October 14, 2010 London, England (Discussion)

[sixgnr]

My heart is broken...

[Halo69]

@ The Prez

You're probably confusing it with this answer : "You're totally wrong...Tommy General Stinson is bass player in Guns n Roses...Duff was only guest on that show,and I'm not impressed with Duff

New band fuckin rocks,and maybe they need ex members like guests (like Izzy andDuff) on some shows"


This answer was not posted by me lol  It was posted by Bolton

[The Prez]

@ The Prez

You're probably confusing it with this answer : "You're totally wrong...Tommy General Stinson is bass player in Guns n Roses...Duff was only guest on that show,and I'm not impressed with Duff

New band fuckin rocks,and maybe they need ex members like guests (like Izzy andDuff) on some shows"


This answer was not posted by me lol  It was posted by Bolton

Right!   .. I guess I'm a bit too excited about the whole thing that I can see and think straight 

Rock on! 

[elevendayempire]

What's all this I'm hearing about an acoustic show in London tonight?

As someone who left the Dublin gig after the bottling incident - and who lives in London - I'd cheerfully gnaw off my own arm to get into a London acoustic gig? anyone know what the score is?

[Sillything]

Duff! and Tommy!

[John]

STFU about reunion.

You wanted to see the old band, well they didn't fucking make it. So here's what you get. Axl Rose, Dizzy Reed, Frank Ferrer, Chris Pitman, Richard Fortus, Tommy Stinson, Ron Thal, DJ Ashba and if you're very fucking lucky, a guest spot by one Duff McKagan.

[Ulises]

For anybody who thinks Duff playing with GN'R is some kind of sign of a reunion: Go fuck yourselves....


I know it might offend some, but that's as clear as it gets. 




/jarmo

Seriously, who could be THAT stupid to think that?


I can't believe people are talking about reunion because Duff went onstage with Guns N' Roses.

[John]

Seriously, who could be THAT stupid to think that?

I can't believe people are talking about reunion because Duff went onstage with Guns N' Roses.

Nice wit you have there.

In that case, Slash must be joining the black eyed peas imminently. RNF'NR

[Nytunz]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TSjzbh3RHTw

Thanks! Great videoclip =)

[horsey]

really go fuck yourselves jarmo,is that right ?
come on if people get hopes up what's wrong with that ?
honestly without deleteing me for an opinion here.i find this outa pocket to speak to some happy fans.
imagine if fans had no hopes ?

[Just_Me]

It's kinda wrong to get peoples hopes up when it's never going to happen, because it's just setting them up for more dissapointment. I'm sure the thought will have crossed a lot of peoples minds (including mine) but there's no reason to go around reinforcing the belief that it could happen where there is absolutely no basis for it.

[gunns1]

whats constitutes  a gnr reunion anyway?

Id want Bucket back over any past member any fuckin day of the week, but probably 90% of fans wouldn't want that.

Im happy with the band now, there all performing the songs great and their energy is second to none.

LETS ENJOY WHAT WE HAVE, AND WHAT WE HAVE IS
FAN
FUCKIN
TASTIC

[ChiDem2010]

really go fuck yourselves jarmo,is that right ?
come on if people get hopes up what's wrong with that ?
honestly without deleteing me for an opinion here.i find this outa pocket to speak to some happy fans.
imagine if fans had no hopes ?

People need to stop with the reunion crap, the only people here bitchin and moaning about a reunion are people not satisfied with the new Gnr. In that sense, go fuck YOURselves and and quit the board or start listening to Jarmos requests.

[COMAMOTIVE]

I believe Duff going up and jamming actually means there is LESS of a chance of any re-union happening.

Duff jumping in and playing almost can give the indication that he has now accepted that the Gnr as it was is now something different -

Cool stuff

[DeN]

anyway, I still don't understand this term, "reunion". it will never happen, and that's not something I'd love to see, I live in 2010 not in 1988.

BUT Guns line-up is not written in stone, it's a changing band, so maybe we'll see in the future some old member rejoins the band, why not ?
if Tommy wanna quit the band one day, who is the best replacement for him? hum well...I'm sure you have some idea.

if Richard wants to do something else one day, there's a great guitarist/songwriter we all knew before who can do the job...

but yes, it has to happen IF one of the current member wants to quit, at first.
and I'll have no problem with that.

[horsey]

really go fuck yourselves jarmo,is that right ?
come on if people get hopes up what's wrong with that ?
honestly without deleteing me for an opinion here.i find this outa pocket to speak to some happy fans.
imagine if fans had no hopes ?

People need to stop with the reunion crap, the only people here bitchin and moaning about a reunion are people not satisfied with the new Gnr. In that sense, go fuck YOURselves and and quit the board or start listening to Jarmos requests.

do u think i should go fuck myself,lets say for instance.i seen guns when the were guns and have respect for all members old n new.but don't make something out of nothing it sounds like.idk seeming like there is no hope kinna makes the fun of g n r dissapear.but i have only high regards for them surviveing the past years.
meaning the band in it's self has survived.

[AxlReznor]

Nothing wrong with fucking yourself...  don't take it so hard (no pun intended).

[The Prez]

You can say what you want, but the fact that Duff hit the stage will bring more (positive?) GN'R news in the media than any other current member did...
That's a fact.
Therefore I think it's bit cheap to insult people with 'go fuck yourselve'.

Most people and fans will always remember guns with lineup of the late eighties and early nineties... most people don't even know the names of the current members except for us (hardcore fans) eventough those people also go and watch, and enjoy the current lineup on stage.

My personal feeling is that the current lineup is maybe the best Guns ever had...but they did not yet released anything (song, video, album) that moved most people out there except for us, the hardcores.
Therefore please don't judge the people who are speculating of having/wanting Duff back in the band...it's a natural thing. It's fucking normal.
Maybe they are not welcome here, but it's what's going on in the 'real world'.

Let's speculate once and imagine it does happen that Duff returns...how would you then react?? I thnik it's a common saying all over the world 'never say never'.

[Lara]

sounds epic. I just cried. SO did both tommy and duff play bass? Did axl and duff shake hands or hug on stage? did he just walk out or was he introduced?

end of the vid, Tommy appeared without a bass and Duff handed it to him before walking offstage, so i dont know.

thats HUGE of Tommy to be so selfless and allow that to happen. big props to him for that!

I agree!
Tommy is great, and why wouldn't he be? There is no threat or competition between them, you have to be naive or too romantic (not that there's anything wrong with that) to believe this was more than just a guest appearance.  

Tommy has been the bass player of GnR for more than a decade now, let's not forget that.
I'm sure everyone in the band made Duff feel welcome as they respect who he is.  

[Gezzy]

A GNR reunion? oooh can we have Robin back?