Robin leaving? Just touring?

[The Prez]

That has nothing to do with it...I'm not talking about the music as such... am just have this feeling they don't have that GN'R attitude, for what this attitude it may be...the smokey fuck off attitude, I don't know.
I like the music of CD and acknowledge their quality and efforts for CD but when I see Robin (and Bucket) playing on stage with Guns...i don't know, it doesn't fit in 'my GN'R'

[Jim Bob]

That has nothing to do with it...I'm not talking about the music as such... am just have this feeling they don't have that GN'R attitude, for what this attitude it may be...the smokey fuck off attitude, I don't know.
I like the music of CD and acknowledge their quality and efforts for CD but when I see Robin (and Bucket) playing on stage with Guns...i don't know, it doesn't fit in 'my GN'R'

i take it you're stuck in 1992.    Sorry to hear it, cuz thats pretty pathetic. 

[Thorned Rose]

I always thought 2 lead guitarists was dumb anyways... it bloats things sometimes...

like in the rs interview....

what Slash and Izzy did, it takes a wall of them now...

just keep Bumble, Fortus, and Stinson....

You don't need 2 leads

[wells]

I always thought 2 lead guitarists was dumb anyways... it bloats things sometimes...

like in the rs interview....

what Slash and Izzy did, it takes a wall of them now...

just keep Bumble, Fortus, and Stinson....

You don't need 2 leads

and You have listened to Chinese Democracy recently? 

edit: I thought we have all digested some things about GN'R; there will be no reunion (of first lineup); there is three guitarists and they are NEEDED for live performance; this topic is about Robin leaving or not leaving...

[Jim Bob]

I always thought 2 lead guitarists was dumb anyways... it bloats things sometimes...

like in the rs interview....

what Slash and Izzy did, it takes a wall of them now...

just keep Bumble, Fortus, and Stinson....

You don't need 2 leads

AFD had 3 guitar tracks, some on the illusions had more, so stop trying to prop the old guys up on some supreme level.

The purpose of having 2 leads, is each guy has his own unique style and it brings a lot more diversity to the table.   I couldn't think of a more perfect lead guitar duo than Robin and Buckethead.   Its not the same old shit every song.   With that said, sure Bumble and Fortus alone would still make for a great guitar lineup. 

[makane]

I always thought 2 lead guitarists was dumb anyways... it bloats things sometimes...

like in the rs interview....

what Slash and Izzy did, it takes a wall of them now...

just keep Bumble, Fortus, and Stinson....

You don't need 2 leads

AFD had 3 guitar tracks, some on the illusions had more, so stop trying to prop the old guys up on some supreme level.

The purpose of having 2 leads, is each guy has his own unique style and it brings a lot more diversity to the table.   I couldn't think of a more perfect lead guitar duo than Robin and Buckethead.   Its not the same old shit every song.   With that said, sure Bumble and Fortus alone would still make for a great guitar lineup. 

He was talking about live situation.

[Mobenrad]

That has nothing to do with it...I'm not talking about the music as such... am just have this feeling they don't have that GN'R attitude, for what this attitude it may be...the smokey fuck off attitude, I don't know.
I like the music of CD and acknowledge their quality and efforts for CD but when I see Robin (and Bucket) playing on stage with Guns...i don't know, it doesn't fit in 'my GN'R'

i take it you're stuck in 1992.    Sorry to hear it, cuz thats pretty pathetic. 

That's the narrow-mindedness we see from the Slash fanboys.

[TVC15]

I always thought 2 lead guitarists was dumb anyways... it bloats things sometimes...

like in the rs interview....

what Slash and Izzy did, it takes a wall of them now...

just keep Bumble, Fortus, and Stinson....

You don't need 2 leads

Statements like this remind me of my fellow classmates. They say that everything the Rolling Stones created without Brian Jones is worthless.

 

The work they did with Mick Taylor is priceless (!!!). Beggars, Let It Bleed, Sticky Fingers, Exile...

 

[Jim Bob]

That has nothing to do with it...I'm not talking about the music as such... am just have this feeling they don't have that GN'R attitude, for what this attitude it may be...the smokey fuck off attitude, I don't know.
I like the music of CD and acknowledge their quality and efforts for CD but when I see Robin (and Bucket) playing on stage with Guns...i don't know, it doesn't fit in 'my GN'R'

i take it you're stuck in 1992.    Sorry to hear it, cuz thats pretty pathetic. 

That's the narrow-mindedness we see from the Slash fanboys.

no kidding... the album is out, its like their worst nightmare.    they can't help but troll these sites about guys who have nothing to do with the band and haven't for 10 years.

[The Catcher]

So is there still any real indication that Robin left?

[wells]

So is there still any real indication that Robin left?

the silence of the lambs 

 

no, we DOESN'T 

[Jim Bob]

So is there still any real indication that Robin left?

i guess the myspace page

[TomFriend]

So is there still any real indication that Robin left?

i guess the myspace page

And the iTunes page, and Bumblefoot pretty much saying he was gone.

[Dead N' Bloated]

So is there still any real indication that Robin left?

i guess the myspace page

And the iTunes page, and Bumblefoot pretty much saying he was gone.

What did Bumble say?


 

[Ulises]

So is there still any real indication that Robin left?

i guess the myspace page

And the iTunes page, and Bumblefoot pretty much saying he was gone.

What?

[Alfie Bones]

And an update on gunsnroses.com two days before the album was released that listed the current band lineup, but was taken down a few hours later.

Listed Axl, Dizzy, Bumble, Tommy, Richard, and Frank as the current members.

[AXL DEMOCRACY]

[TomFriend]

So is there still any real indication that Robin left?

i guess the myspace page

And the iTunes page, and Bumblefoot pretty much saying he was gone.

What?

I can't find the damn interview now...recent one, towards the end when he was asked if they'd be touring in support of the album.

[TomFriend]

Let's find Axl first 

[prairie]

Let's find Axl first 

They're with Izzy.