Robin leaving? Just touring?

[GypsySoul]

People need to getover the whole NIN thing.  The Album is coming out and im sure as hell Robin is excited for it's release.  Last thing we need to do as fans is get all pissed off when actually GnR isn't touring at the moment and be angry with Robin.  Nothing we can do about it until it's time for Guns to plan their touring schedule.

That's bullshit!!!  We got every right to be pissed at Robin for not addressing the GNR fans about his status in the band because he made himself a distraction during the time when the ONLY thing GNR fans should be thinking about is the release of Chinese Democracy!!!  Robin had no problem telling the NIN fans how fuckin "thrilled" he was to be playing with them but hasn't said shit to us!!! 

[Ali]

People need to getover the whole NIN thing.  The Album is coming out and im sure as hell Robin is excited for it's release.  Last thing we need to do as fans is get all pissed off when actually GnR isn't touring at the moment and be angry with Robin.  Nothing we can do about it until it's time for Guns to plan their touring schedule.

That's bullshit!!!  We got every right to be pissed at Robin for not addressing the GNR fans about his status in the band because he made himself a distraction during the time when the ONLY thing GNR fans should be thinking about is the release of Chinese Democracy!!!  Robin had no problem telling the NIN fans how fuckin "thrilled" he was to be playing with them but hasn't said shit to us!!! 

Wow, that seems like a bit of an overreaction.  Maybe the official word on Robin summed everything up perfectly?  When it is time to tour, then things will be addressed.  But now, is it really necessary?  I don't see how.

Ali

[GypsySoul]

Wow, that seems like a bit of an overreaction.  Maybe the official word on Robin summed everything up perfectly?  When it is time to tour, then things will be addressed.  But now, is it really necessary?  I don't see how.

Ali

No.  The official word was "Only Robin knows what Robin's doing."


P.S.  Happy November 7th Birthday anyways, Robin. 

[whiny]

robin is great. he will shine on cd, no matter if he's in the band or not at the moment. that's the important thing right now.

[Ali]

Wow, that seems like a bit of an overreaction.  Maybe the official word on Robin summed everything up perfectly?  When it is time to tour, then things will be addressed.  But now, is it really necessary?  I don't see how.

Ali

No.  The official word was "Only Robin knows what Robin's doing."


P.S.  Happy November 7th Birthday anyways, Robin. 

No, the official word was a bit more detailed than that.  It included that they will see how things stand when it comes time to tour.

Ali

[adman2374]

Wow, that seems like a bit of an overreaction.  Maybe the official word on Robin summed everything up perfectly?  When it is time to tour, then things will be addressed.  But now, is it really necessary?  I don't see how.

Ali

No.  The official word was "Only Robin knows what Robin's doing."


P.S.  Happy November 7th Birthday anyways, Robin. 

No, the official word was a bit more detailed than that.  It included that they will see how things stand when it comes time to tour.

Ali

Sorry, man. You are flat wrong. The only band statement as specific to robin was as described above. It goes without saying that they will see how things stand when it comes to touring...that has nothing to do with robin in particular...duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

[Ali]

Wow, that seems like a bit of an overreaction.  Maybe the official word on Robin summed everything up perfectly?  When it is time to tour, then things will be addressed.  But now, is it really necessary?  I don't see how.

Ali

No.  The official word was "Only Robin knows what Robin's doing."


P.S.  Happy November 7th Birthday anyways, Robin. 

No, the official word was a bit more detailed than that.  It included that they will see how things stand when it comes time to tour.

Ali

Sorry, man. You are flat wrong. The only band statement as specific to robin was as described above. It goes without saying that they will see how things stand when it comes to touring...that has nothing to do with robin in particular...duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Nope.  You are flat wrong.

"When we begin to put tour plans together we'll see where things are at. Until then, Robin's touring with NIN and we're working with management on our game plans."

http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?topic=51547.0

Ali

[McDuff]

So as it stands now no one even knows really who is in or out of the band,it doesn't really matter at this point anyway I guess.

[willow]

Hell yeah it matters. A lot of us have grown to love the newer band members, just as we loved the others. It matters. Robin is one of the most amazing people I have ever met. I for one really want to see him in this band.

[slane92]

Lets hope Robin returns from his break for a GNR world tour in 09

[russtcb]

Lets hope Robin returns from his break for a GNR world tour in 09

That's what I'm hoping for too. I think Robin Finck is a bad ass on the guitar and I hope he returns to GNR.

[adman2374]

Wow, that seems like a bit of an overreaction.  Maybe the official word on Robin summed everything up perfectly?  When it is time to tour, then things will be addressed.  But now, is it really necessary?  I don't see how.

Ali

No.  The official word was "Only Robin knows what Robin's doing."


P.S.  Happy November 7th Birthday anyways, Robin. 

No, the official word was a bit more detailed than that.  It included that they will see how things stand when it comes time to tour.

