Going to call it right now...

[dmathski]

Steven Adler will guest on songs Sat night at Coachella!  He's well enough to play M3 Rockfest next week. http://www.m3rockfest.com/  Confirmed by Adler!   https://www.facebook.com/adlermusic

[Bodhi]

Steven Adler will guest on songs Sat night at Coachella!  He's well enough to play M3 Rockfest next week. http://www.m3rockfest.com/  Confirmed by Adler!   https://www.facebook.com/adlermusic

That's assuming he was even asked to take part in the first place.  I don't see why he wouldn't play a song here and there,  but we also have no idea if he was even asked.  Put it this way, if Izzy was not asked I don't see why Steven would have been.

[Bridge]

Put it this way, if Izzy was not asked I don't see why Steven would have been.

Because Steven and Slash are closer than Izzy and Slash, and Slash knows Steven has been wanting this for ages.

And you said it yourself elsewhere, if Steven hadn't been asked, why would he be so quiet?

Gotta admit though, if it's true Izzy wasn't asked at all, I don't understand why.   

[Bodhi]

Put it this way, if Izzy was not asked I don't see why Steven would have been.

Because Steven and Slash are closer than Izzy and Slash, and Slash knows Steven has been wanting this for ages.

And you said it yourself elsewhere, if Steven hadn't been asked, why would he be so quiet?

Gotta admit though, if it's true Izzy wasn't asked at all, I don't understand why.   

Absolutely, his silence really makes me feel like he is going to be involved somehow in someway at some point. 

Back in 1991, Axl, Slash and Duff were the ones who carried on to become the biggest band in the world during the "Use Your Illusion" tour.  Izzy quit arguably when the band needed him most.  Steven essentially quit as well through his actions.  So essentially the only constant was  the big 3 through that whole run from 1987-1993.  I don't think there is any animosity towards Izzy as he has worked with all 3 a bunch of times over the years.  Really not sure why he wasn't asked other than they already have 2 guitar players.  I have never viewed this as a reunion, but as Slash and Duff rejoining the current band, because thats essentially what it is.  So maybe that's why Izzy wasn't asked?  I really don't know. 

Also didn't Axl say something along the lines of him not thinking Izzy and Steven could pull off the types of shows the band currently does on a nightly basis?  That wasn't his exact wording but I thought a few years back he only thought Slash and Duff would be able to do it.  I'll have to search for that interview.

[Thorned Rose]

I don't think it is really Slash and Duff joining the "current" lineup really.

Axl, Richard, Frank, Dizzy were the remaining ones right? So basically Slash and Duff join. I get that thinking and that's fine.

For me it is more less of Ashba, Stinson and Bumble all leaving withing a 1 year span. And in that span them doing nothing.

So I'll always think of it of Duff and Slash starting fresh with Axl. Cause so much time passed since Axl and Slash worked together. It doesn't really matter I guess but my mind set will always be a "regrouping" or "reunion" in some sense. If Slash and Axl had played a few shows together like Duff did, then this would very much be like Slash and Duff plugging in and going.

When you sit back and look at the ticket sales and great success of this thing so far, it is very obvious that Slash and Duff brough a lot to the band, and it isn't just them joining the "current Gn'R lineup"

and yes I hope to God Steven gets his thing going.

[Bodhi]

I don't think it is really Slash and Duff joining the "current" lineup really.

Axl, Richard, Frank, Dizzy were the remaining ones right? So basically Slash and Duff join. I get that thinking and that's fine.

For me it is more less of Ashba, Stinson and Bumble all leaving withing a 1 year span. And in that span them doing nothing.

So I'll always think of it of Duff and Slash starting fresh with Axl. Cause so much time passed since Axl and Slash worked together. It doesn't really matter I guess but my mind set will always be a "regrouping" or "reunion" in some sense. If Slash and Axl had played a few shows together like Duff did, then this would very much be like Slash and Duff plugging in and going.

When you sit back and look at the ticket sales and great success of this thing so far, it is very obvious that Slash and Duff brough a lot to the band, and it isn't just them joining the "current Gn'R lineup"

and yes I hope to God Steven gets his thing going.

I guess its all semantics, but Guns N Roses never stopped being a band since its inception.  So Slash and Duff rejoined the band they left.  A reunion is what happens when a band is defunct and they all get back together.  Like when people ask why Richard and Frank are still in the band, its because they have been in the band this entire time.  I believe Pittman would have been in there too if he didn't run his mouth like a putz.   But who cares, there are tons of threads  that cover this.

It will be interesting to see if Steven and Izzy play any part in any of this.  I think having them guest on a song here  and there is the most likely thing that is going to happen, I can't see them ever being full time members again.  I also don't think Steven can do it, I don't think he can do what Frank does for over 2 hours.  I also can't picture Izzy showing up night after night and doing what Richard does.  Slash and Duff are the only ones besides Axl from the classic line up to maintain a consistent touring schedule all of these years.

[Bridge]

Also didn't Axl say something along the lines of him not thinking Izzy and Steven could pull off the types of shows the band currently does on a nightly basis?  That wasn't his exact wording but I thought a few years back he only thought Slash and Duff would be able to do it.  I'll have to search for that interview.

http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/music_blog/2011/12/axl-rose-talks-playing-los-angeles-rock-hall-reunion.html

Because, really, you can get guys from the "Illusion" thing, but the only thing that would make it would be Duff and Slash, really. It?s nothing against Izzy and it?s nothing against Steven, or anything like that. Steven may want it, but these guys I?m working with right now, they work really hard and it?s hard work. I?ve toured with the other guys and I?ve also seen what they?ve done since, and I just know the difficulties.

[Paco1936]

That's assuming he was even asked to take part in the first place.  I don't see why he wouldn't play a song here and there,  but we also have no idea if he was even asked.  Put it this way, if Izzy was not asked I don't see why Steven would have been.
[/quote]

Why do you think Izzy wasn't asked?

He never said they didn't asked him.

He just said "At this point in time, I will not be playing at any of the April 2016 GNR shows."

So what makes you say that?

[Jay Tea]

Edit: I was wrong. I bet he did a great job. Congrats Steven. We all know how badly both you and the fans wanted to see this. So cool that this happened.

[NaturalLight]

Steven Adler will guest on songs Sat night at Coachella!  He's well enough to play M3 Rockfest next week. http://www.m3rockfest.com/  Confirmed by Adler!   https://www.facebook.com/adlermusic

Yeah, you called it alright.

I agree with the previous poster. He might show up at a show one day for a song. Maybe. A long time from now.