Why is Paul "Huge" Tobias considered an ex-member?

[CherryGarcia]

Didn't Axl say in some interview within the last five years that Paul still works with the band? And didn't Fortus confirm that? That while Paul isn't on stage, he does stuff in the studio and writing wise?

[EmilyGNR]

Who exactly is calling him an ex-member?

Did this honestly merit it's own topic? 

[CherryGarcia]

Who exactly is calling him an ex-member?

Did this honestly merit it's own topic? 

When I had made a thread regarding Paul in the past (about his band Mank Rage whose demos Axl himself produced), it was moved to the Ex-Members section. So I figured forum policy was to consider Paul an ex-member, and I was asking why. Are you all anger, all the time?

[EmilyGNR]

Who exactly is calling him an ex-member?

Did this honestly merit it's own topic? 

When I had made a thread regarding Paul in the past (about his band Mank Rage whose demos Axl himself produced), it was moved to the Ex-Members section. So I figured forum policy was to consider Paul an ex-member, and I was asking why. Are you all anger, all the time?

Once again, you aren't talented at discerning or deriving someone's mood from what they post, no psychic abilities there

I simply don't understand why this warranted it's own topic. If you had a question why your topic was moved, why not send a pm?

Guess that was too easy and didn't get you any attention.

[CherryGarcia]

Who exactly is calling him an ex-member?

Did this honestly merit it's own topic? 

When I had made a thread regarding Paul in the past (about his band Mank Rage whose demos Axl himself produced), it was moved to the Ex-Members section. So I figured forum policy was to consider Paul an ex-member, and I was asking why. Are you all anger, all the time?

Once again, you aren't talented at discerning or deriving someone's mood from what they post, no psychic abilities there

I simply don't understand why this warranted it's own topic. If you had a question why your topic was moved, why not send a pm?

Guess that was too easy and didn't get you any attention.

Okay, more like "all condescension, all the time". You cannot claim you aren't nasty and condescending; because you are.

It was a question. You, my dear sweet lady, are not a mod, despite your status as an untouchable, invincible poster "on the right side". If Jarmo wants to close this thread, he will.

[D-GenerationX]

I never really considered him a member.

3 total shows does not a full fledged member make.

[EmilyGNR]

Who exactly is calling him an ex-member?

Did this honestly merit it's own topic? 

When I had made a thread regarding Paul in the past (about his band Mank Rage whose demos Axl himself produced), it was moved to the Ex-Members section. So I figured forum policy was to consider Paul an ex-member, and I was asking why. Are you all anger, all the time?

Once again, you aren't talented at discerning or deriving someone's mood from what they post, no psychic abilities there

I simply don't understand why this warranted it's own topic. If you had a question why your topic was moved, why not send a pm?

Guess that was too easy and didn't get you any attention.

Okay, more like "all condescension, all the time". You cannot claim you aren't nasty and condescending; because you are.

It was a question. You, my dear sweet lady, are not a mod, despite your status as an untouchable, invincible poster "on the right side". If Jarmo wants to close this thread, he will.

Not your Dear, sweet anything troll, save your innane chatter for someone else.

Why not post this question in your original thread, was it this important?

Here's the link:

http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?topic=37216.140

[Princess Leia]

I never really considered him a member.

3 total shows does not a full fledged member make.

Exactly, nobody would call West Arkeen a member. Paul is or was a colaborator

[jarmo]

I wonder if the original poster hates GN'R.....



/jarmo

[adman2374]

I never really considered him a member.

3 total shows does not a full fledged member make.

It was only 2. HOB 01 Rio 01. Am I missing another gig???

[jarmo]

Aren't you both missing something?

Jan 1, 2001 - House of Blues, Las Vegas
Jan 15, 2000 - RIR3, Rio de Janeiro
Dec 29 & 31, 2001 - The Joint, Las Vegas

Richard joining was announced in July 2002.




/jarmo

[Sosso]

But Richard himself said that he joined the band in 2001.

[jarmo]

Explain to me how none of us knew he was in the band until July 2002, and then his first shows were the next month.

If he was in the band in 2001, wouldn't we have knows about it in 2002?



/jarmo

[Sosso]

I don't know. I was just wondering because Paul was still in the band too..

[D-GenerationX]

What exactly are we arguing here?

[jarmo]

What exactly are we arguing here?

No argument, you were wrong about something....

I don't know. I was just wondering because Paul was still in the band too..

Maybe Richard just got the years mixed up. Or he was in the band but didn't play shows until 2002.




/jarmo

[Sosso]

I never really considered him a member.

3 total shows does not a full fledged member make.

4 total shows. And he was one of the main songwriters on chinese democracy

[D-GenerationX]

What exactly are we arguing here?

No argument, you were wrong about something....

Oh, when I said he only played 3 shows, when actually...it was 4!!

GAME CHANGER

[jarmo]

I saw two people trying to get the fact straight...

Yeah, imagine that. You being wrong! In public! Oh the horror.



/jarmo

[D-GenerationX]

I saw two people trying to get the fact straight...

Yeah, imagine that. You being wrong! In public! Oh the horror.

And not just that! 

Not only to be wrong, but to be wrong about something so consequential, it changes the entire conversation.  Whole thing got stood right on its head.  4 shows, not 3.

Where's the egg?  Well, right on my face, obviously.