Brain "probably not" touring

[MrMojoRa]

Jarmo's house, jarmo's rules. Been like that since '02 and prob before. He has his defense missiles ready at all times. Has to. Hey jarmo, remember that Van Halen fan board invasion way back when?

So, back on topic...............

As long as Axl shows up, the show will go on regardless of which highly talented musician joins him. If they are on the stage with Axl, then they are talented enough to be there. My opinion.

[The Illusionist]

Do we know what's going on with Robin Fink?  Is he gone for good too?

[The Illusionist]

Do we know what's going on with Robin Fink?  Is he gone for good too?

I know we have DJ Ashba "officially" replacing him but I wasn't sure how serious it was.

[jarmo]

How serious what was?

DJ replaced Robin. Seems pretty "serious"? 

Hey jarmo, remember that Van Halen fan board invasion way back when?

Yes....




/jarmo

[Jim Bob]

Do we know what's going on with Robin Fink?  Is he gone for good too?

I know we have DJ Ashba "officially" replacing him but I wasn't sure how serious it was.

well it was posted on the official site, the official myspace, and dj says he's in rehersals with GnR right now.. so thats about as serious as it gets.

[djcleaver]

Well I'm glad Frank will be back, he really is a great guy and I've always liked his work.

[younggunner]

thanks for the info....sucks that Brain wont be back. But at this point as long as Axl shows up who really cares.

Until a gnr lineup stays together for the making, recording, and touring of at least one album then it will just be an Axl show at this point.

[jarmo]

You sound like a broken record.....

By the looks of thing, the "line up" that recorded the album never existed at the same time.

Or do have you proof that Axl, Dizzy, Chris, Richard, Frank, Ron, Tommy, Robin, Brain, Buckethead and Paul were all planning to tour together?


Since Paul wasn't gonna be a touring member anyway, the line up with him wasn't meant to tour.

That alone makes it impossible to get what you want..... But you keep going on and on about it.




/jarmo

[younggunner]

By the looks of thing, the "line up" that recorded the album never existed at the same time.

Or do have you proof that Axl, Dizzy, Chris, Richard, Frank, Ron, Tommy, Robin, Brain, Buckethead and Paul were all planning to tour together?


Since Paul wasn't gonna be a touring member anyway, the line up with him wasn't meant to tour.

That alone makes it impossible to get what you want..... But you keep going on and on about it.

The lineup that created and  recorded the bulk of CD is Axl, Dizzy, Bucket, Tommy, Tobias, Robin, Brain, Pitman..and a liltle Fortus.

Frank and Ron are on the album by default

last I checked in 2002 and even some of 2006 had the majority of those members on tour. Really just minus Bucket because Paul never had plans of being a touring member.

Rock n roll is about guitars and vocals. The guitarists in GNR who created a good bulk of CD will not be on the Chinese Democracy World tour. Its like old GNR releasing AFD and then shortly after touring without Slash and Izzy.

I dont know why the reality of the situation bothers you so much but from here on out its all about Axl. Until this current lineup or whatever lineup there is a yr or so from now records and creates the majority of what makes it on a record and then tours its an Axl thing. Nothing wrong with that. It is what it is.

It must be a little bit of a bummer for a kid from Idaho to dig CD and then learn that the guitarists of his favorite solos and songs are gone and wont be touring. Hence this show right now is mostly an Axl thing. And of course for the alumni who have remained loyal like Dizzy and Pitman...but mainly TOmmy

[Layne Staley's Sunglasses]

It must be a little bit of a bummer for a kid from Idaho to dig CD and then learn that the guitarists of his favorite solos and songs are gone and wont be touring

Or some wiffleball playing chump from cheap-ass Jersey.

[jarmo]

Bothers me?

You're the one who keeps going on and on about it....


I know Buckethead hasn't been part of GN'R since 2004.

He put his mark on the album, it's there for us all to listen to and he didn't want to be part of the touring band. So he was replaced. Doesn't bother me at all!

You on the other hand...

So I'm just wondering when you'll stop posting the same "it's not the same line up that recorded the album" crap... We know!





/jarmo

[younggunner]

Or some wiffleball playing chump from cheap-ass Jersey.

lol.

Bothers me?

You're the one who keeps going on and on about it....


I know Buckethead hasn't been part of GN'R since 2004.

He put his mark on the album, it's there for us all to listen to and he didn't want to be part of the touring band. So he was replaced. Doesn't bother me at all!

You on the other hand...

So I'm just wondering when you'll stop posting the same "it's not the same line up that recorded the album" crap... We know!

It doesnt bother me. Im gonna go to the shows and enjoy the hell out of it. But its really just an Axl show at the moment. Nothing wrong with that...again, it is what it is.

[Layne Staley's Sunglasses]

An Axl Rose only should would be....uhhh, mm, well, Axl Rose only.

English, motherfucker!  Do you speak it?

[younggunner]

English, motherfucker!  Do you speak it?

sum tymez I Englush speeek

[jarmo]

But its really just an Axl show at the moment.

No, it's not. He's got a band. Just like in the past.


You seem to forget that Buckethead joined the band Axl was in, not the other way around.

So if you want to use the "Axl show" excuse, it's been true for longer than you want to admit.



/jarmo

[CheapJon]

English, motherfucker!  Do you speak it?

what? 


 

[Jim Bob]

Theres no way it could possibly be an Axl only show.   Without the band, there is no music..

Why the fuck are people complaining about the touring band vs the recording band again??

[younggunner]

No, it's not. He's got a band. Just like in the past.

And what happened to GNR when Slash, Izzy, and Duff left?

Forget about the media....Im talking about the actual GNR fan base. Did most of the old fans support Axl over the past decade? The fans that jumped ship or lost interest in the band probably felt that any new incarnation would have to impress them via new music. Slash and company gained their support and hearts with the music they created.

If old GNR toured right after AFD without Slash and Izzy..particularly Slash... would it still have been the same? It might have been called GNR but in reality it wouldnt have been. And thats my only point.

You seem to forget that Buckethead joined the band Axl was in, not the other way around.

You seem to forget that most people think that this is an Axl Rose solo gig. And as fans of Axl, we can no longer dispute that argument.

[AC]

You seem to forget that Buckethead joined the band Axl was in, not the other way around.

You seem to forget that most people think that this is an Axl Rose solo gig. And as fans of Axl, we can no longer dispute that argument.

Who cares? LOL. Lot of people here with nothing better to do these days. It's impressive.

AC

[HBK]

uuuffff.... OLD DISCUSSIONS... By Newbies

On-Topic:

Me Favorite Drum In History Is Brain, excelent:

Writing, Dj, Creator, Drum, Producer, etc, etc.. General Music Styles, GENIUS: HipHop, Rock, Hardcore, Funk Is GOD