Eddie Trunk: "By all accounts, there's definitely stuff in motion"

[Annie]

To carmiedisco12.
Yes the dark side of fame. That is what I have been trying to shine a light on. When you are a celebrity who started out with nothing it is almost impossible to know who your true friends are. Fame is the biggest commodity in our society right now.
The band has hardly been in a creative void. Chinese Democracy is a great CD with a lot of great songs.
I have many great memories of seeing a lot of concerts with hearing those songs performed live.

[carmiedisco12]

Ok a fair reply. I do remain concerned at some of your comments and actions . They appear less than balanced.
That aside we clearly are defining creative 'void' differently. However surely you must admit post original band GNR has been anything but productive in a creative and artistic sense. One album in how many decades now? Yes a lot of great shows but tribute acts do that all the time. Creative means ....well, creating.

[GNR2014]

I would say that tracking a stranger down at their place of work and leaving a note that reads:
"What you are doing is wrong! You are a douche"
Constitutes harassment and stalking and make you look creepy.

[Annie]

Ok a fair reply. I do remain concerned at some of your comments and actions . They appear less than balanced.
That aside we clearly are defining creative 'void' differently. However surely you must admit post original band GNR has been anything but productive in a creative and artistic sense. One album in how many decades now? Yes a lot of great shows but tribute acts do that all the time. Creative means ....well, creating.

I am an intense person but I am not a threat to anybody. I prevented a major race riot on the CTA last year by having the courage to stare somebody down with a look that said I WILL TESTIFY against you if all hell breaks loose. He got off the train. the CEO of our hospital thanked me.
I think there is a lot of music that will be released in the future when the time is right.

[Annie]

I would say that tracking a stranger down at their place of work and leaving a note that reads:
"What you are doing is wrong! You are a douche"
Constitutes harassment and stalking and make you look creepy.

Actually just being a smartass like TED!!!

[D-GenerationX]

Canter seems completely delusional, but tracking him down to return that book with your little zinger of a note is straight up creepy stalker behavior.

Put whatever spin on it you like.  You look like a lunatic, pulling that move.

[Annie]

Canter seems completely delusional, but tracking him down to return that book with your little zinger of a note is straight up creepy stalker behavior.

Put whatever spin on it you like.  You look like a lunatic, pulling that move.

You are entitled to your opinion. I was in LA for a VIP event and I thought it would be funny to stop by and drop off the book. Canter had made a challenge that anybody unhappy with his book could return it.

[jarmo]

I love lamp.




/jarmo

[JAEBALL]

Canter seems completely delusional, but tracking him down to return that book with your little zinger of a note is straight up creepy stalker behavior.

Put whatever spin on it you like.  You look like a lunatic, pulling that move.

lol

No matter what you think of the guy...

He produced a great book.

[EmilyGNR]

Of course nothing's for certain until Axl confirms it.

It's silly season and it's fun to speculate in rumors I think. As long as people take it for what it is, and just roll with it. If you take every rumor as fact you're setting yourself up for a lot of disappointments... But we already know that, right? Haha

I prefer facts rather than endless speculation. I dont see the fun in it to be honest.

My mindset exactly, I don't get the fascination with rumors and heresay.   

Only one thing to talk about the past year then. Dj leaving.

Emily just peddles that same old tired line about waiting for official announcements to sound superior, the fact is, this rarely happens. One announcement every five years keeps her happy but if that's all we ever discussed this board would be a ghost town!

Wrong again, I've already told you that interpreting things off the internet is not your forte', keep your day job troll.

There is nothing wrong with preferring official, actual news over a bunch of asanine speculations and rumors.

The only thing asanine is you.
Perhaps you could do us all a favour and only comment when we get an official announcement then? Rather than give us your tired repeated "oh I don't like asanine unfounded gossip" crap???
Yet here you are... Day in, day out repeating yourself.
It's a little bit silly Emily.
Jussayin

Only thing silly, and asanine is you here on a fan forum attempting to dictate how I behave and obsessing about me you sick troll.

I don't care what you think and I will not amend my behavior to appease "fans" like you, ever.

There is nothing wrong with dismissing unfounded gossip and preferring actual facts and reality.
I'm actually a supportive fan, I know that's an alien concept to you-

Don't make me start reporting you again for harassment and personal attacks.

Ahh the old... " oh iim gonna cry in my room and report you"... gotta love how you play that card everytime you get called out for your behavior on here. 

Harassment and personal attacks? Stop being so melodramatic. Its a forum... are you really that sensitive? If so.. you may need a teaspoon of cement. 

