TOP 3 from each GN'R album *THE RESULTS/SUGGEST NEXT TOP 3*

[faldor]

How about a best of the worst? I use the term "worst" loosely of course. Take the bottom 3 songs from each album and see what wins out. There's a few songs I think a lot of people enjoy that got voted off early. A second chance, if you will.

[Spirit]

How about a best of the worst? I use the term "worst" loosely of course. Take the bottom 3 songs from each album and see what wins out. There's a few songs I think a lot of people enjoy that got voted off early. A second chance, if you will.

I'll add it to the list.

[Spirit]

I'll also add a couple of new suggestion of mine, Best guitar riff and Best chorus.

Nominations required for both of em.

[Sosso]

the best opening acts on tour
the best album cover
the best single cover
the best dvd cover

[Spirit]

I'll add those.

Best DVD cover is kinda limited though. They only have 3 releases, right? Tokyo, WTTV and Vegas.

The last three (album, single and dvd cover) could maybe put together into one poll.

[Sosso]

I'll add those.

Best DVD cover is kinda limited though. They only have 3 releases, right? Tokyo, WTTV and Vegas.

It was just a thought. But maybe we should put over focus on the other top 3's.

[14 Yrs Of Silence]

best lyrics

[Sosso]

the best demo version of a song or demo vs. finished version

[Spirit]

I think all suggestions are good. What do you guys say to just do all of them, one at the time, starting at the top of the list (in the original post)?

If you have any more suggestions, just post them, I'll add to the list.

[Spirit]

Top 3 Concerts, could that be interesting?

[Sosso]

Top 3 Concerts, could that be interesting?

Yes, but I would make a top 3 concert list from every tour

[Spirit]

Top 3 Concerts, could that be interesting?

Yes, but I would make a top 3 concert list from every tour

I think it would be more interesting to mix up the old with the new to see how we feel about the performances, regardless of line-up.

Dividing up the individual tours will make up a whole lot of polls. Also, I think it'll be hard for everyone to judge say 10-12 concerts from each tour. Not many people have listened/seen that many concerts, bootleggers excluded. We could end up having to vote on over a hundred concerts in total, I think it'll be too much.

If we ask people to nominate one concert each, and we can end up with a list of about 15 concerts, I think that would be more manageable for most people to decide on.

[TheBaconman]

Best hair

[Spirit]

Best hair

So, we can have the same person in different time periods also?

We'll throw it in there. It's good to have some fun ones as well 

[D-GenerationX]

How about a best of the worst? I use the term "worst" loosely of course. Take the bottom 3 songs from each album and see what wins out. There's a few songs I think a lot of people enjoy that got voted off early. A second chance, if you will.

Yeah, this would be interesting.

[14 Yrs Of Silence]

Some of this is getting ridiculous.  Concerts only work for the shows we've all heard from popular bootlegs.  Hair?  Really?  How about we vote for the best 5 second increment of each song?  We can take each song from the catalog, one at a time, a breakdown the song into 5 second increments.  So for WTTJ at 4:33, we have 55 increments.   

[Spirit]

Concerts only work for the shows we've all heard from popular bootlegs.

Wasn't that the suggestion I made pretty much?

Hair?  Really?

I agree it's a ridiculous one. So far I've just put up all suggestions. No final decision made on how we go about it.

How about we vote for the best 5 second increment of each song?  We can take each song from the catalog, one at a time, a breakdown the song into 5 second increments.  So for WTTJ at 4:33, we have 55 increments.

Noted as 14 Yrs Of Silence's suggestion. 

[Ja5oN]

when people say "best concert", do they mean that we have footage of?

or are we going to rank some concert that we went to but nothing exists in the public domain to view?

[The Wight Gunner]

What about the best sections of a song that would make the best message alert  Maybe this could evolve to become reality 

"So you think you can stone me and spit in my eye...."  from the Freddie tribute concert is the one single line guaranteed to make my hairs stand on end. Such attitude and menace, if IIRC both Slash and Duff both said words to the effect that was one concert that Axl was totally King Dick in a good way.  To me his segment of this song was above anything I've seen done by Freddie himself, who owned Live Aid in 1985, but in my opinion comes a distant 2nd to Axl's version in his honour.

Edit: The section I refer to was not played at Live Aid but a Wembley a year later see 1:19:22 on https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7RAH11OjfGk and compare to 3:20 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i26406_EldM

[Spirit]

when people say "best concert", do they mean that we have footage of?

or are we going to rank some concert that we went to but nothing exists in the public domain to view?

Haven't decided on how we'll do a nominations process. But, if it's a concert only you on this board have seen, with no footage available, no one else than you would be likely to vote on that concert. 

So, I would think that the most known and available concerts would be considered for the poll. That's the most logical way in my mind. That way, most people are familiar with the majority of the concerts on the list, and can make a decision from that.