        Ain't It Fun
4          Hair Of The Dog
3          Attitude
1  -2     Black Leather
10        I Don't Care About You
7        Look At Your Game, Girl