Go obsess about someone else troll.

I'm here to discuss and read about GNR, not the idiocy posted by some frustrated idiot.

Like Jarmo suggested on the last page, take the personal attacks elsewhere, this has nothing to do with the topic.

Please respect that this is first and foremost a GNR fan forum for actual fans of GNR, anything to add on topic?

[EmilyGNR]

Ok a fair reply. I do remain concerned at some of your comments and actions . They appear less than balanced.
That aside we clearly are defining creative 'void' differently. However surely you must admit post original band GNR has been anything but productive in a creative and artistic sense. One album in how many decades now? Yes a lot of great shows but tribute acts do that all the time. Creative means ....well, creating.

GNR has performed countless shows, 2 residencies and released a live DVD just last year- You have no way of knowing what has been written, recorded, worked on, or created -

I'm going to enjoy gloating when the next album is released, and attending shows at the next round of touring. 

[JAEBALL]

Ok a fair reply. I do remain concerned at some of your comments and actions . They appear less than balanced.
That aside we clearly are defining creative 'void' differently. However surely you must admit post original band GNR has been anything but productive in a creative and artistic sense. One album in how many decades now? Yes a lot of great shows but tribute acts do that all the time. Creative means ....well, creating.

GNR has performed countless shows, 2 residencies and released a live DVD just last year- You have no way of knowing what has been written, recorded, worked on, or created -

I'm going to enjoy gloating when the next album is released, and attending shows at the next round of touring. 

I think 99.9 percent of us believe at some point in time there will be another album, so I don't know what good the gloating will do or the point of it.

Some of us just think it's a little silly that if the album comes out tomorrow that it will be close to two decades since those songs were started on.. you're not one of them... that's cool.

[dmathski]

Ok a fair reply. I do remain concerned at some of your comments and actions . They appear less than balanced.
That aside we clearly are defining creative 'void' differently. However surely you must admit post original band GNR has been anything but productive in a creative and artistic sense. One album in how many decades now? Yes a lot of great shows but tribute acts do that all the time. Creative means ....well, creating.

GNR has performed countless shows, 2 residencies and released a live DVD just last year- You have no way of knowing what has been written, recorded, worked on, or created -

I'm going to enjoy gloating when the next album is released, and attending shows at the next round of touring. 

I think 99.9 percent of us believe at some point in time there will be another album, so I don't know what good the gloating will do or the point of it.

Some of us just think it's a little silly that if the album comes out tomorrow that it will be close to two decades since those songs were started on.. you're not one of them... that's cool.

NU GNR is dead. Dead to me at least.  It's all about the reunion now.  I feel all these songs that were recorded years ago by guys no longer in the old new band will never see the light of day.

[EmilyGNR]

Ok a fair reply. I do remain concerned at some of your comments and actions . They appear less than balanced.
That aside we clearly are defining creative 'void' differently. However surely you must admit post original band GNR has been anything but productive in a creative and artistic sense. One album in how many decades now? Yes a lot of great shows but tribute acts do that all the time. Creative means ....well, creating.

GNR has performed countless shows, 2 residencies and released a live DVD just last year- You have no way of knowing what has been written, recorded, worked on, or created -

I'm going to enjoy gloating when the next album is released, and attending shows at the next round of touring. 

I think 99.9 percent of us believe at some point in time there will be another album, so I don't know what good the gloating will do or the point of it.

Some of us just think it's a little silly that if the album comes out tomorrow that it will be close to two decades since those songs were started on.. you're not one of them... that's cool.

Why is it supposedly silly? There exists no set schedule of when Artists release albums.

Don't forget GNR had a release last year of the Live DVD Appetite 4 Democracy.

[JAEBALL]

Ok a fair reply. I do remain concerned at some of your comments and actions . They appear less than balanced.
That aside we clearly are defining creative 'void' differently. However surely you must admit post original band GNR has been anything but productive in a creative and artistic sense. One album in how many decades now? Yes a lot of great shows but tribute acts do that all the time. Creative means ....well, creating.

GNR has performed countless shows, 2 residencies and released a live DVD just last year- You have no way of knowing what has been written, recorded, worked on, or created -

I'm going to enjoy gloating when the next album is released, and attending shows at the next round of touring. 

I think 99.9 percent of us believe at some point in time there will be another album, so I don't know what good the gloating will do or the point of it.

Some of us just think it's a little silly that if the album comes out tomorrow that it will be close to two decades since those songs were started on.. you're not one of them... that's cool.