Ali

Sorry, man. You are flat wrong. The only band statement as specific to robin was as described above. It goes without saying that they will see how things stand when it comes to touring...that has nothing to do with robin in particular...duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Nope.  You are flat wrong.

"When we begin to put tour plans together we'll see where things are at. Until then, Robin's touring with NIN and we're working with management on our game plans."

http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?topic=51547.0

Ali

You have no clue?! Do you understand english? Yes, that was the statement. But, it is a general statement about touring. There was never anything said about their personal knowledge about what Robin said or what his plans are. Of course, they are working with management on a tour and yes, once they put together tour plans they will see where they are..Of course, that's true no matter what. The point here is what is up with Robin? They have told us nothing. What is your problem? Deal with reality and stop kissing someone's ass....Who are you trying to impress? Well, not me!

[loretian]

You have no clue?! Do you understand english? Yes, that was the statement. But, it is a general statement about touring. There was never anything said about their personal knowledge about what Robin said or what his plans are. Of course, they are working with management on a tour and yes, once they put together tour plans they will see where they are..Of course, that's true no matter what. The point here is what is up with Robin? They have told us nothing. What is your problem? Deal with reality and stop kissing someone's ass....Who are you trying to impress? Well, not me!

I think the statement is pretty clear.   It was in the Robin posting on guns n' roses.com.  Not that hard to understand, buddy. 

[Ali]

Wow, that seems like a bit of an overreaction.  Maybe the official word on Robin summed everything up perfectly?  When it is time to tour, then things will be addressed.  But now, is it really necessary?  I don't see how.

Ali

No.  The official word was "Only Robin knows what Robin's doing."


P.S.  Happy November 7th Birthday anyways, Robin. 

No, the official word was a bit more detailed than that.  It included that they will see how things stand when it comes time to tour.

Ali

Sorry, man. You are flat wrong. The only band statement as specific to robin was as described above. It goes without saying that they will see how things stand when it comes to touring...that has nothing to do with robin in particular...duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Nope.  You are flat wrong.

"When we begin to put tour plans together we'll see where things are at. Until then, Robin's touring with NIN and we're working with management on our game plans."

http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?topic=51547.0

Ali

You have no clue?! Do you understand english? Yes, that was the statement. But, it is a general statement about touring. There was never anything said about their personal knowledge about what Robin said or what his plans are. Of course, they are working with management on a tour and yes, once they put together tour plans they will see where they are..Of course, that's true no matter what. The point here is what is up with Robin? They have told us nothing. What is your problem? Deal with reality and stop kissing someone's ass....Who are you trying to impress? Well, not me!

Do I understand english?  Yes, I think so.  Very mature response, though.  Thanks for the chuckle.  I especially enjoyed the ass-kissing remark, though I have no idea whose ass it is I am attempting to kiss.

The point, which you seem to have missed, is that when it comes time to tour, Robin's status will be re-evaluated.  Until then, there are other matters at hand which are more pressing, obviously.  I don't see the ambiguity in that that would lead to any disagreement.

Ali

[whiny]

Wow, that seems like a bit of an overreaction.  Maybe the official word on Robin summed everything up perfectly?  When it is time to tour, then things will be addressed.  But now, is it really necessary?  I don't see how.

Ali

No.  The official word was "Only Robin knows what Robin's doing."


P.S.  Happy November 7th Birthday anyways, Robin. 

No, the official word was a bit more detailed than that.  It included that they will see how things stand when it comes time to tour.

Ali

Sorry, man. You are flat wrong. The only band statement as specific to robin was as described above. It goes without saying that they will see how things stand when it comes to touring...that has nothing to do with robin in particular...duhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhhh

Nope.  You are flat wrong.

"When we begin to put tour plans together we'll see where things are at. Until then, Robin's touring with NIN and we're working with management on our game plans."

http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?topic=51547.0

Ali

You have no clue?! Do you understand english? Yes, that was the statement. But, it is a general statement about touring. There was never anything said about their personal knowledge about what Robin said or what his plans are. Of course, they are working with management on a tour and yes, once they put together tour plans they will see where they are..Of course, that's true no matter what. The point here is what is up with Robin? They have told us nothing. What is your problem? Deal with reality and stop kissing someone's ass....Who are you trying to impress? Well, not me!

thanx for your contribution. that's really one of the worst posts ever. really misplaced.

[duasoul]

It looks like the band lineup has been updated on Guns' Myspace page, and Robin's not included:

http://www.myspace.com/gunsnroses

[ThatGuy]

i wonder what happened that may have led robin finck to walk away from guns n roses right before the release of the album he had helped create for nearly a decade...

[The Catcher]

How do you know it's been updated and that they didn't just overlook it? What did it say last time? Didn't it say nearly the same thing, except that maybe Brain was in, and yet we got an update from the band around the same time saying the situation with Robin is still not very clear?

[axlroses]

It really doesn't matter what the situation is right at this point anyways.  It only matters when they start touring.

[grog mug]

We need Robin and Buckethead to be a part of this band!  Give us some answers GN'R!!