So why is the DUFF topic locked?

[JAEBALL]

or am I mistaken .. cant reply to it anymore? did axl change his mind? ha

[Gaymo, the Hobbit]

i'm asking that myself aswell. stupid

[JAEBALL]

Only on a guns N roses message board does the original bass player rejoin the band for a few shows and we are not allowed to talk about it....

[Gaymo, the Hobbit]

Thats incorrect: only on HTGTH you can't

[Princess Leia]

I?d like to think it?s an April Fool joke. Please tell me it?s a joke 

[D-GenerationX]

You have to hope its an April Fool's joke.

But that's likely an easier sell if there was any history of levity around here, no?

[JAEBALL]

If this is locked for some reason...preventing reunion talk or something like that....

then I have to really reconsider why I choose this site to post... I like that people are respectful and there are no constant Axl is fat posts

but if Axl rose invites an original member to join the fun... and we cant talk about it?

what is the point of this place?

[JAEBALL]

I am hoping we get a message that they just want to wait until every detail is ironed out

[D-GenerationX]

The only posts at this entire site in the past hour have been in this thread.  Is that a sign of something?

If this was an April Fool's joke, I'm not sure it landed.  And as I said, that would have to be chalked up to the fact that there is never any levity around here.

I know that I had 5 posts outright deleted yesterday of the jokey variety.  If we are suddenly all about the comedy around here, its a new development.

[Gaymo, the Hobbit]

funny that a mod opens the thread, posts sth in it and closes it again.

pure comedy this forum

[JAEBALL]

I understand the mission statement of this place and why it is done, and I am ok with it....

but this is absurd

[D-GenerationX]

Not totally out of left field though.

Jarmo was conspicuously silent on the whole thing.  Didn't really say much, even after confirmation.

Thing I don't get is that Axl is clearly OK with this.  So why isn't Jarmo?

Weirdness.

[JAEBALL]

Not totally out of left field though.

Jarmo was conspicuously silent on the whole thing.  Didn't really say much, even after confirmation.

Thing I don't get is that Axl is clearly OK with this.  So why isn't Jarmo?

Weirdness.

you cant talk about "demanding" a new album
you cant talk about Slash... unless ofcourse its how he lies and holds up DVD releases
you cant talk about the setlist unless you think its great that its basically the same every night

and to an extent i understand all of those

but now... AXL ROSE the guy who this board is dedicated to... invites a former member of GNR back... and that's off limits too ?

obviously jarmo does not owe any of us anything... hes gunna lose zero sleep tonight if any of us decide not to chime in here...but id appreciate some kind of logical explanation

look in the thread...everybody is excited to see Duff play... and thats bad?


if he tells me its for some legal reason or something and that its not 100 percent yet... then ill take back what ive said and apologize

[Princess Leia]

It is a sure thing. Yesterday Duff confirmed in his twitter. He is performing in Argentina, Paraguay, Bolivia and Brazil. Also his wife Susan in her twitter said they are going to South America.

Really it doesn?t make any sense to lock that thread. At least move it to the ex members forum if it is a crime to talk about Duff in the GN?R forum but don?t lock it

[D-GenerationX]

It is a sure thing. Yesterday Duff confirmed in his twitter. He is performing in Argentina, Paraguay, Bolivia and Brazil. Also his wife Susan in her twitter said they are going to South America.

Really it doesn?t make any sense to lock that thread. At least move it to the ex members forum if it is a crime to talk about Duff in the GN?R forum but don?t lock it

Agreed.

And the thread was pretty much nothing but positivity.  It was probably the most positive thread of the first 5 or 6 on that page.

[LunsJail]

Although I post here occasionally and not myGNR (way negative), shit like this is why this forum is dead as a fucking duck. There's nothing to discuss here! Why wouldn't fans be talking about this?

[D-GenerationX]

Although I post here occasionally and not myGNR (way negative), shit like this is why this forum is dead as a fucking duck. There's nothing to discuss here! Why wouldn't fans be talking about this?

I love your sig.  What a great flick.

[JAEBALL]

i dont ever get posts deleted...and today i got one

i dont think its Jarmo... what the hell is going on over here lately?

i said this version of GNR hasnt ever released a song.... is that incorrect ?

[D-GenerationX]

i dont ever get posts deleted...and today i got one

i dont think its Jarmo... what the hell is going on over here lately?

i said this version of GNR hasnt ever released a song.... is that incorrect ?

Yeah, I don't think it was Jarmo that nuked our entire exchange the other day.

I have had exchanges with Jarmo directly, some that got a bit testy, and he never deleted any of them.  In fact, I've taken to mentioning that on other boards.  That Jarmo's rep isn't really fair because he give me a lot of leeway.

But as for that post of your that got tossed, I don't get it.  What's inaccurate about that?

[jarmo]

you cant talk about Slash...

Say hello to your new best friend: http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?board=15.0






/jarmo