Best songs *REMATCH* - Anyone interested?

[Spirit]

5 years ago we voted the best songs from each album, and got the results you can see below. These days, most of us are mostly isolated in our homes (unfortunately), and are looking for things to pass the time. Anyone interested in a rematch? Many new users have joined the forum since then. If the interest is there, I'll set up the threads.

A recap of the results:

FINAL RESULTS

Appetite For Destruction	GN'R Lies	Use Your Illusion I
1. Rocket Queen 2. Nightrain 3. It's So Easy 4. Welcome To The Jungle 5. Sweet Child O' Mine 6. Mr. Brownstone 7. Paradise City 8. Out Ta Get Me 9. Think About You 10. My Michelle 11. You're Crazy 12. Anything Goes	1. Patience 2. Used To Love Her 3. One In A Million 4. You're Crazy 5. Nice Boys 6. Move To The City 7. Mama Kin 8. Reckless Life	1. Coma 2. Don't Cry 3. November Rain 4. Don't Damn Me 5. Dead Horse 6. Double Talkin' Jive 7. Perfect Crime 8. Garden Of Eden 9. Dust N' Bones 10. Right Next Door To Hell 11. The Garden 12. Bad Obsession 13. You Ain't The First 14. Live And Let Die 15. Back Off Bitch 16. Bad Apples

Use Your Illusion II	"The Spaghetti Incident?"	Chinese Democracy
1. Estranged 2. Civil War 3. You Could Be Mine 4. Breakdown 5. Locomotive 6. Yesterdays 7. Pretty Tied Up 8. 14 Years 9. Get In The Ring 10. Knockin' On Heaven's Door 11. So Fine 12. Shotgun Blues 13. Don't Cry (Alt. lyrics) 14. My World	1. Ain't It Fun 2. Down On The Farm 3. Human Being 4. Attitude 5. Hair Of The Dog 6. New Rose 7. Black Leather 8. I Don't Care About You 9. Raw Power 10. Since I Don't Have You 11. You Can't Put Your Arms.. 12. Buick Makane (Big Dumb Sex) 13. Look At Your Game, Girl	1. There Was A Time 2. Better 3. Prostitute 4. Street Of Dreams 5. Madagascar 6. Catcher In The Rye 7. This I Love 8. Sorry 9. Chinese Democracy 10. Shackler's Revenge 11. If The World 12. I.R.S. 13. Riad N' The Bedouins 14. Scraped

[rizzo160]

Sounds good, something to do, thanks

[COMAMOTIVE]

Bring it

[Nytunz]

Ready!

[Steve McKagan]

After Chinese is done this time, it would be fun to make a "final" round with all winners from each album competing.

[COMAMOTIVE]

After Chinese is done this time, it would be fun to make a "final" round with all winners from each album competing.

Great idea

Maybe take top 3 from each album and let it roll

[Spirit]

Will do

[Spirit]

After Chinese is done this time, it would be fun to make a "final" round with all winners from each album competing.

Great idea

Maybe take top 3 from each album and let it roll

I'm thinking of maybe doing some sort of seeding.

First do a round of voting to rank the albums themselves, where the best two albums get 4 songs in the pot, the two next get 3, and the bottom two get 2.

An example:

AFD is voted #1: Nightrain, RQ, ISE and Paradise City will be included in the final voting list.

Lies is voted #5: Patience and You're Crazy will be included.



At the end, this will portray a more "real" best-of list at the end I think.

[AxlsMainMan]

You could also do a bonus round with the top 3 tracks from both UYI albums so we can see which UYI track truly is the greatest.

[Bridge]

You could also do a bonus round with the top 3 tracks from both UYI albums so we can see which UYI track truly is the greatest.

That's a great idea... and after we're done with all the albums, we could also do a "best of the best" round with the top 3 from ALL the albums so we could rank GNR's greatest songs overall.

[Nytunz]

Maybe we should do a "best lyrics" also... 

[dsaddler78]

You could also do a bonus round with the top 3 tracks from both UYI albums so we can see which UYI track truly is the greatest.

That's a great idea... and after we're done with all the albums, we could also do a "best of the best" round with the top 3 from ALL the albums so we could rank GNR's greatest songs overall.

I second this. would be cool as fuck to keep this thing going.