GNR Finish CD?

[misterID]

I might have missed it, but was it proven that Richard's e-mail was fake, and the Beta interview was fake, where they stated it was turned in?

[mrbucketfoot]

The interview with Beta is under dispute because apparently the mag twisted some of her words. However, according to them she said that the album was done and everybody knew it.

Baz said that Axl was serious about putting out the album and said he was finishing liner notes implying that it was done. After Baz said that there were business issues preventing release Ron said "and that's all we're saying about that". Apparently Ron also told a fan that the record company was somewhat to blame which adds to credence that the Richard E-Mail is true.

So, it's pretty much a certainty outside of GNR announcing it. If they were to release a "the record's handed in" statement, I'd get excited about the album. But yeah.

[gunns1]

but its all still just rumours based on assumption,

its not really true and hasnt been stated that the record has indeed been handed in yet...

This would be a good time for the band to inform its fans...

[norway]

This is just another of many excuses for not being able to produce a finished product.

Either you deliver a product when it's done or not, be it homework, medicine or CD's.

Axl is in position where there is no deadlines and not so much financial limitations (compared) so can spend a lot of time getting it done.
Time will show anyway if you are right or wrong that he "is not able to produce a finisihed product"

[misterID]

The interview with Beta is under dispute because apparently the mag twisted some of her words. However, according to them she said that the album was done and everybody knew it.

Baz said that Axl was serious about putting out the album and said he was finishing liner notes implying that it was done. After Baz said that there were business issues preventing release Ron said "and that's all we're saying about that". Apparently Ron also told a fan that the record company was somewhat to blame which adds to credence that the Richard E-Mail is true.

So, it's pretty much a certainty outside of GNR announcing it. If they were to release a "the record's handed in" statement, I'd get excited about the album. But yeah.

Well, that explains some of it then. Didn't know the mag was accused of twisting her words. Thanks

[Bartlet]

just coz the label have it (allegedly) doesnt necassarily mean theyd release it straight away. it has already been rumoured (confirmed...?) that they were refusing to enter in to any negotiations til they had the album in their hands.

given the history as we understand it, it makes sene.

[Ak1nney]

So the cd is officially done? I've been out of the loop...

[jarmo]

So the cd is officially done? I've been out of the loop...

Yeah.


Q: What do you think is the biggest misconception people have about Axl Rose?

Sebastian: "They think that 'Chinese Democracy' is never coming out... that is #1 misconception, 'cause I've heard it... like, it exists. To me I think it has a lot more to do with the business side of it. I've heard four albums' worth of material that's incredible. So when people go 'Is it ever coming out?', I go 'Yeah! And you're gonna feel stupid when it does.'




/jarmo

[The Chad Cometh]

When it does arrive, I wonder how many people on these boards are going to come out and say they were wrong. The number of times I've read some random post on these boards about the album never coming out is getting ridiculous. 

[slashsbaconpit]

When it does arrive, I wonder how many people on these boards are going to come out and say they were wrong. The number of times I've read some random post on these boards about the album never coming out is getting ridiculous. 

I'd be happy to come and say I was wrong for doubting that it's ever coming out, because that means it would be out! That'd be AWESOME!

[bodine]

When it does arrive, I wonder how many people on these boards are going to come out and say they were wrong. The number of times I've read some random post on these boards about the album never coming out is getting ridiculous. 

Alternatively, how long do you wait before you say the naysayers were right?   

[Jaakko]

Alternatively, how long do you wait before you say the naysayers were right?   

Next phase in GNR-saga: fans go philosophic 

Someone said in some thread (who needs search-function ?) that it took about 15 months after Bumblefoot joined to get the record finished, so it shouldn't be impossible that we will see Chinese Democracy out, perhaps this year. Lots of things have happened these past 2 years, since the band became finished.

Come on, record has been in companys hands about three months, so where not talking of long wait YET. So, everyone can feel happy if we just forget 1994-2005...

Maybe I should go to bed cause this post makes no sense.

[ppbebe]

Come on, record has been in companys hands about three months,

I wouldn't be so sure. and 3 months? Am I missing something?

Alternatively, how long do you wait before you say the naysayers were right?   

right about what?

[bodine]

Alternatively, how long do you wait before you say the naysayers were right?   

right about what?

What was I replying to?  I thought it was pretty straight-forward.  I do think eventually the thing will be released, but people really show their blind loyalty by acting like anyone with a pessemistic view is an idiot. 

[jarmo]

anyone with a pessemistic view is an idiot. 

Ask Baz! 




/jarmo

[ppbebe]

What was I replying to?  I thought it was pretty straight-forward.  I do think eventually the thing will be released, but people really show their blind loyalty by acting like anyone with a pessemistic view is an idiot. 

Me too thought my question was clear. about what naysayers were right?
axl can't sing? the album doesn't exist?

[bodine]

Me too thought my question was clear. about what naysayers were right?

No no no . . .  Go back and read your own post, you didn't ask what naysayers, you asked "right about what".  Which I went ahead and answered again for you.  And no I never said anything about CD not existing. 

[ppbebe]

I thought you were not a naysayer? 

 naysayers or the naysayers, I meant the same. Back to your original q
Tommy has said naysayers can fuck off.

[bodine]

I thought you were not a naysayer? 

I'm not, but I think it's understandable that there's a whole lot of 'em.   

[kingcanute]

NAY!