TOP 3 from each GN'R album *ROUND 1 - CLOSED*

[Spirit]

2nd vote


18        Welcome To The Jungle
26  +1  It's So Easy
30        Nightrain
0          Out Ta Get Me
0          Mr. Brownstone
0          Paradise City
0          My Michelle
0          Think About You
3  -1     Sweet Child O' Mine
0          You're Crazy
0          Anything Goes
43        Rocket Queen

[TheBaconman]

At this rate we won't be done all the rounds until around June!!!!

I suggest for the best round we switch too three daily votes per member.    Then mb we can see the end by April at least

When 3 songs remain on the list, we'll close the vote for this round.

The rules will be changed from round 2. Instead of giving 1 plus and 1 minus, you'll give 1 plus and 2 minus. That way there's one less point in circulation for each vote.

Good idea

[Sosso]

No changes please.

[Spirit]

No changes please.

Not in this round, but in order to have one name left at the end of the voting, we'll need to change it for the next round. Otherwise, like in this round, it won't be over until one song has 120 points (12 songs x 10 points), and the rest at 0. It will take forever, therefore we'll stop when there are 3 songs left in this round.

If we change to 1 plus and 2 minus (the 2 minus points can't be divided between two songs, one song only), the total amount of points will eventually be 0. GN'R Lies will go for a maximum of 80 rounds, UYI I will go for a maximum of 160 rounds, UYI II for a max of 140 rounds and so on. Therefore we can vote until there's 1 song left on the list.

Also with the new rules in place for the next round, you can only vote once every day.

[jazjme]

No changes please.

Not in this round, but in order to have one name left at the end of the voting, we'll need to change it for the next round. Otherwise, like in this round, it won't be over until one song has 120 points (12 songs x 10 points), and the rest at 0. It will take forever, therefore we'll stop when there are 3 songs left in this round.

If we change to 1 plus and 2 minus (the 2 minus points can't be divided between two songs, one song only), the total amount of points will eventually be 0. GN'R Lies will go for a maximum of 80 rounds, UYI I will go for a maximum of 160 rounds, UYI II for a max of 140 rounds and so on. Therefore we can vote until there's 1 song left on the list.

Also with the new rules in place for the next round, you can only vote once every day.

Sounds good.

[Muerto]

18 Welcome To The Jungle
27 +1 It's So Easy
29 -1 Nightrain
0 Out Ta Get Me
0 Mr. Brownstone
0 Paradise City
0 My Michelle
0 Think About You
3 Sweet Child O' Mine
0 You're Crazy
0 Anything Goes
43 Rocket Queen

 

[rebelhipi]

todays 1st


19  +1   Welcome To The Jungle
27         It's So Easy
29         Nightrain
0           Out Ta Get Me
0           Mr. Brownstone
0           Paradise City
0           My Michelle
0           Think About You
3           Sweet Child O' Mine
0            You're Crazy
0            Anything Goes
42   -1    Rocket Queen

[Sosso]

19        Welcome To The Jungle
27         It's So Easy
29         Nightrain
0           Out Ta Get Me
0           Mr. Brownstone
0           Paradise City
0           My Michelle
0           Think About You
2           Sweet Child O' Mine
0            You're Crazy
0            Anything Goes
43       Rocket Queen

[AxlsMainMan]

19        Welcome To The Jungle
28  +1   It's So Easy
29         Nightrain
0           Out Ta Get Me
0           Mr. Brownstone
0           Paradise City
0           My Michelle
0           Think About You
1   -1     Sweet Child O' Mine
0           You're Crazy
0           Anything Goes
42         Rocket Queen

[Sosso]

19        Welcome To The Jungle
28        It's So Easy
29         Nightrain
0           Out Ta Get Me
0           Mr. Brownstone
0           Paradise City
0           My Michelle
0           Think About You
0           Sweet Child O' Mine
0           You're Crazy
0           Anything Goes
43         Rocket Queen

[Axl4Prez2004]

Sosso!  You're a Sweet Child killer!   

Okay, here are my 2 +'s and 2 -'s for today:

21    +2    Welcome To The Jungle
26    -2    It's So Easy
29         Nightrain
0           Out Ta Get Me
0           Mr. Brownstone
0           Paradise City
0           My Michelle
0           Think About You
0           Sweet Child O' Mine
0           You're Crazy
0           Anything Goes
43         Rocket Queen

[Spirit]

1st vote (correted error in post #168 - Rocket Queen)


21         Welcome To The Jungle
26         It's So Easy
30   +1  Nightrain
0           Out Ta Get Me
0           Mr. Brownstone
0           Paradise City
0           My Michelle
0           Think About You
0           Sweet Child O' Mine
0           You're Crazy
0           Anything Goes
43    -1  Rocket Queen

[asdf gunner]

why not leave it as a top 4? otherwise it will last forever

[Spirit]

why not leave it as a top 4? otherwise it will last forever

It works for me. Looks like this will take some time.


If many disagree about the final standings, we can make a *FINAL* round after we're done with Chinese Democracy - with the top 4 from this vote, implementing the new rules.

[Sosso]

why not leave it as a top 4? otherwise it will last forever

It works for me. Looks like this will take some time.


If many disagree about the final standings, we can make a *FINAL* round after we're done with Chinese Democracy - with the top 4 from this vote, implementing the new rules.

We could choose the best three or four from each album and make a final round

[Spirit]

why not leave it as a top 4? otherwise it will last forever

It works for me. Looks like this will take some time.


If many disagree about the final standings, we can make a *FINAL* round after we're done with Chinese Democracy - with the top 4 from this vote, implementing the new rules.

We could choose the best three or four from each album and make a final round

That's possible.

[jarmo]

1. Rocket Queen
2. Nightrain
3. It's So Easy

4. Welcome To The Jungle
5. Sweet Child O' Mine
6. Mr. Brownstone
7. Paradise City
8. Out Ta Get Me
9. Think About You
10. My Michelle
11. You're Crazy
12. Anything Goes

That's interesting. So the songs you guys voted for are the ones the band has played the most during concerts.




/jarmo