So is Tommy in or out (your opinions)?

[TheBaconman]

I would like the band to release a official poster of the current line up

I think there would be two guitars and one bass just laying there agaisnt the wall

When have they ever taken a picture of lone instruments as a band poster AND why would they release an official poster as long as the band is on hiatus and has not announced the lineup yet?

Makes.no.sense.

I know it doesn't make any sense...

Even though the band is on a hiatus, they have no problem selling merchandise..   

The business of Gun N Roses, does not stop or does ever go on a hiatus.   

Should they stop selling records during this hiatus?   Should they stop selling t-shirts?  Should they stop selling band posters??  Oh wait...

The question was very mythical.  I could of also asked...  If the current band was to appear on a late night talk show, who would appear?   

They are just what if questions.......

If you don't want to answer a what if question, there are plenty of other threads to prowl around in.....

If you do care to answer it.

If Guns was to put out a current Christmas card to all there loyal fans, with a team picture in it.   Who do you think would be in it?? 

Theoretically, if GNR were to put out a current Christmas card I think Santa would be on it.
 

Good.

At least it wouldn't be some safe, generic..

Happy Hollidays!!! 

Card

Its always.

Merry Christmas!

[reayj2003]

He's out. Duff is in, Slash is in & perhaps Richard, Frank, Dizzy & Chris. 2016 is on! 

[CherryGarcia]

He's out. Duff is in, Slash is in & perhaps Richard, Frank, Dizzy & Chris. 2016 is on! 

I honestly don't see a hybrid lineup happening. I can see Duff joining full time, yes. But I can't see Slash rejoining the band full time unless it was a full reunion (whether of the AFD or UYI lineups).

[TheSyxer]

He's out. Duff is in, Slash is in & perhaps Richard, Frank, Dizzy & Chris. 2016 is on! 

I honestly don't see a hybrid lineup happening. I can see Duff joining full time, yes. But I can't see Slash rejoining the band full time unless it was a full reunion (whether of the AFD or UYI lineups).

Things happen, regardless of you seeing it or not.

[OscarAxl22]

He's out. Duff is in, Slash is in & perhaps Richard, Frank, Dizzy & Chris. 2016 is on! 

I honestly don't see a hybrid lineup happening. I can see Duff joining full time, yes. But I can't see Slash rejoining the band full time unless it was a full reunion (whether of the AFD or UYI lineups).

Why dont you see a Hybrid lineup happening? I think its the bigger possibility out of all the scenarios at this point... but that's just going on rumor and innuendo.

I cant see an AFD line up touring... i could be wrong... but i really don't even see a set line up in the future... i could honestly see the lineups interchanging regularly with some past and current members playing separate shows. Just my opinion of course.

[D-GenerationX]

What do you think. Is he out of the band or in?

Long gone.

His words were not the words of a guy that was still in the mix.

[COMAMOTIVE]

He's done, but if a reunion tour goes down, he'll come out and jam a few tunes here and there. Guy's been a trooper the past decade and has my respect.

[Lucky]

if the old GNR reunites.... where do I sign up for the wait of the New GNR reunion?

[Spirit]

What do you think. Is he out of the band or in?

Long gone.

His words were not the words of a guy that was still in the mix.

But to be fair, none of the members seem to be "in the mix".. To me, it doesn't seem to be any information flow out to the current members, probably because there's no information to give.

The band is on hiatus, seems like they shut down completely after Vegas.


Hopefully they'll fire up again soon.

[norway]

 

if the old GNR reunites.... where do I sign up for the wait of the New GNR reunion?

I come and yell 'where's buckethead' with u.

[JAEBALL]

if the old GNR reunites.... where do I sign up for the wait of the New GNR reunion?

I come and yell 'where's buckethead' with u.

Hahaha... plus 1 . This made me laugh.

[D-GenerationX]

if the old GNR reunites.... where do I sign up for the wait of the New GNR reunion?

I come and yell 'where's buckethead' with u.

Hahahaha

In Axl's ass, I assume.

[Princess Leia]

if the old GNR reunites.... where do I sign up for the wait of the New GNR reunion?

I come and yell 'where's buckethead' with u.

Hahahaha

In Axl's ass, I assume.

 

Another question will be if you guys show up wearing a Buckethead shirt. Will Axl call Mr Security man to kick you out?

 

[D-GenerationX]

That guy...GONE!!

[Wooody]

New GNR reunion starts now? haha

Yeah, if Tommy isnt out, then Axl must've done something to keep him in. On those interviews he almost sounded bitter, or disappointed. '' Of course I'd have to think about it''? this sounds like someone who got cheated on by his girlfriend but he still loves her, but of course, he'd have to think about it?to forgive her

[Sosso]

Just because it's silent right now it doesn't mean that he is out of the band. He didn't left in the band in 2003 too for example?

[raindogs70]

In, sort of.

[HBK]

Tommy = Top Secret

 

[D-GenerationX]

Tommy was pretty clearly talking about the band in the past tense.  And was speaking in a very looking back reflectively manner.

That's why I think its a stretch to say he's still in the fold.

[jarmo]

Tommy was pretty clearly talking about the band in the past tense.  And was speaking in a very looking back reflectively manner.

That's why I think its a stretch to say he's still in the fold.

That's true.
But also, that could change with short notice if his services were needed. Don't you think?



/jarmo