Robin leaving? Just touring?

[123191]

Personally I think that if Robin was really out of the band, it would be the best thing to happen to GNR. Robin may be a good rhythm player and his original solos on CD may be allright, but the guy could never play Slash's classic solos for shit. It was actually PAINFUL to listen to him raping the solos on November Rain and SCOM, just to name a couple.

Tha'ts just my opinion, don't take it personally 

Stupid!

[GnR-NOW]

 5. Flyering filler for fun is not in my make-up, my form nor fancy. More true, kindling amassed for my melt-down; I'm trying it on here thsame 7:13 PM

Maybe that means he didn't fully enjoy plaing the old material everynight ??

[Voodoochild]

Personally I think that if Robin was really out of the band, it would be the best thing to happen to GNR. Robin may be a good rhythm player and his original solos on CD may be allright, but the guy could never play Slash's classic solos for shit. It was actually PAINFUL to listen to him raping the solos on November Rain and SCOM, just to name a couple.

Tha'ts just my opinion, don't take it personally 

Oh, good for you. I took personally and now I want to make you listen to every single VR boot with Slash raping his own work.

[Rock the jungle]

Personally I think that if Robin was really out of the band, it would be the best thing to happen to GNR. Robin may be a good rhythm player and his original solos on CD may be allright, but the guy could never play Slash's classic solos for shit. It was actually PAINFUL to listen to him raping the solos on November Rain and SCOM, just to name a couple.

Tha'ts just my opinion, don't take it personally 

I think like you about robin playing the old stuff

[Koskenkorvasieni]

Personally I think that if Robin was really out of the band, it would be the best thing to happen to GNR. Robin may be a good rhythm player and his original solos on CD may be allright, but the guy could never play Slash's classic solos for shit. It was actually PAINFUL to listen to him raping the solos on November Rain and SCOM, just to name a couple.

Tha'ts just my opinion, don't take it personally 

Oh, good for you. I took personally and now I want to make you listen to every single VR boot with Slash raping his own work.

I don't think Slash is capable of butchering his own solos..but just for curiosity's sake, why don't you post a youtube-link to a clip you THINK has him rape his own solo...

[ppbebe]

Go to dead horse.

Maybe that means he didn't fully enjoy plaing the old material everynight ??

of nin?

One may think that could lead to some esquizo-psycho-twisting-meaning:

4. I think I'm better suited to write to someone singular and real like my mother or my self in the future. 7:15 PM

I say he's referring to these posts @twitter.

what about...
3. Dear Future Self, I'm doing my best to meet you half way. Could you take it easy on me at first? 7:16 PM

[GNRFAN20]

Robin plays old material in NIN. So that closes the argument about him being bored.

[Voodoochild]

what about...
3. Dear Future Self, I'm doing my best to meet you half way. Could you take it easy on me at first? 7:16 PM

Ha, that's a good one.

But I don't really think he's sending cryptic messages on twitter. I'm sure he has more going on in his life than just GNR - NIN stuff.

Personally I think that if Robin was really out of the band, it would be the best thing to happen to GNR. Robin may be a good rhythm player and his original solos on CD may be allright, but the guy could never play Slash's classic solos for shit. It was actually PAINFUL to listen to him raping the solos on November Rain and SCOM, just to name a couple.

Tha'ts just my opinion, don't take it personally 

Oh, good for you. I took personally and now I want to make you listen to every single VR boot with Slash raping his own work.

I don't think Slash is capable of butchering his own solos..but just for curiosity's sake, why don't you post a youtube-link to a clip you THINK has him rape his own solo...

Go youtube.com and type: Velvet Revolver.

[Jim Bob]

Personally I think that if Robin was really out of the band, it would be the best thing to happen to GNR. Robin may be a good rhythm player and his original solos on CD may be allright, but the guy could never play Slash's classic solos for shit. It was actually PAINFUL to listen to him raping the solos on November Rain and SCOM, just to name a couple.

Tha'ts just my opinion, don't take it personally 

Oh, good for you. I took personally and now I want to make you listen to every single VR boot with Slash raping his own work.

I don't think Slash is capable of butchering his own solos..but just for curiosity's sake, why don't you post a youtube-link to a clip you THINK has him rape his own solo...

i think if you want to talk about that fucking guy you should go to the ex-members section.

