Fantasy Baseball Trade I Need Help On

[western_chaos]

On my 12 team public league, I need closers really badly, but I already have two. I have both Kevin Gregg and Carlos Marmol for Chicago, and George Sherill of Baltimore.

Anyways, this guy has offered Joe Nathan and Rafael Furcal for Hanley Ramirez.

Also, he has also just offered Joe Nathan for Carlos Beltran.

Are any of these trades worth it? I'm thinking not cause it's just for saves anyways.

[D]

NO WAY

Hanley is a Fantasy STUD

Closers are only worth 1 category right?

Hanley gets u average, triples, Stolen bases, HR's, RBI's OBP OPS


do not do any of those deals


PLUS

Every season u can always pick up a couple of quality closers that emerge out of Spring Training.

[western_chaos]

Alright, that's what I figured, thanks man.

[D]

Plus u got Marmol. He should get a shit load of saves for the Cubs this season.

I figure the Cubs will win at least 90 this year, so u are looking at about 45 saves for Marmol

[freedom78]

Plus u got Marmol. He should get a shit load of saves for the Cubs this season.

I figure the Cubs will win at least 90 this year, so u are looking at about 45 saves for Marmol

Not to mention that Marmol should come cheap (if the league considers real world salary), and be uber-productive for the price.  He may hit a rough patch during the season, as he did last year, but he seems to bounce back, so I wouldn't give up on him 'til Lou does.

[Layne Staley's Sunglasses]

Furcal is a magnet for injuries, stay away,

STAAAYYYYY AWWAYYYYYYYYYYY.

[faldor]

Definitely no on the first one.  Keep Ramirez at all costs.  Nathan for Beltran might be worth considering, depending on what you could replace Beltran with.

I've got one for my team.  I'm in a keeper league and need to decide to keep 4 players from last seasons team.  We need to keep 2 hitters and 2 pitchers and can only keep 1 early round pick of each (guys who were drafted in rounds 1-5).  I've got and am obviously keeping Hanley.  And my other hitter is going to be Nate McLouth, only other option would be Delmon Young as I used my first 5 choices last year on hitters so they aren't eligible.  My pitching comes down to 4 choices and I can only keep 2.  Scott Kazmir, who was my keeper from the previous season, Chad Billingsley, Brad Lidge, and Jose Valverde.  Any thoughts?  I'm leaning towards Kazmir and Lidge, but an argument could be made for Billingsley.

[pilferk]

Definitely no on the first one.  Keep Ramirez at all costs.  Nathan for Beltran might be worth considering, depending on what you could replace Beltran with.

I've got one for my team.  I'm in a keeper league and need to decide to keep 4 players from last seasons team.  We need to keep 2 hitters and 2 pitchers and can only keep 1 early round pick of each (guys who were drafted in rounds 1-5).  I've got and am obviously keeping Hanley.  And my other hitter is going to be Nate McLouth, only other option would be Delmon Young as I used my first 5 choices last year on hitters so they aren't eligible.  My pitching comes down to 4 choices and I can only keep 2.  Scott Kazmir, who was my keeper from the previous season, Chad Billingsley, Brad Lidge, and Jose Valverde.  Any thoughts?  I'm leaning towards Kazmir and Lidge, but an argument could be made for Billingsley.

Definitely Kazmir.

My concern with Lidge would be injuries...but based purely on performance, he'd be my other choice as well.

[faldor]

Definitely no on the first one.  Keep Ramirez at all costs.  Nathan for Beltran might be worth considering, depending on what you could replace Beltran with.

I've got one for my team.  I'm in a keeper league and need to decide to keep 4 players from last seasons team.  We need to keep 2 hitters and 2 pitchers and can only keep 1 early round pick of each (guys who were drafted in rounds 1-5).  I've got and am obviously keeping Hanley.  And my other hitter is going to be Nate McLouth, only other option would be Delmon Young as I used my first 5 choices last year on hitters so they aren't eligible.  My pitching comes down to 4 choices and I can only keep 2.  Scott Kazmir, who was my keeper from the previous season, Chad Billingsley, Brad Lidge, and Jose Valverde.  Any thoughts?  I'm leaning towards Kazmir and Lidge, but an argument could be made for Billingsley.

Definitely Kazmir.

My concern with Lidge would be injuries...but based purely on performance, he'd be my other choice as well.

Thanks pilferk.  I think that's what I'll end up doing.  It's a 12 team league, so I'm trying to weigh whether it's more important to keep starting pitching or relievers.  Last year I had 3 pretty solid closers for most of the season but my starting pitching was a little lacking.  But I did finish 1st in my division and 2nd in the playoffs so that method seemed to work.  Hopefully I could land Billingsley OR better in the draft.  I figure Lidge is a top 5 closer or so and Billingsley is somewhere near a top 25 SP.

[D]

Lidge was perfect last season and Philly are back just as strong. So definitely.

I know in Fantasy baseball, I always go hard on pitching my first 4 rounds.

I never take a hitter before round 5 unless I get a shitty spot in the order and most of the good pitchers are gone

If I get a top 3 pick though, I go pitching to the max cause u can get great hitting all through the draft usually.

[faldor]

Lidge was perfect last season and Philly are back just as strong. So definitely.

I know in Fantasy baseball, I always go hard on pitching my first 4 rounds.

I never take a hitter before round 5 unless I get a shitty spot in the order and most of the good pitchers are gone

If I get a top 3 pick though, I go pitching to the max cause u can get great hitting all through the draft usually.

Yeah I rarely have a specific plan on how I draft from year to year, although the last couple years I've sided with hitting.  Last year I went heavy on offense because the year before even though I had as good an infield as you could have (Fielder, Utley, M. Cabrera, H. Ramirez) my outfield was pretty awful.  My pitching has been a little lacking but last year my closers helped even things out.   

[western_chaos]

Yeah, that guy finally gave up on the trades. He's desperate for offense lol.

He tried trading with another guy: Bobby Abreu for Huston Street.

Abreu is so much better.

[D]

I don't understand this guy's strategy

shit, it isn't even Spring Training yet.


Hitters ALWAYS come out of nowhere.

Hitting is really the least of my concerns in Fantasy Baseball.

I always concede HR's, RBI and Slugging

I concentrate on OB, AVG, SB  I try to split the hitting categories, load up my pitching staff and consistently get wins.

It won me 2 first place trophies a couple years ago.


Last year, I did the hitting thing and lost my ass in every league.

so this year, back to pitching

[western_chaos]

So, this same guy just offered me another trade lol.

Carlos Beltran in exchange for Troy Percieval and Bobby Abreu.

[Rage in the Cage]

You have to be careful with Troy Percival.  He's great when he's healthy, but he's always battling the injury bug.

[western_chaos]

You have to be careful with Troy Percival.  He's great when he's healthy, but he's always battling the injury bug.

Yeah, I'm aware. He is still promising his team he'll be healthy, but we'll see I guess.

[faldor]

So, this same guy just offered me another trade lol.

Carlos Beltran in exchange for Troy Percieval and Bobby Abreu.

I would definitely take that trade.  If you're getting Beltran that is.

[western_chaos]

So, this same guy just offered me another trade lol.

Carlos Beltran in exchange for Troy Percieval and Bobby Abreu.

I would definitely take that trade.  If you're getting Beltran that is.

I'm not getting Beltran, ha ha. That's why I'm gonna reject it.