The yearly GN'R for the Super Bowl Halftime Show....

[johnreed3344]

Well apparently Jay-Z turned down the Super Bowl Halftime Show (thank God) So here we are again with "GNR should do it" I think it would be awesome? After November there is nothing planned right now it would be cool for them to play the show in Feb. then could launch another leg of touring or even a new CD! I don't believe the reports that this is it for Axl and GNR too much good things going on. What you think?

[Dr. Blutarsky]

Much deserved but not gonna happen. NFL is more interested in booking artists in the pop music genre the last few years for the halftime show. 

[Spirit]

If ever, this is the most realistic time. The popularity of the band has been through the roof these past two years.

Not that they really need it at this point, the exposure I mean.

[allwaystired]

Can't see any advantage to them doing it at all.

[Dr. Blutarsky]

Isn't the rule now that the performers need to lip sync the show? Want to say I heard that last year. 

[(t)]

Not on my wish list. I just don't think it's a cool event.

[Lord Stan]

Isn't the rule now that the performers need to lip sync the show? Want to say I heard that last year. 

What now.

[allwaystired]

Not on my wish list. I just don't think it's a cool event.

I just don't see any point in them doing it. A fifteen minute race through truncated versions of the hit benefits no one. They're above that level.

[izzyjim]

Let the yearly "Fuck no" festival begin..

[allwaystired]

Let the yearly "Fuck no" festival begin..

Can I start?

Fuck no

[D-GenerationX]

Will Slash and Duff be compelled to make any GNR commitments after December 31, 2017?

[sofine11]

Will Slash and Duff be compelled to make any GNR commitments after December 31, 2017?

That's the million dollar question isn't it?  Considering Axl's apparent apathy regarding new music  I'm not sure there's going to be much interest once the upcoming tour leg ends.

Also, even though the novelty of seeing Axl belt out AC/DC tunes has largely worn off, Angus buzzing around the shows over the summer likely bodes for...well...more of that in 2018. 

[D-GenerationX]

Will Slash and Duff be compelled to make any GNR commitments after December 31, 2017?

That's the million dollar question isn't it?  Considering Axl's apparent apathy regarding new music  I'm not sure there's going to be much interest once the upcoming tour leg ends.

I think they all go their separate ways in 2018.

Not on bad terms, and certainly not without at least some expectation they might do this all again.  But "this" is another tour.  Not new music.

Put another way, whatever Axl, Slash, or Duff do in 2018...my money is on none of the 3 of them doing anything Guns N' Roses related.

[allwaystired]

Will Slash and Duff be compelled to make any GNR commitments after December 31, 2017?

That's the million dollar question isn't it?  Considering Axl's apparent apathy regarding new music  I'm not sure there's going to be much interest once the upcoming tour leg ends.

Also, even though the novelty of seeing Axl belt out AC/DC tunes has largely worn off, Angus buzzing around the shows over the summer likely bodes for...well...more of that in 2018. 

Haha! it actually IS a 'million dollar question'  I imagine, given their earnings this year!

[Ginger King]

Will Slash and Duff be compelled to make any GNR commitments after December 31, 2017?

That's the million dollar question isn't it?  Considering Axl's apparent apathy regarding new music  I'm not sure there's going to be much interest once the upcoming tour leg ends.

Right...making a fuck ton of money becomes less of an incentive when you just made a fuck ton of money.  IMO, there needs to be something else to keep this group together.  The answer is staring us all in the face, and I think it just boils down to whether Axl wants to.

[allwaystired]

Will Slash and Duff be compelled to make any GNR commitments after December 31, 2017?

That's the million dollar question isn't it?  Considering Axl's apparent apathy regarding new music  I'm not sure there's going to be much interest once the upcoming tour leg ends.

I think they all go their separate ways in 2018.

Not on bad terms, and certainly not without at least some expectation they might do this all again.  But "this" is another tour.  Not new music.

Put another way, whatever Axl, Slash, or Duff do in 2018...my money is on none of the 3 of them doing anything Guns N' Roses related.

Absolutely. "See you in three years folks".

[sofine11]

Will Slash and Duff be compelled to make any GNR commitments after December 31, 2017?

That's the million dollar question isn't it?  Considering Axl's apparent apathy regarding new music  I'm not sure there's going to be much interest once the upcoming tour leg ends.

Right...making a fuck ton of money becomes less of an incentive when you just made a fuck ton of money.  IMO, there needs to be something else to keep this group together.  The answer is staring us all in the face, and I think it just boils down to whether Axl wants to.

Even a touring powerhouse like the Rolling Stones or Paul McCartney need to "rebrand" their touring machine in the form of a new album.  No idea why Axl is seemingly so adverse to this idea.

I'm of the mind that the situation regarding new music is likely a tangled web and a complete and utter mess.  Axl likely is emotionally attached to whatever else is "finished" from the Chi Dem eras.  But I'm sure those songs have 9,000 writing credits many of which involve members who aren't on great terms with Axl, i.e Chris Pitman and whoever else.  The only soundbites we have on the subject of new music is Axl saying he played some stuff for Slash & Duff last year and "they like it". Not sure the label would be crazy about putting that stuff out with input from Slash & Duff, nor do I think said members would be all that crazy about doing that.

I'm sure they'd opt for a more "organic" and completely new album once the touring ends this fall.  But boy, if that's the plan then it's the best kept secret since the Manhattan Project. I'm of the mind that, yes, they all go their separate ways in 2018, however unfortunate.

[D-GenerationX]

Axl is lazy.  Why do we dance around it?

Now, the kneejerk apologist will tell me how lazy people don't do 3 hour shows.  Yet that is :

- never what I said
- doesn't address the point of this topic
- a desperate attempt to change the subject

When it comes to creating and putting stuff out, Axl Rose is the laziest man in the business.  It was mentioned upthread about the Stones "rebranding" before a tour.  It's true.  But the last few times they did that, it was via literally 2-4 total songs.

And Axl can't be bothered.  Not because of that evil record company.  Not because the universe is against him.  Because he can't be bothered.

Just say what it is.  We are all grown ups here.  Allegedly.

[patcooper]

they would be forced to lip sync who in the hell would want this

[Ginger King]

Axl is lazy.  Why do we dance around it?

Now, the kneejerk apologist will tell me how lazy people don't do 3 hour shows.  Yet that is :

- never what I said
- doesn't address the point of this topic
- a desperate attempt to change the subject

When it comes to creating and putting stuff out, Axl Rose is the laziest man in the business.  It was mentioned upthread about the Stones "rebranding" before a tour.  It's true.  But the last few times they did that, it was via literally 2-4 total songs.

And Axl can't be bothered.  Not because of that evil record company.  Not because the universe is against him.  Because he can't be bothered.

Just say what it is.  We are all grown ups here.  Allegedly.

Truth is the truth hurts, don't you agree?

There really is no other feasible explanation...just excuses that somehow don't affect other bands (IMO).