So is Tommy in or out (your opinions)?

[CherryGarcia]

What do you think. Is he out of the band or in?

[Annie]

What do you think. Is he out of the band or in?

Mr Thumby thinks you like to stir up shit.

[norway]

equally as much as the others (besides dj and bumble)

[Jim Bob]

I think he is probably available if needed.   But things are quiet on the GNR front.

[draguns]

I say he's out and Duff is in.

[AHUGEAxlFan]

to me, it seems he's in it Axl wants him in. I'm 99% sure guns n roses isn't giving up with there current lineup so I'm sure he will be in. Whenever he gets a call I'm guessing.

[AHUGEAxlFan]

Wait... Who's Tommy... Isn't Mr Thumby on bass?

[JAEBALL]

This thread is amusing ...

But I'll play along ... I think there's zero chance he is the bass player going forward.

[dmathski]

Tommy is out and Duff in. Nice run Tommy. Hung with Axl for 15 years. 

[TheBaconman]

I would like the band to release a official poster of the current line up

I think there would be two guitars and one bass just laying there agaisnt the wall

[Spirit]

As it stands, I think there's a 50/50 chance of Tommy being on board. Depends on the merit of the reunion rumors.

Tommy himself seems to want to keep on going if Axl wants him to.

[Ginger King]

Question:  Who made the following statement?

"If they got [the modern lineup] together again and wanted me to play, of course I'd have to think about it."

Answer [spoiler alert]:  Tommy

Still unsure?  Ok, who made the following statement?

"Basically, I played my last gig in Las Vegas with them and had to come home and tend to that the best I could while the Replacements were kinda being offered up."

Answer [spoiler alert]:  Tommy

Tommy.  Is.  Out.

[Spirit]

If you say so.

[LIGuns]

Remember when people were shooting down the "rumor" that they be and members were advised to take on any outside endeavors...Still sound like a rumor? I'm hoping for some new/unreleased material more than anything...

[AHUGEAxlFan]

Eh shit. As much as I hate it, the chindem lineup is falling apart. No Tommy, no finck, no bucket, no Tobias, no brain, we are down to Frank, dizzy, Axl, Richard, and Chris. Looks like duff will be the new bass player with two new guitarist.


meh

[EmilyGNR]

I would like the band to release a official poster of the current line up

I think there would be two guitars and one bass just laying there agaisnt the wall

When have they ever taken a picture of lone instruments as a band poster AND why would they release an official poster as long as the band is on hiatus and has not announced the lineup yet?

Makes.no.sense.

[Virolec]

It all seems rather up in the air.  I think if for whatever reason some kind of reunion does not happen (it falls through in negotiations, it was never happening anyway, whatever) and Axl decides to carry on either touring or putting out the next album, then there's a reasonable chance Tommy will be called and asked to do it.  But I think it's more likely that if and when we ever see Guns N' Roses onstage again, Duff McKagen will be playing bass guitar. 

[sky dog]

Honestly, the whole thing is so fucked up that I don't believe anything anyone says anymore. All I know is there is no release date for an album and no tour dates scheduled. 

Jimmy doesn't like Gnr on "hiatus".

[TheBaconman]

I would like the band to release a official poster of the current line up

I think there would be two guitars and one bass just laying there agaisnt the wall

When have they ever taken a picture of lone instruments as a band poster AND why would they release an official poster as long as the band is on hiatus and has not announced the lineup yet?

Makes.no.sense.

I know it doesn't make any sense...

Even though the band is on a hiatus, they have no problem selling merchandise..   

The business of Gun N Roses, does not stop or does ever go on a hiatus.   

Should they stop selling records during this hiatus?   Should they stop selling t-shirts?  Should they stop selling band posters??  Oh wait...

The question was very mythical.  I could of also asked...  If the current band was to appear on a late night talk show, who would appear?   

They are just what if questions.......

If you don't want to answer a what if question, there are plenty of other threads to prowl around in.....

If you do care to answer it.

If Guns was to put out a current Christmas card to all there loyal fans, with a team picture in it.   Who do you think would be in it?? 

[EmilyGNR]

I would like the band to release a official poster of the current line up

I think there would be two guitars and one bass just laying there agaisnt the wall

When have they ever taken a picture of lone instruments as a band poster AND why would they release an official poster as long as the band is on hiatus and has not announced the lineup yet?

Makes.no.sense.

I know it doesn't make any sense...

Even though the band is on a hiatus, they have no problem selling merchandise..   

The business of Gun N Roses, does not stop or does ever go on a hiatus.   

Should they stop selling records during this hiatus?   Should they stop selling t-shirts?  Should they stop selling band posters??  Oh wait...

The question was very mythical.  I could of also asked...  If the current band was to appear on a late night talk show, who would appear?   

They are just what if questions.......

If you don't want to answer a what if question, there are plenty of other threads to prowl around in.....

If you do care to answer it.

If Guns was to put out a current Christmas card to all there loyal fans, with a team picture in it.   Who do you think would be in it?? 

Theoretically, if GNR were to put out a current Christmas card I think Santa would be on it.