TWAT Discussion - your opinions

[Reinaldo]

It's fucking amazing!!!
Considering it's a demo, the song has everything to be a new GNR classic.
This is one of those multi-layer tunes Tommy mentioned in one of his interviews: lots of guitars, strings, some synths, great backing vocals, a piano, axl sounds awesome...

I just miss the bass (not only on this one but in all these newest tracks). Can't hear it at all. The song is so good that I even forget about the drums, which I still think is the weakest part of all the new songs (I really don't think Brain fits GNR right).

This tune will really kick ass when/if they play it live!

[Gaymo, the Hobbit]

it's a drum machine,dude. i think the drumming on the album will be awsome

[Lesty]

The mix is too muddled for me to really gauge whether I like it.
I'm so used to the incredible production on past GnR songs, it's hard to listen to the demos that have been leaked.
I have faith that the final versions will sound amazing, and possibly, quite different than these tracks.

[Reinaldo]

it's a drum machine,dude. i think the drumming on the album will be awsome

Doesn't sound like they're using the machine.
But even on live tunes (blues, madagascar, CD, the old songs, etc) I don't like Brain.
Hope you're right about the album anyway.

[dENIS]

I think the ext version of TWAT and guitars in second part is amazing!!!

[Thorned Rose]

The solo in this song is very long, and the solo itself is better then Mettalica's last album 

TWAT has potential... I love that solo, it is wicked....

[Sakib]

its starts off ok-ish and then all of a sudden up to the guitar solo till the end of the song, it amazing. i really love it

[mikegiuliana]

it's a really good tune, has high points and low points.. I think the song could be shortened a bit.. Has the estranged vibe with the voice.. I like the little bends in the guitar..  Sometimes I think the vocals clash witht eh playing.. yes I know it's a demo..

[dave-gnfnr2k]

it's a drum machine,dude. i think the drumming on the album will be awsome

Doesn't sound like they're using the machine.
But even on live tunes (blues, madagascar, CD, the old songs, etc) I don't like Brain.
Hope you're right about the album anyway.

Brain has a good groove much like Steven did. I have seen Brain with gnr, Primus and BH and he is really great

[Gaymo, the Hobbit]

i don't know, but right now twat is my theme for all those festival confirmations.. it makes me think about how great this summer will be...
i love living right now

[Smoking Guns]

I can't remember the songs that well.  Its like I can't remember a true riff.  I go to my guitar and I can't think of anything really that cool to learn from any of the songs so far.  I think I am already burnt out on them.  I like IRS, Twat, and Better, but, the lead guitar melody is just not catching me at all.  Am I the only one?  I like the songs, but they just aren't sticking in my brain like I thought. Other then Ax's voice, there isn't much to take away from these.

[ARC]

Can you imagine how good this song will be on the record...

The final three minutes are just amazing.

[Smoking Guns]

They are good, but, jeez, I just don't know.  Something is just missing.  Too robotic.  Like pink floyd, but not all the way.  I just can't figure it out.  He is going to struggle really bad with this song live.  It sounds very demanding vocally.  I like the wah guitar, very simple, but good.  I hear the playing, it is good, but sounds underinspired or something.  Sounds like Tom morello at times.  WHere as IRS sounds like straight up Zakk Wylde.

[gunner mad]

i don't know, but right now twat is my theme for all those festival confirmations.. it makes me think about how great this summer will be...
i love living right now

Ain't that the truth  

[metallex78]

The solo in this song is very long, and the solo itself is better then Mettalica's last album?

Who are Mettalica, never heard of them?

[MR W,AXL ROSE]

this song will be the final song on the new tours.instead of PC.the outro would bring the curtains down perfectaly on each show.i can imagine all the yellow and red confetti floating down on my ed as axl sings "yeah there was a time,do ye wanna know it all,do ye wanna know it all nowwwwwwww.i would do anything for youuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuuu" .i have fukin goosepimpels now just imagining that 

[Eazy E]

This is my favourite new song, no question.  The first of these new songs that I didn't need to let "settle in", it hit me right over the head, and I've only listened to it over crappy speakers so far, I need to get it on my ipod.

[scawl18]

I like the beginning and the end is going to be awesome..but i think the chorus REALLY SUCKS!

it was the wrong the time for you
it was the wrong the time for me
it was the wrong time for everyone

i think that part is terrible or sounds terrible...just a bunch of noise.

[Gunner17]

This song keeps growing on me...I like it the best out of the three

[Krispy Kreme]

I did not like any of the 3 new  songs  at  all at first listen, but after a few listens  TWAT is the best of the 3, and is not bad. Which is not to say it even  begins to measure up to the older stuff, but at  least it is listenable. Can't say the same for Better, which is wretched, and IRS, which is mediocre at best, if I am drunk and very desperate.