[LeftToDecay]

i think if you want to talk about that fucking guy you should go to the ex-members section.

Yeah I guess it's pretty safe to say Finck is out.

[Voodoochild]

i think if you want to talk about that fucking guy you should go to the ex-members section.

Yeah I guess it's pretty safe to say Finck is out.

Dont be a smart ass.

[GNR4L]

i think if you want to talk about that fucking guy you should go to the ex-members section.

Yeah I guess it's pretty safe to say Finck is out.

it's pretty safe to assume that he will be back for GnR Tour... Thank you.

[highend88]

After 230 pages, we still don't know if he's still with GNR. God bless Robin.

[Jim Bob]

i think if you want to talk about that fucking guy you should go to the ex-members section.

Yeah I guess it's pretty safe to say Finck is out.

it's pretty safe to assume that he will be back for GnR Tour... Thank you.

he definitely has a better shot than that other guy, whose chances are ZERO.

hate idiots who are stuck in the past.

[LeftToDecay]

hate idiots who are stuck in the past.

Coming from a guy whose very signature is all about good ol axl vs slash bullshit? It isn't 1996 anymore.
Move on, dude. Move on.

[GNR4L]

i think if you want to talk about that fucking guy you should go to the ex-members section.

Yeah I guess it's pretty safe to say Finck is out.

it's pretty safe to assume that he will be back for GnR Tour... Thank you.

he definitely has a better shot than that other guy, whose chances are ZERO.
hate idiots who are stuck in the past.

When Tix go on sale for tour, they usually go onsale atleast 5-6 months ahead of time.  That saying Guns N' Roses have not made a announcement dates, there for nothing is indicating that Robin won't be stuck with NIN the same time.   Robin is done in August, so I doubt NIN will interfere with GnR's plans to tour.  For all those so called fans wanting Robin to not tour with GnR tells me two things   1. They don't know what there talking about   2. they wish there top hat friend would comeback.

[Koskenkorvasieni]

For all those so called fans wanting Robin to not tour with GnR tells me two things   1. They don't know what there talking about   2. they wish there top hat friend would comeback.

I am perfectly aware of the fact that Axl wants absolutely nothing to do with Slash and probably vice versa. I'm just saying that there are way better players out there than Finck, players who are probably capable of doing Slash's solos justice instead of brutally murdering them. Besides, Finck only co-wrote one song out of the fourteen songs that ended up on Chinese Democracy, namely Better. So atleast in my opinion he could be replaced, since he is currently unavailable anyway...

[Giant_Robot]

. I'm just saying that there are way better players out there than Finck, players who are probably capable of doing Slash's solos justice instead of brutally murdering them.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pfiDhRdDQGQ     

[GNR4L]

For all those so called fans wanting Robin to not tour with GnR tells me two things   1. They don't know what there talking about   2. they wish there top hat friend would comeback.

I am perfectly aware of the fact that Axl wants absolutely nothing to do with Slash and probably vice versa. I'm just saying that there are way better players out there than Finck, players who are probably capable of doing Slash's solos justice instead of brutally murdering them. Besides, Finck only co-wrote one song out of the fourteen songs that ended up on Chinese Democracy, namely Better. So atleast in my opinion he could be replaced, since he is currently unavailable anyway...

Finck style is unique and he has awesome stage presense which people love.  Only writing one song ?    the one song he wrote which you ask 98 percent of GnR fans say Better is the best song off the album.   Finck is on future material  so NO HE SHOULDN'T BE REPLACED.

[Voodoochild]

^ Not only that, but also he probably wrote some of the best solos of the album (SOD, TIL, Better and so on).

I'm just saying that there are way better players out there than Finck, players who are probably capable of doing Slash's solos justice instead of brutally murdering them.

It's your opnion and thanks God Axl don't share it with you. Obviously there are tons of players who can play Slash's solos, but how many can do it on their own way, in ther own style? And since when Robin is there just to play Slash's parts?

I get you. You're just trying to stir shit up here because you hate Robin so much that you like to take cheap (and dumb) shots in this thread to express how much you'd love to see an average Slash wannabe instead of him. All because Axl prefer to work with Robin instead of your hero.