In a perfect world, what would the ideal situation be?

[Ow-So7411501]

What would the Ideal situation for GNR be going forward?

A. Release CD2
B. Scrap it and start over with the new band.
C. Go on tour.
D. Reunion

Personally I'd like to see them scrap whatever they had and try to make new music with the current band.

I would only welcome a reunion if it led to new music.

Axl Rose has always been one of my favorite lyricists. It's time for us to hear some new Inspired material from one of the all time greats/

[mortismurphy]

What would the Ideal situation for GNR be going forward?

A. Release CD2
B. Scrap it and start over with the new band.
C. Go on tour.
D. Reunion

Personally I'd like to see them scrap whatever they had and try to make new music with the current band.

I would only welcome a reunion if it led to new music.

Axl Rose has always been one of my favorite lyricists. It's time for us to hear some new Inspired material from one of the all time greats/

A, B, D, C.

If they are not going to do A or B and release new material then the old guys may as well reunite. Another new band tour would be the worst possible course of action.

Whoops, I just noticed that you mentioned 'new music' with the reunion. Well that changes everything,

D, A, B, C

[rebelhipi]

Anything Exept D

[Ow-So7411501]

Anything Exept D

Really? Even if a reunion led to new music?

[EmilyGNR]

In a perfect world fans would realize that GNR doesn't need or require any armchair quarterbacks. 

[GNR2014]

D, then C, then A, then B.

[rebelhipi]

Anything Exept D

Really? Even if a reunion led to new music?

Id rather hear new music from the current GNR than 80s GNR.

 By all means 80s GNR was great while it lasted, obviously it didnt work out.
Plus i have a hard time believing that a reunion wouldnt be done just for the money. If i would want to see a band sell out i would go see Van Halen. Or some other band.

[draguns]

I would say D, B, A, C. 

[D-GenerationX]

What would the Ideal situation for GNR be going forward?

A. Release CD2
B. Scrap it and start over with the new band.
C. Go on tour.
D. Reunion

D, B, A, C

Option C is not moving the least bit forward.  If they aren't going to move forward, than give me the real band and Option D. 

I would love Option B and think its makes the most sense.  Also know its never going to happen.  So if you are interested in seeing Axl move forward, you will have to make due with Option A.  Which is fine with me.  Its the best we're going to do.

What do I think actually will happen?  Option C.  Coupled with the same vague talk about still trying to get a handle on how to best tackle this amazing material locked up in Fort Knox.

[suicide]

D, B, A, C

[italian queen]

REUNION, NEW MUSIC, WORLD TOUR

[AdZ]

If this just becomes another dull reunion thread, I'm going to move it to Dead Horse.

[Ow-So7411501]

In a perfect world fans would realize that GNR doesn't need or require any armchair quarterbacks. 

Don't see how this topic qualifies as an armchair quarterback. Care to explain?

Maybe you can start your own thread about how great everything seems to be going right now.

[Ow-So7411501]

Anything Exept D

Really? Even if a reunion led to new music?

Id rather hear new music from the current GNR than 80s GNR.

 By all means 80s GNR was great while it lasted, obviously it didnt work out.
Plus i have a hard time believing that a reunion wouldnt be done just for the money. If i would want to see a band sell out i would go see Van Halen. Or some other band.

Have never really gotten the whole cash grab argument. Of course it's going to be a cash grab. People don't do this for free. Plus the originals worked so hard (literally from the bottom up) to establish the brand. Why shouldnt they enjoy the fruits of there labor?

[Ow-So7411501]

If this just becomes another dull reunion thread, I'm going to move it to Dead Horse.

Not what I had in mind when I created the thread. Not much going on in the GNR world...just wanted to see what the popular choices would be.

[D-GenerationX]

If this just becomes another dull reunion thread, I'm going to move it to Dead Horse.

3 of the 4 options are for the new band.

[D-GenerationX]

In a perfect world fans would realize that GNR doesn't need or require any armchair quarterbacks. 

Don't see how this topic qualifies as an armchair quarterback. Care to explain?

Maybe you can start your own thread about how great everything seems to be going right now.

She always says that sort of thing though.  You are just supposed to sit quietly in the corner. 

And any discussion, not matter how benign, is both an insult to the band as well as your proclamation that you should be running the band because you know everything about everything.

[D-GenerationX]

Have never really gotten the whole cash grab argument. Of course it's going to be a cash grab. People don't do this for free. Plus the originals worked so hard (literally from the bottom up) to establish the brand. Why shouldnt they enjoy the fruits of there labor?

Same here.

All tours for any band are "cash grabs".  That's pretty much the job.

[D-GenerationX]

If this just becomes another dull reunion thread, I'm going to move it to Dead Horse.

Not what I had in mind when I created the thread. Not much going on in the GNR world...just wanted to see what the popular choices would be.

Agreed.

If there was something more relevant or current, we'd be talking about that.  It's our fault nothing is happening on those fronts?

Nah, sorry.

[Ow-So7411501]

In a perfect world fans would realize that GNR doesn't need or require any armchair quarterbacks. 

Don't see how this topic qualifies as an armchair quarterback. Care to explain?

Maybe you can start your own thread about how great everything seems to be going right now.

She always says that sort of thing though.  You are just supposed to sit quietly in the corner. 

And any discussion, not matter how benign, is both an insult to the band as well as your proclamation that you should be running the band because you know everything about everything.

Playing armchair quarterback would imply that I am trying to tell or suggest what the band does next. All I was doing with this thread was asking a simple multiple choice question.