What's your feeling on the next live performance?

[JAEBALL]

Why do you think Bucket would be back after he's been gone for over a decade?




/jarmo

Oh I don't ... I think Saul is more plausible than him.

[D-GenerationX]

Why do you think Bucket would be back after he's been gone for over a decade?

Oh, NEVER gonna happen.  I see no plausible scenario.

[D-GenerationX]

Oh I don't ... I think Saul is more plausible than him.

Haha, yeah, so do I.

[Spirit]

Who is in the touring band really doesn't interest me much...I personally hope Duff is the bass player.. but that's about it.

Just hypothetically, if say Buckethead was back it wouldn't interest you?

Yes but only because I assume he created a lot of the guitar parts that will be featured on the next record. So yeah of course I'd always prefer to see the person responsible for the song on stage. However I can't say I have ever been a fan of Bucket's whole package.

So if Ron is gone.. he'd be my first choice to step back in to that role for that reason.

I was just wondering if it didn't matter to you at all, or if it means something to you.

So, you do care a little bit?  

[D-GenerationX]

I was just wondering if it didn't matter to you at all, or if it means something to you.

So, you do care a little bit?  

Lawyered!

I figure it will be some other guy I never heard of.  I didn't know Ron from a hole in the wall when he joined.  Hell, I never knew anything about the guy he replaced either.

[Spirit]

Why do you think Bucket would be back after he's been gone for over a decade?




/jarmo

I don't think anyone think that'll happen. I only brought it in as a hypothetical example.

[D-GenerationX]

I got an iPod manual with your name on it, it explains the repeat feature so you don't need to put the same songs X times in a playlist to play the same song over and over. 

Hahaha.  See, now this is funny.

I truly thought the repeat was for the whole playlist.

[jarmo]

Great success! You learned something new.

I don't think anyone think that'll happen. I only brought it in as a hypothetical example.

Hypothetical discussions can be fun.



/jarmo

[JAEBALL]

Who is in the touring band really doesn't interest me much...I personally hope Duff is the bass player.. but that's about it.

Just hypothetically, if say Buckethead was back it wouldn't interest you?

Yes but only because I assume he created a lot of the guitar parts that will be featured on the next record. So yeah of course I'd always prefer to see the person responsible for the song on stage. However I can't say I have ever been a fan of Bucket's whole package.

So if Ron is gone.. he'd be my first choice to step back in to that role for that reason.

I was just wondering if it didn't matter to you at all, or if it means something to you.

So, you do care a little bit?  

Ha yes I do prefer somebody who was involved with GNR in the past over another completely new guy.

[D-GenerationX]

Ha yes I do prefer somebody who was involved with GNR in the past over another completely new guy.

Yeah, but everybody that leaves seems to burn the boats.

[TheBaconman]

Ha yes I do prefer somebody who was involved with GNR in the past over another completely new guy.

Yeah, but everybody that leaves seems to burn the boats.

The amount of ex players that have come back to play shows greatly out weighs that of the ones that have never.

Who hasn't come back.  Slash, Bucket and Steven.   I will count Axl singing with Gilby in LA as a show

[DeN]

you forgot Brain, I think

[rebelhipi]

Ha yes I do prefer somebody who was involved with GNR in the past over another completely new guy.

Yeah, but everybody that leaves seems to burn the boats.

The amount of ex players that have come back to play shows greatly out weighs that of the ones that have never.

Who hasn't come back.  Slash, Bucket and Steven.   I will count Axl singing with Gilby in LA as a show

Matt, Josh, Paul (maybe in the studio).

Brain did play bongos at one gnr show in 2012.

[Ow-So7411501]

I remember being at the Hammerstein shows in 06 and the anticipation in the air before they finally came out. Great show, great atmosphere. Band sounded tight. Axl was definitely on fire that night.
I dont think it would be the same type of anticipation in 2015. Unless it was a reunion. ( This from a guy who hasnt been calling for one)

[D-GenerationX]

Ha yes I do prefer somebody who was involved with GNR in the past over another completely new guy.

Yeah, but everybody that leaves seems to burn the boats.

The amount of ex players that have come back to play shows greatly out weighs that of the ones that have never.

Who hasn't come back.  Slash, Bucket and Steven.   I will count Axl singing with Gilby in LA as a show

Yeah, but those are one offs.  I'm talking as a full time guy on a tour.

Bucket and Robin helped create this material and want nothing to do with it. 

[Ow-So7411501]

Ha yes I do prefer somebody who was involved with GNR in the past over another completely new guy.

Yeah, but everybody that leaves seems to burn the boats.

The amount of ex players that have come back to play shows greatly out weighs that of the ones that have never.

Who hasn't come back.  Slash, Bucket and Steven.   I will count Axl singing with Gilby in LA as a show

Yeah, but those are one offs.  I'm talking as a full time guy on a tour.

Bucket and Robin helped create this material and want nothing to do with it. 

Would you? Unless your in it for the money or for the exposure that it provides in order to market other ventures. I think that whoever is in this band will always have to deal with the burden of being in one of the most legendary bands of all time.

[D-GenerationX]

Would you? Unless your in it for the money or for the exposure that it provides in order to market other ventures. I think that whoever is in this band will always have to deal with the burden of being in one of the most legendary bands of all time.

Bucket got wise pretty quick. 

But I don't get Robin.  He eventually arrived at the same conclusion Bucket did, but not before staying on for 6 more years.

[jarmo]

Yeah, but those are one offs.  I'm talking as a full time guy on a tour.

Bucket and Robin helped create this material and want nothing to do with it. 

If you want nothing to do with the material, you'd assume guesting on a song you wrote at a show would be out of the question? Yet, that's what Robin did.

There's a difference between making assumptions and stating exaggerations as facts.



/jarmo

[D-GenerationX]

Yeah, but those are one offs.  I'm talking as a full time guy on a tour.

Bucket and Robin helped create this material and want nothing to do with it. 

If you want nothing to do with the material, you'd assume guesting on a song you wrote at a show would be out of the question? Yet, that's what Robin did.

Oh, you mean like a one off?  I guess I should have said that.

Actually...

[jarmo]

You mention a one off, then say they want nothing to do with it.

Somewhat of an oxymoron.




/jarmo