SCOM in the film "big daddy"

[Voodoochild]

Tell me when exactly he's out of tune on this recording.

[GnR-NOW]

it sounds like its Finck playing when the song switches, the way he stresses the solo live sounds similar, but who really knows ..........

[lakersaregreat]

it sounds like its Finck playing when the song switches, the way he stresses the solo live sounds similar, but who really knows ..........

its robin, 100% and it's great. he makes the solo his own and makes it much better than slash's.....much....

[LawsonsLaw007]

the movie sucks but i think its is robin but how the hell would i know

Peace

[Voodoochild]

Why people even have doubts if it's Robin when we all know for sure it's him? Despite the obvious common sense (because his playing and tone is 100% recognizable), I'm pretty sure there is a lot of articles on HTGTH main page stating it is indeed Robin.

[Feel_The_Burn]

Tell me when exactly he's out of tune on this recording.

3:17 and 3:18 , the bends are real nasty.

[Voodoochild]

LOL, just because he bends slowly you think he's out of tune?

[DeN]

rock n'roll is nasty, anyway.

[cai666]

it sounds like its Finck playing when the song switches, the way he stresses the solo live sounds similar, but who really knows ..........

its robin, 100% and it's great. he makes the solo his own and makes it much better than slash's.....much....

much better than slash`s??  WTF??
I can not believe this...

[Bruno Poeys]

i've always thought the old band played the first part, then the new band starts playing at about 3 minutes. the tone seems different to me before and after 3 minutes. Nothing wrong with Robin's bends, by the way. If you want to hear a really ridiculous and out of tune bend, listen to the Slash's solo on you could be mine (near the end, there's a bend that hurt my ears): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVV0qlukPVw

[Angel Down]

That is the sound of The Slash. 

[Voodoochild]

And that sucks!

[Feel_The_Burn]

i've always thought the old band played the first part, then the new band starts playing at about 3 minutes. the tone seems different to me before and after 3 minutes. Nothing wrong with Robin's bends, by the way. If you want to hear a really ridiculous and out of tune bend, listen to the Slash's solo on you could be mine (near the end, there's a bend that hurt my ears): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVV0qlukPVw

From what I hear NR Slash is the best

BH is really good , but doesn't fit the song , his note choice.

Bubmlefoot is by far the lower of the 3 to me , the tone is off , and its random shredding.


Nightrain.........Sorry but come on Slash OWNS that solo. Once again BH comes 2nd , very close second at that though , it's his note choice that throws me off I favor the blues'y style of Slash compared to BH note choice , his tremolo picking is bad ASS though.  'Foot is once again last to me , he is just hitting stuff at least BH made it into his own creation.

I didn't see YCBM anywhere there?

[lakersaregreat]

i've always thought the old band played the first part, then the new band starts playing at about 3 minutes. the tone seems different to me before and after 3 minutes. Nothing wrong with Robin's bends, by the way. If you want to hear a really ridiculous and out of tune bend, listen to the Slash's solo on you could be mine (near the end, there's a bend that hurt my ears): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVV0qlukPVw

From what I hear NR Slash is the best

BH is really good , but doesn't fit the song , his note choice.

Bubmlefoot is by far the lower of the 3 to me , the tone is off , and its random shredding.


Nightrain.........Sorry but come on Slash OWNS that solo. Once again BH comes 2nd , very close second at that though , it's his note choice that throws me off I favor the blues'y style of Slash compared to BH note choice , his tremolo picking is bad ASS though.  'Foot is once again last to me , he is just hitting stuff at least BH made it into his own creation.

I didn't see YCBM anywhere there?

Buckethead owns them ALL, especially NT! Go listen to Rio 2001 and HOB 2001.......Slash 2nd, Ron distant 3rd...

[Feel_The_Burn]

i've always thought the old band played the first part, then the new band starts playing at about 3 minutes. the tone seems different to me before and after 3 minutes. Nothing wrong with Robin's bends, by the way. If you want to hear a really ridiculous and out of tune bend, listen to the Slash's solo on you could be mine (near the end, there's a bend that hurt my ears): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVV0qlukPVw

From what I hear NR Slash is the best

BH is really good , but doesn't fit the song , his note choice.

Bubmlefoot is by far the lower of the 3 to me , the tone is off , and its random shredding.


Nightrain.........Sorry but come on Slash OWNS that solo. Once again BH comes 2nd , very close second at that though , it's his note choice that throws me off I favor the blues'y style of Slash compared to BH note choice , his tremolo picking is bad ASS though.  'Foot is once again last to me , he is just hitting stuff at least BH made it into his own creation.

I didn't see YCBM anywhere there?

Buckethead owns them ALL, especially NT! Go listen to Rio 2001 and HOB 2001.......Slash 2nd, Ron distant 3rd...

I think BH and Slash have such different styles it's really what appeals to your ear , if you like BH note choice you chose him if you like Slash's you chose him.

[lakersaregreat]

i've always thought the old band played the first part, then the new band starts playing at about 3 minutes. the tone seems different to me before and after 3 minutes. Nothing wrong with Robin's bends, by the way. If you want to hear a really ridiculous and out of tune bend, listen to the Slash's solo on you could be mine (near the end, there's a bend that hurt my ears): http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XVV0qlukPVw

From what I hear NR Slash is the best

BH is really good , but doesn't fit the song , his note choice.

Bubmlefoot is by far the lower of the 3 to me , the tone is off , and its random shredding.


Nightrain.........Sorry but come on Slash OWNS that solo. Once again BH comes 2nd , very close second at that though , it's his note choice that throws me off I favor the blues'y style of Slash compared to BH note choice , his tremolo picking is bad ASS though.  'Foot is once again last to me , he is just hitting stuff at least BH made it into his own creation.

I didn't see YCBM anywhere there?

Buckethead owns them ALL, especially NT! Go listen to Rio 2001 and HOB 2001.......Slash 2nd, Ron distant 3rd...

I think BH and Slash have such different styles it's really what appeals to your ear , if you like BH note choice you chose him if you like Slash's you chose him.

totally agree with that! im just blown away with bh's work ....

[cotis]

I just love how nearly EVERY discussion here turns into a Slash vs. Robin or Bucket vs. Robin.

 

[ppbebe]

I just love how nearly EVERY discussion here turns into a Slash vs. Robin or Bucket vs. Robin.

 

where's the bucket vs Robin one? I haven't seen it for ages.

[Bruno Poeys]

Nah, it's mostly robin x slash and bucket x ron.

[cotis]

I just love how nearly EVERY discussion here turns into a Slash vs. Robin or Bucket vs. Robin.

 

where's the bucket vs Robin one? I haven't seen it for ages.

meant to say Ron.

but regardless, nearly every conversation ends up with one of them.