Robin leaving? Just touring?

[Ines_rocks!]

wait a minute... Guns could go back to having two guitar players! 

If they didn't for the 2006-7 tours, why would they for the tour following the album's release? 



/jarmo

I was talking of the possibility (let?s hope not) of Robin leaving.

[Smoking Guns]

wait a minute... Guns could go back to having two guitar players! 

If they didn't for the 2006-7 tours, why would they for the tour following the album's release? 



/jarmo

It may sound better and clear up some stage space and save from having to pay another member.  Stripped down, like the old Skin and Bones tour.

[Neemo]

What you're trying to say is irrelevant when you choose to ignore facts so you can say whatever you are saying.

When you're shown facts that you choose to ignore, your comments become pretty irrelevant.

THERE ARE NO FACTS....dont you get it? if there are hard facts that you know that I dont then please enlighten me

heres all the FACTS that i know and all i've ever claimed to know....the rest is hearsay

http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/releases/newalbum.htm

You guys have spent 5 pages arguing something that is off topic to this discussion.   Wow. 

Not only is it off topic, that guy is just being a hypocrite and wrong about the album not being done.

your the one who kept it off topic after i tried to drop the discussion twice  

wait a minute... Guns could go back to having two guitar players! 

If they didn't for the 2006-7 tours, why would they for the tour following the album's release? 



/jarmo

I agree! 

[HBK]

^a nice current picture i see  

bandita beat me 

  I'm quick.

I can't possibly think anyone would take him seriously to book anything if he can't even get a correct photo of the band posted?

The Producers, just want SELL ... They were not interested in anything more ...

AXL for them while this is GUNS N 'ROSES.

HBK *

Guns N' Roses is a band, not just Axl.  It isn't helping the cause to promote things that are 20 years old.

Not to mention these rumours are everywhere, they mean nothing.  I even saw two shows listed on Facebook that GNR are supposed to be partaking in.  I wonder if they even know they are playing them?

If a tour was in the works we would know about it.

I am sure much more effort is being put into the release of CD right now.

Yes .. Bandita ... But I say to what they say ... PHOTO echo of that is 87 and 92 brought another LINE UP ...

I for a little more I have to go with the theme, but try to put a aelante CURRENT PHOTO ..

That party sees ANOTHER Producer.

PATIENCE.

 HBK *

[Ines_rocks!]

wait a minute... Guns could go back to having two guitar players! 

If they didn't for the 2006-7 tours, why would they for the tour following the album's release? 



/jarmo

It may sound better and clear up some stage space and save from having to pay another member.  Stripped down, like the old Skin and Bones tour.

talking of clearing up some stage space.. this way when Izzy goes back to play some gigs, we will have some more room to play around!   

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S4HDerVjLN8&feature=related

(just kiddin...  )

[Neemo]

You guys have spent 5 pages arguing something that is off topic to this discussion.   Wow. 

Not only is it off topic, that guy is just being a hypocrite and wrong about the album not being done.







/jarmo

if the album is done then what is the tracklist  

[jarmo]

Well I think they know what is needed.

GN'R has been a three guitar band for a while now.

You've had some time to get used to it.....

THERE ARE NO FACTS....dont you get it? if there are hard facts that you know that I dont then please enlighten me

Oh God.

I guess in your world if somebody says something, it's not a fact.

Baz has said so for example.

It was on gunsnroses.com in early 2007 that recording was finished and mixing had started. Another example.


Maybe you can ask your source since he/she seems to have a better idea than people who are actually involved with GN'R.

if the album is done then what is the tracklist 

King Of Comedy.




/jarmo

[HBK]

wait a minute... Guns could go back to having two guitar players! 

If they didn't for the 2006-7 tours, why would they for the tour following the album's release? 



/jarmo

It may sound better and clear up some stage space and save from having to pay another member.  Stripped down, like the old Skin and Bones tour.

talking of clearing up some stage space.. this way when Izzy goes back to play some gigs, we will have some more room to play around!   