NU GNR is dead. Dead to me at least.  It's all about the reunion now.  I feel all these songs that were recorded years ago by guys no longer in the old new band will never see the light of day.

Well I don't care for the term NU GNR... well...the name issue is something I don't care for in any way. People on both ends of that fight are ridiculous...it's a band name.

But as of today... there is no band... there's Axl Rose and his right to the GNR name... so whoever he decides he plays with next time he performs... that'll be GNR.

I just hope to hear those songs sooner than later... AND... I also hope for a reunion with Slash Duff and Izzy.

[JAEBALL]

Ok a fair reply. I do remain concerned at some of your comments and actions . They appear less than balanced.
That aside we clearly are defining creative 'void' differently. However surely you must admit post original band GNR has been anything but productive in a creative and artistic sense. One album in how many decades now? Yes a lot of great shows but tribute acts do that all the time. Creative means ....well, creating.

GNR has performed countless shows, 2 residencies and released a live DVD just last year- You have no way of knowing what has been written, recorded, worked on, or created -

I'm going to enjoy gloating when the next album is released, and attending shows at the next round of touring. 

I think 99.9 percent of us believe at some point in time there will be another album, so I don't know what good the gloating will do or the point of it.

Some of us just think it's a little silly that if the album comes out tomorrow that it will be close to two decades since those songs were started on.. you're not one of them... that's cool.

Why is it supposedly silly? There exists no set schedule of when Artists release albums.

Don't forget GNR had a release last year of the Live DVD Appetite 4 Democracy.

Yeah ... no schedules... I've heard that one before : )

I didn't forget... I bought a copy.

[EmilyGNR]

Ok a fair reply. I do remain concerned at some of your comments and actions . They appear less than balanced.
That aside we clearly are defining creative 'void' differently. However surely you must admit post original band GNR has been anything but productive in a creative and artistic sense. One album in how many decades now? Yes a lot of great shows but tribute acts do that all the time. Creative means ....well, creating.

GNR has performed countless shows, 2 residencies and released a live DVD just last year- You have no way of knowing what has been written, recorded, worked on, or created -

I'm going to enjoy gloating when the next album is released, and attending shows at the next round of touring. 

I think 99.9 percent of us believe at some point in time there will be another album, so I don't know what good the gloating will do or the point of it.

Some of us just think it's a little silly that if the album comes out tomorrow that it will be close to two decades since those songs were started on.. you're not one of them... that's cool.

NU GNR is dead. Dead to me at least.  It's all about the reunion now.  I feel all these songs that were recorded years ago by guys no longer in the old new band will never see the light of day.

The band is on Hiatus, Fernando said there would be an announcement in a few months- were you not aware of that?

[JAEBALL]

BTW Emily

I was scrolling thru the GNR instagram this morning and I came across a picture of Duff in SA... and it said big thanks to ORIGINAL gunner Duff Mckagan!

I immediately thought of you 

Please tell them Duff is not the original bass player!

[dmathski]

Ok a fair reply. I do remain concerned at some of your comments and actions . They appear less than balanced.
That aside we clearly are defining creative 'void' differently. However surely you must admit post original band GNR has been anything but productive in a creative and artistic sense. One album in how many decades now? Yes a lot of great shows but tribute acts do that all the time. Creative means ....well, creating.

GNR has performed countless shows, 2 residencies and released a live DVD just last year- You have no way of knowing what has been written, recorded, worked on, or created -

I'm going to enjoy gloating when the next album is released, and attending shows at the next round of touring. 

I think 99.9 percent of us believe at some point in time there will be another album, so I don't know what good the gloating will do or the point of it.

Some of us just think it's a little silly that if the album comes out tomorrow that it will be close to two decades since those songs were started on.. you're not one of them... that's cool.

NU GNR is dead. Dead to me at least.  It's all about the reunion now.  I feel all these songs that were recorded years ago by guys no longer in the old new band will never see the light of day.

The band is on Hiatus, Fernando said there would be an announcement in a few months- were you not aware of that?

That means to me. Axl is on hiatus now and they'll be an announcement soon. Who is in this "band"

[EmilyGNR]

BTW Emily

I was scrolling thru the GNR instagram this morning and I came across a picture of Duff in SA... and it said big thanks to ORIGINAL gunner Duff Mckagan!

I immediately thought of you 

Please tell them Duff is not the original bass player!

Everyone knows the difference and the actual history, it is a very stupid non-argument that seems to upset little misguided fanboys like you that insist on regurgitating it time and time again.