Robin leaving? Just touring?

[November_Rain]

154 pages ... does he even know? ...

Robin's busy rehearsing and touring with NIN and probaly doesn't have time to read a thread of 154 pages.  Im sure he would probaly laugh at some of us who think he's left.  There's nothing going on in the GnR world as touring goes, hell he doesn't even have time to update his website let alone write a statement on his status in GnR.  The man is busy making a living give him some respect.

Yes. I always thought this NIN thing is just like a kind of side project like when Dizzy tours with his band...etc and people are reading too much into it. I bet Robin will be back when things in GNR are ready for the release and all that stuff.

[Ulises]

you again? maybe you don't deserve to be in a GNR forum since you keep blaming your lack of comprehension  on others

seriously all brain said is that he gotta get paid. Obviously it was a joke but at the same time I think it was sorta true. respect should be paid to these guys. they deserve it.

I don't like Brain so much. That's all. I don't like what he said...Did you read something about Robin or Richard or Tommy or any other member making jokes like that? Sorry if my opinion bothers you man 

And yes, me again. 


Ferrer  you're the man

[ppbebe]

I guess you don't like what you think he said.
According to richard brain gotta sick sense of humour. I happen to like it. Sorta like axl calls himself a king dick.

I donno but seemingly some are even offended by franks or ron's jokes...I really hope people chill out a bit.

[russtcb]

you again? maybe you don't deserve to be in a GNR forum since you keep blaming your lack of comprehension  on others

seriously all brain said is that he gotta get paid. Obviously it was a joke but at the same time I think it was sorta true. respect should be paid to these guys. they deserve it.

I don't like Brain so much. That's all. I don't like what he said...Did you read something about Robin or Richard or Tommy or any other member making jokes like that? Sorry if my opinion bothers you man 

And yes, me again. 


Ferrer  you're the man

I personally like Frank better then Brain as well.

[ppbebe]

I like them all. I win! 

really you don't need to dislike one to like the other, do you?

and wasn't this thread about Robin?

[Ulises]

I like them all. I win! 

really you don't need to dislike one to like the other, do you?

and wasn't this thread about Robin?

Yep.

I want him on Guns N' Roses. I don't care if he needs to play, i want him sit down waiting for Chinese Democracy!

[ppbebe]

I don't care if he needs to play, i want him sit down waiting for Chinese Democracy!

tell me you're sarcastic....

[russtcb]

I like them all. I win! 

really you don't need to dislike one to like the other, do you?

and wasn't this thread about Robin?

You're right on both counts.

And yes, this thread was about Robin. Who by the way, I think is much better fitted for GNR and I hope he's not out.

[mrbucketfoot]

Frank did an outstanding job in 2006/2007 and I'm glad to have him in the GN'R family, but Brain is "the" GN'R drummer in my opinion.
His power, his style, his charisma, everything just fits like a glove and really molds well.

Thanks to Brain there's a deeper musical texture there. To the old songs especially. It sounds new and powerful.

[Ulises]

I don't care if he needs to play, i want him sit down waiting for Chinese Democracy!

tell me you're sarcastic....

Not sarcastic. Selfish, yes

[downzy56]

In today's Toronto Star, they review last nights NIN show.  In the review, they refer to Robin as ex-Guns N' Roses guitarist. 

Not sure if this is based on factual knowledge or due to the fact that Robin is playing with NIN and there's little going on with GNR (other than Shackler's Revenge).

Cheers,

Andrew

[russtcb]

When they mentioned NINs lineup on Billboard a few months back, they referred to Robin as being "back from a stint in Guns N' Roses". I don't think it means much.

[Luigi]

^

It's just a stint with NIN for now.........

[gcluskey]

He's just earning a few bucks and enjoying playing guitar, if I were him I'd be doing the same. I wouldn't be flushing GnR down the toilet for it. He'll be back when he needs to be

[gearbm95]

Nice to see Trent is still taking shots at Axl...what does this say about Robin, anything?

From this month's Rolling Stone interview with NIN:

As an experiment, Reznor gave away a pair of tickets for the tour's dress rehearsal by hiding an envelope under a rock in Burbank. Using a Google Earth link on his Website, Reznor indicated the tickets' location with a question mark. Fans quickly found the envelope. "Well, we couldn't leave that alone," Reznor says. "We hid another 30, in places from Watts Towers to behind a mirror in a strip-club restroom to a Home Depot." One envelope was hidden in a graveyard; the location was announced after it had closed for the day: "We wanted to see if anyone would break in, because I would've. And someone did." Reznor contemplated providing the location of Axl Rose's house and encouraging people to dig in his yard for tickets, "just to see how many people got arrested on his front lawn."

[russtcb]

Nice to see Trent is still taking shots at Axl...what does this say about Robin, anything?

From this month's Rolling Stone interview with NIN:

As an experiment, Reznor gave away a pair of tickets for the tour's dress rehearsal by hiding an envelope under a rock in Burbank. Using a Google Earth link on his Website, Reznor indicated the tickets' location with a question mark. Fans quickly found the envelope. "Well, we couldn't leave that alone," Reznor says. "We hid another 30, in places from Watts Towers to behind a mirror in a strip-club restroom to a Home Depot." One envelope was hidden in a graveyard; the location was announced after it had closed for the day: "We wanted to see if anyone would break in, because I would've. And someone did." Reznor contemplated providing the location of Axl Rose's house and encouraging people to dig in his yard for tickets, "just to see how many people got arrested on his front lawn."

I don't get how that's a "shot at Axl" seems more like a dumb remark involving Axl's name.

[Voodoochild]

Ron said in the cd.com chat that he was invited by Robin to watch a NIN gig...

[*Timothy*]

seem to me Robin is still in and will be their when he is need to be .
 
Not as if none of the other guys are just sitting around. they all seem to be doing stuff while Axl and managment take care of the album stuff.

[AxlsMainMan]

Ron said in the cd.com chat that he was invited by Robin to watch a NIN gig...

Did Ron take Robin up on his offer?

[Voodoochild]

Here's what he said:

[Bumbumbleybumblefucker] 4:18 pm: Yes, will be Robin's guest at NIN in NJ in a few weeks....
[Bumbumbleybumblefucker] 4:19 pm: oh wait, I'm not PLAYING, just going to watch the show....!
[Bumbumbleybumblefucker] 4:20 pm: ***DAMAGE CONTROL ALERT*** I'm not performing with NIN ! ! !
[Bumbumbleybumblefucker] 4:21 pm: (just making sure y'all got that, lol)