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=S4HDerVjLN8&feature=related

(just kiddin...  )

TOMMY In DRUMS...

Us GOD.

HBK *

[Bodhi]

i wil maintain my opinion that Robin Finck is not exactly the biggest loss Guns N Roses have ever had....why dont you guys wait and see what the band says is going to happen with their guitar player situation instead of just assuming shit....I really dont think Robin Finck will make or break CD coming out whenever it is going to come out

[jarmo]

why dont you guys wait and see what the band says is going to happen with their guitar player situation instead of just assuming shit....I really dont think Robin Finck will make or break CD coming out whenever it is going to come out

You should get a golden star for that.

That's basically what it comes down to.

Wait and see.





/jarmo

[Smoking Guns]

why dont you guys wait and see what the band says is going to happen with their guitar player situation instead of just assuming shit....I really dont think Robin Finck will make or break CD coming out whenever it is going to come out

You should get a golden star for that.

That's basically what it comes down to.

Wait and see.





/jarmo

Ha, at some point all of us in this thread said the same thing... Ha!  Then our minds wander.  But I agree with what he said. 

[Ines_rocks!]

why dont you guys wait and see what the band says is going to happen with their guitar player situation instead of just assuming shit....I really dont think Robin Finck will make or break CD coming out whenever it is going to come out

You should get a golden star for that.

That's basically what it comes down to.

Wait and see.





/jarmo

I want a golden star too! I made a funny joke to bring some good humour in this thread! 


haha 

[bazgnr]

Whether Robin stays or goes, CD will push on, as will Axl, his vision, and the music of Guns 'n Roses.  It's far bigger than any one guitar player, that's for sure.  

That said, I hope Robin stays in the picture.  If nothing else, he deserves a Dr. Pepper.    

[Bandita]

I have no idea how this thread fell into if CD is actually done or not but I can't believe there is even 1 person left on this board that doesn't believe it is.  Apparently, word from Sebastian or even members of GNR isn't good enough for you?

As for Robin, well, it would suck if he was gone but I don't think it is going to have the devastating effect on the band that some of you think it will.

Last I checked there had been 3 very capable men playing guitar in GNR.

[bazgnr]

Well, that'll teach me to make a tongue-in-cheek remark before checking around.

In the meantime, I refuse to take anybody's "official" word until I find it on the GnR site and we hear from Axl or the band.

[Smoking Guns]

GNR is like Whitesnake, Ozzy, or Dio, they always have killer guitar players.

[Nytunz]

Robin leaving GNR would be incredible SAD!
But lets hope he`s still in.. Thats what i hope and think...

[greendog]

It may sound better and clear up some stage space and save from having to pay another member.  Stripped down, like the old Skin and Bones tour.

Yes, because with out Robin... ONE member, the band is totally stripped. Like, almost acoustic maaaan. 

[Feel_The_Burn]

The only part i found suspicious was

More recently, he played in Guns N Roses. Fownes has been performing with UNKLE, and has been a member of With Scissors and The Eighties Matchbox B-Line Disaster.

Sounds past tense , as if it is done and over with. I mean Trent always has people coming in out of NIN this could just be a tour deal and thats it. I don't see everyone is jumping to conclusions. It would really suck to see him go out of the 3 I always favored Robin's playing a little bit more.

[gunns1]

The only part i found suspicious was

More recently, he played in Guns N Roses. Fownes has been performing with UNKLE, and has been a member of With Scissors and The Eighties Matchbox B-Line Disaster.

Sounds past tense , as if it is done and over with. I mean Trent always has people coming in out of NIN this could just be a tour deal and thats it. I don't see everyone is jumping to conclusions. It would really suck to see him go out of the 3 I always favored Robin's playing a little bit more.

true , I mean, the dude wrote better,
if we lost him, whos going to play it live now? I cant see anyone else play that song,
its fincks, and the blues solo.......


I hope we hear from the gnr camp in the next day or so...