Robin leaving? Just touring?

[Rockin' Rose]

I'm not so worried about this, so what that Robin is off to play with NiN live, good for him.

If CD isn't out until the end of the year this is a good thing for both bands, theres always new fans, every year, a kid sees NiN live, is amazed by Robin and can't find many original albums with him but wait, there is one album coming out soon..

Besides, even if CD drops in September that doesn't mean they have to start the tour right away, few shows here and there, then the world tour.

But if he would leave, I'd be sad, he might be a bit sloppy sometimes but the energy he brings to the shows, Maddy is not the same anymore without Bucket just like Better would not be the same without Robin

I'm sure he comes back when the time comes, just like Brain

[chriskon72]

I'm not so worried about this, so what that Robin is off to play with NiN live, good for him.

If CD isn't out until the end of the year this is a good thing for both bands, theres always new fans, every year, a kid sees NiN live, is amazed by Robin and can't find many original albums with him but wait, there is one album coming out soon..

Besides, even if CD drops in September that doesn't mean they have to start the tour right away, few shows here and there, then the world tour.

But if he would leave, I'd be sad, he might be a bit sloppy sometimes but the energy he brings to the shows, Maddy is not the same anymore without Bucket just like Better would not be the same without Robin

I'm sure he comes back when the time comes, just like Brain

 you are a very positive person. 

[AxlsMainMan]

Its about loyalty

if u are in GUNS N ROSES u dont join other bands and tour the world.

Side projects or solo things are ok cause they are smaller level things.

NIN is a huge thing

u dont go from GNR to NIN


If u want me to take this band seriously as GNR, these guys should be dedicated and committed TO GNR and not going back and forth with major bands.

Uh..and who are you to tell other people how they should live their lives?

[ppbebe]

I thought Trent didn't want to do the whole "Rock Band" kind of tour again?

How can you say that now? They havent played a single event.

I think he said that after the china tour?

[Fingers]

I wonder if Robin is still under contract with GNR, did it run out

[Verse Chorus Verse]

I thought Trent didn't want to do the whole "Rock Band" kind of tour again?

How can you say that now? They havent played a single event.

"The idea of five guys playing loud music two hours, while it's the culmination of fine tuning over a lot of years, has got to change once finances come into play, especially performing in markets outside of the mainland U.S. I want to whittle things down."

"at this point, I want to switch things around a bit. Nine Inch Nails as a rock band configuration, we've done it and we've done it again. I see other ways I can present the material in concert, more challenging, something new. I don't want it to go stale."

http://starbulletin.com/2007/09/14/features/story05.html

[ppbebe]

why the hysteria?

The album is ready and robin is on it.
bh is on it brain is on it. bumble is on it frank is on it.

10 is greater than 8. and 9.

[Tatiana Kudrin]

At some point in 06, (or 07?) someone in ETS asked Reznor about  the random bitter sounding remarks of Robin.

The circa 05 great Robin slander was because they did intially ask Finck to take part in With Teeth tour,  but instead of just giving a straight "yes" or a "no"Robin  kinda stalled everything by not being able to decide in reasonable timeline.

Above isn't an accurate word-to word quote but that essentially was what TR was saying.

In an interview released in my country in 2005, Trent was quoted as saying about Robin being happy as he was  waiting for a 'hypothetical' move by Axl. As regards as the quote I posted, it's from memory because it got deleted from the site where I got it censored. Maybe I shouldn't have used those ' '  for the quote isn't exact  but I wanted to point out this isn't my opinion. Actually I find that comment pretty mean.
I wasn't aware that Aaron's presence among NIN members was the result of Robin's lack of decision...

[Howard2k]

it's not her real name.
but she's the CEO of Geffen

and she's a spokeperson for GNR sometimes.
from her we get info that's all I can say

Doug Morris?

[ppbebe]

He was bitter as he missed robin. no biggy.

[ppbebe]

it's not her real name.
but she's the CEO of Geffen

and she's a spokeperson for GNR sometimes.
from her we get info that's all I can say

Doug Morris?

someone who wrote a bogus cd promo plan.

[makane]

I thought Trent didn't want to do the whole "Rock Band" kind of tour again?

How can you say that now? They havent played a single event.

"The idea of five guys playing loud music two hours, while it's the culmination of fine tuning over a lot of years, has got to change once finances come into play, especially performing in markets outside of the mainland U.S. I want to whittle things down."

"at this point, I want to switch things around a bit. Nine Inch Nails as a rock band configuration, we've done it and we've done it again. I see other ways I can present the material in concert, more challenging, something new. I don't want it to go stale."

http://starbulletin.com/2007/09/14/features/story05.html

And? As far as I know, they could be doing acoustic performances only. Or they could all play banjos. Finck returning doesn't necessarily mean a ROCK BAND? performance.

[Crowebar]

I will cut my balls off with a rusty Hindu blade if Fink quites the band now.

No, you won't.   

[ppbebe]

lets not go semantic makane

[dolphin]

I don't see what the big deal is here.  Hasn't Axl always allowed his members to persue other things when GNR weren't active?  I mean, when Tommy went to do some shows and tour with Soul Asylum, everyone acted the same way as they are now with "Tommy's out of GNR.  Oh my god, Tommy quit., etc".

 

[greekmule]

i hope Robin did not leave but even if he has we have suffered worse...

[Fingers]

I think the reasons are when Robin went back the last time he said in so many words he was tired of waiting around-I'm not sure if his contract is up, or how much it is, but he is probably looking at a good payday touring with NIN

[ppbebe]

But he came back. and the band became 8

people here love fuss and feathers.

[guns_n_motley]

I think if this is true and Robin is out, I don't think he is someone that can be replaced, he and tommy are the only people from the first show 01/01/01 that are still in the band.  so if Finck is out ... that would suck !

so they survived slash/izzy leaving but cant survive finck?? do some of you realise what you are saying??

[ppbebe]

By the time I got here / and izzy were long gone. 

It wasn't long until I heard BH's departure. Nothing can hurt me anymore.