Guitarists That Could Replace Dj

[Rainfox]

Robin, to me, is the biggest player for me apart from Axl in regards to New Guns. His writing and musicon the album, and his live perfomances... amazing.

Bucket as well, but I have no illusions. He's vague in terms of touring and band commitments. His work on Chinese stands forever though.

I would settle for Robin. That would be outtathisworld.

[sofine11]

Robin, to me, is the biggest player for me apart from Axl in regards to New Guns. His writing and musicon the album, and his live perfomances... amazing.

Bucket as well, but I have no illusions. He's vague in terms of touring and band commitments. His work on Chinese stands forever though.

I would settle for Robin. That would be outtathisworld.

Robin and Bucket's guitars defined Chinese, and likely the bulk of the next album. If either of them came back in the wake of the recent departures, it would be a huge win for the band.

[Spirit]

How do you think the sound of GNR will be with Richard and Robin as the only guitarists? Would it work?

They have to re-structure some of the Chinese songs live since there's so much going on in parts, but it would be cool with a 2 guitar line-up. You would loose a bit of the "crazy" solos, but I think Richard could handle some of it.

[sofine11]

How do you think the sound of GNR will be with Richard and Robin as the only guitarists? Would it work?

They have to re-structure some of the Chinese songs live since there's so much going on in parts, but it would be cool with a 2 guitar line-up. You would loose a bit of the "crazy" solos, but I think Richard could handle some of it.

According to Ron, Richard and Robin were set to be a duo in 2006 before Ron was brought in by Axl and Merck last minute, which, according to him, sparked some of the awkwardness that lingered during his tenure in the band.  So, yes, I'm sure if Robin's willing they'd be down for it.

[deadtotheworld]

Id like to see Bucket and Robin but if it was somebody new, this guy could do it....

http://youtu.be/gXmQXR-KYTE

[Sosso]

I would like to see Robin to replace Dj and Dave Navarro to replace Bumblefoot (I agree that a return of Buckethead is pretty impossible)

[LIGuns]

Actually a pretty good and believable list....I would like to add Chrid Broderick former,y of Megadeth....,

[GnR-NOW]

I would really prefer Robin. I mean he was the guy that replaced Slash. He played the materiel with his own sound which I always thought was so unique from other guitarists.

[Spirit]

Trent is tinkering with a new album. Depends on what the situation is there right now.

If both NIN and GNR are ready to go at the same time, and they both want Robin... who will he choose?

[nick6sic6]

Robin and maybe Paul Huge.
I never really liked Buckethead and imo DJ was perfect for Guns.Only Robin could replace Ashba.

[Spirit]

Personally I think Robin and Richard fits well together.

[Sosso]

Personally I think Robin and Richard fits well together.

Better then Robin with Bumblefoot

[Spirit]

Probably not legit, but there's a rumor going around that Robin is returning to GNR.

Not sure about the exact source, but I think the rumor originates from the Brazilian fan community.

[TheBaconman]

If the plan is to release a album of older material written by bucket and Robin.   Then tour with this material and other old material.  I would say the best bet would make every effort possible to try and get Robin and bucket back

[axlvai]

   /

[Spirit]

This is how I would set the odds:


Slash   100-1
Buckethead   100-1
Zakk Wylde   50-1
Izzy   30-1
Paul Tobias   30-1
Duff   20-1
Dave Navarro   20-1
John 5   10-1
Robin Finck   4-1

[C0ma]

This is how I would set the odds:


Slash   100-1
Buckethead   100-1
Zakk Wylde   50-1
Izzy   30-1
Paul Tobias   30-1
Duff   20-1
Dave Navarro   20-1
John 5   10-1
Robin Finck   4-1

While I certainly wouldn't mind seeing it, I just don't understand the confidence some people have in a guitar player that has quit the band twice coming back.

[Spirit]

Well, I say there's a 80% chance of him not coming back so I wouldn't say I'm confident of him returning.

I'm just saying, of the people who've had some sort of connection with GNR previously, I think the one most likely to return is Robin. There's probably a bigger chance of someone new coming in.

[sofine11]

Well, I say there's a 80% chance of him not coming back so I wouldn't say I'm confident of him returning.

I'm just saying, of the people who've had some sort of connection with GNR previously, I think the one most likely to return is Robin. There's probably a bigger chance of someone new coming in.

What a shame, if Robin doesn't return.  His chemistry with Axl & Richard was/is amazing.

[faldor]

Well, I say there's a 80% chance of him not coming back so I wouldn't say I'm confident of him returning.

I'm just saying, of the people who've had some sort of connection with GNR previously, I think the one most likely to return is Robin. There's probably a bigger chance of someone new coming in.

He did return once, so why not again? I know plenty of couples who break up and get back together countless times. Obviously not an equal comparison, but it could happen.