Neemo's Greatest Movie of All-Time Survivor (Top 5)

[Neemo]

In "Greatest Movie Survivor", fire represents death, when the Movie's credits roll, the movie goes up in flames, when the names are read, the decision is final and they must leave the tribal council area immediately. I'll go tally the votes.

Goodfellas, bring me your torch.



The Tribe has spoken.


Thanks to all who participated in this marathon its def been an up and down road. Also i'm kinda shocked at the top 5 but what can ya do i suppose when a bunch of people vote then the results aren't always what you'd expect

[Neemo]

#5 - A Clockwork Orange (1971)

Director - Stanley Kubrick
Writers - Anthony Burgess (novel); Stanley Kubrick (screenplay)
Starring - Malcolm McDowell

[Neemo]

#4 - Pulp Fiction (1994)

Director - Quentin Tarantino
Writers - Quentin Tarantino; Roger Avary
Starring -? Tim Roth; John Travolta; Samuel L. Jackson; Amanda Plummer; Eric Stoltz; Bruce Willis; Ving Rhames; Uma Thurman

[Neemo]

#3 - The Shawshank Redemption (1994)

Director: Frank Darabont
Writers: Stephen King (story); Frank Darabont (screenplay)
Starring: Tim Robbins; Morgan Freeman; Bob Gunton; Clancy Brown

[Neemo]

#2 - Goodfellas (1990)

Director: Martin Scorsese
Writers: Nicholas Pileggi (book); Nicholas Pileggi & Martin Scorsese (screenplay)
Starring: Robert De Niro; Ray Liotta; Joe Pesci; Lorraine Bracco; Paul Sorvino

[Neemo]

#1 - The Godfather (1972)

Director: Francis Ford Coppola
Writer: Mario Puzo (novel); Mario Puzo & Francis Ford Coppola (screenplay)
Starring: Marlon Brando; Al Pacino; James Caan; Robert Duvall; Diane Keaton

[Genesis]

Pretty ok list.
Am I the only one who hates "A Clockwork Orange"? One of the crappiest movies I've seen. 

[Where is Hassan Nasrallah ?]

Pretty ok list.
Am I the only one who hates "A Clockwork Orange"? One of the crappiest movies I've seen. 

so basically you hate the only original movie in the list?

this is the most mainstream top 5 i have ever seen - beside clockwork -. there are so many amazing movies in the world, and eveytime we have a top 5; we get pulp fiction and the godfather.

i mean ?!!! Pulp Fiction? you like this movie when you're 13?

[Timothy]

Pretty ok list.
Am I the only one who hates "A Clockwork Orange"? One of the crappiest movies I've seen. 

so basically you hate the only original movie in the list?

this is the most mainstream top 5 i have ever seen - beside clockwork -. there are so many amazing movies in the world, and eveytime we have a top 5; we get pulp fiction and the godfather.

i mean ?!!! Pulp Fiction? you like this movie when you're 13?

why is clockwork original? It's is just a mixture of diffrent generas.

what counts as being original? The truth is it;s all opinions and people can have different opinions. Now you and I may not agree with it but doesn't mean their opinions are any less valid.

How do you choose a best of all time.. is it the best made , the movie you like the most, ect...

[Genesis]

so basically you hate the only original movie in the list?

Original in what way? It was adapted from Antony Burgess's novel.
I just found the movie boring that's all.

i mean ?!!! Pulp Fiction? you like this movie when you're 13?

Perhaps, but now that's an original movie.

[Where is Hassan Nasrallah ?]

Original in the form, the shape, the content. The message.
It is complete. It's a real movie.


But anyway, you guys have to agree that these movies are very much mainstream. it would be like ranking the American Psycho book over Victor Hugo or Kafka ....

i'd call the survivor  Neemo's Greatest Mainstream Movie of All-Time Survivor

[Timothy]

Original in the form, the shape, the content. The message.
It is complete. It's a real movie.


But anyway, you guys have to agree that these movies are very much mainstream. it would be like ranking the American Psycho book over Victor Hugo or Kafka ....

i'd call the survivor  Neemo's Greatest Mainstream Movie of All-Time Survivor

While i don't agree with clockwork being original . I do agree with the rest of what u said.

[Genesis]

Well, when you have a movie survivor, it has to be about movies that everyone has seen. Or how would it work otherwise? So there's nothing wrong with the movies being "mainstream".

[Danny Top Hat]

Al 5 films in the list are excellent. ?A Clockwork Orange should have won it because it is simply better than the others. ?'Original' isn't the point, it's powerful and inventive with incredible music and dialogue and a really good story. ?It's unique and a masterpiece so LOVE IT!

Shawshank is a really powerful film and I like it a lot but I preferred the Green Mile and wouldn't have either film near the top 5.

Pulp Fiction was unlucky not to win it I reakon. ?It's ultimately cool - everyone should love Pulp Fiction!

The Godfather - very good film. ?I'm glad it beat Goodfellas cause it's a lot better.. ?A worthy winner in that is probably is one of the best movies of all time, though it wouldn't have been my choice.

Goodfellas just doesn't belong there.

[Neemo]

Goodfellas just doesn't belong there.

i gotta agree

[Timothy]

Goodfellas just doesn't belong there.

i gotta agree

your both fucking wrong well in my opinion.

but to each their own...

[Axl4Prez2004]

Opinions are like assholes, right?  Everyone's got one. 

The subjectivity is what makes it fun. 

I'm happy that my #1 made it as far as it did, to #3.