"Better" - discuss it in this thread

[D]

Exactly right, The Blues at RIR3 willa lways be my fav version.


LIke I have said a million times, I can listen to the RIR3 version continously and it moves me and breaks me out in gooseflesh.


The 2002 and 06 versions put me to sleep.

[Randy Jesus]

If you click on properties, it says its track #1 unlike the previous demo.

[D]

If its not real explain?

[Death Cube K]

LIke I have said a million times, I can listen to the RIR3 version continously and it moves me and breaks me out in gooseflesh.

And I always had a feeling they just played it too fast and settled with the final version (or what appears to be)

Doesnt really do anything besides touching on your subjective opinions about songs...everyone has them.

[russtcb]

As I listen to this more, I honestly can't see how people aren't 100% in love with it.

I find it to be amazing.

Let's put it this way, my band covers Better and our drummer *hates* the song. After he heard the new one last night, now he loves it. It's that good.

[gandra]

well,in my car in last 4 months only one disc is in the cd "rock am ring part 1"

My girlfriend doesn't like gnr music,but she likes "better

And i'm sure better have commercial potential

[polluxlm]

As I listen to this more, I honestly can't see how people aren't 100% in love with it.

I find it to be amazing.

Let's put it this way, my band covers Better and our drummer *hates* the song. After he heard the new one last night, now he loves it. It's that good.

It seems the fanbase is pretty divided on this. I personally can't stand this version, don't even enjoy listening to it.

[russtcb]

As I listen to this more, I honestly can't see how people aren't 100% in love with it.

I find it to be amazing.

Let's put it this way, my band covers Better and our drummer *hates* the song. After he heard the new one last night, now he loves it. It's that good.

It seems the fanbase is pretty divided on this. I personally can't stand this version, don't even enjoy listening to it.

Not even the "Now I, Now I" change around 4:09??

[Death Cube K]

Let's put it this way, my band covers Better and our drummer *hates* the song

Well, the demo version fronts a drum machine?? No wonder he hates it 

[russtcb]

Let's put it this way, my band covers Better and our drummer *hates* the song

Well, the demo version fronts a drum machine?? No wonder he hates it 

Hahaha.....Actually he's just not a big GNR fan in the first place.

But last night after listening to this one, we got out of the car and on the way into the bar he said "Wow, Axl might just make me a fan yet!".

[stvyrayvhn]

Just my two cents...
I like it.

-Larry

[D]

As I listen to this more, I honestly can't see how people aren't 100% in love with it.

I find it to be amazing.

Let's put it this way, my band covers Better and our drummer *hates* the song. After he heard the new one last night, now he loves it. It's that good.

Your drummer sounds like an idiot no offense.

The new version isnt that much different than the old one, its still the same notes, melodies and lyrics just cleaned up a bit.

[Death Cube K]

The new version isnt that much different than the old one, its still the same notes, melodies and lyrics just cleaned up a bit.

Sounds taken infront, others going back, clean drums, more sounds, less guitars, more guitars. But its still much of the same.

[D]

LIke I have said a million times, I can listen to the RIR3 version continously and it moves me and breaks me out in gooseflesh.

And I always had a feeling they just played it too fast and settled with the final version (or what appears to be)

Doesnt really do anything besides touching on your subjective opinions about songs...everyone has them.

U are missing my point.

U hear a version and u get so use to that version that it is almost impossible to accept any other version.


had I never heard RIR3, Id probably love the 06 version but since I heard RIR3 first, no other version compares. that was my point about leaks.

U get use to an unfinished product and the finished product sometimes seems not as good cause u are simply use to the one u have had in your concious for so long.

[Death Cube K]

U hear a version and u get so use to that version that it is almost impossible to accept any other version.

If people can be that narrowminded, they should be shot.

[D]

The new version isnt that much different than the old one, its still the same notes, melodies and lyrics just cleaned up a bit.

Sounds taken infront, others going back, clean drums, more sounds, less guitars, more guitars. But its still much of the same.

Im just sayin if u dont like the old version, I dont see how this version could make u love it cause its still the exact same song with some minor differences here and there.

[whiny]

LIke I have said a million times, I can listen to the RIR3 version continously and it moves me and breaks me out in gooseflesh.

And I always had a feeling they just played it too fast and settled with the final version (or what appears to be)

Doesnt really do anything besides touching on your subjective opinions about songs...everyone has them.

U are missing my point.

U hear a version and u get so use to that version that it is almost impossible to accept any other version.


had I never heard RIR3, Id probably love the 06 version but since I heard RIR3 first, no other version compares. that was my point about leaks.

U get use to an unfinished product and the finished product sometimes seems not as good cause u are simply use to the one u have had in your concious for so long.

somewhat true... sadly

[D]

U hear a version and u get so use to that version that it is almost impossible to accept any other version.

If people can be that narrowminded, they should be shot.

Its not that big of a deal to be shot but RIR3 is amazing, everything about that song is unreal.

the 02 and 06 versions are slow,dull and boring in my opinion.

[daviebuckethead]

this is ther finished version IMO, much more backing, mucher clearer vocals, keyboards, more production, although the solo'particularly bh's are a little lower to me. and this version has proper fuckin drums!

just my opinion!

thanks to everyone who posted me a link!

i was desperate for a while!

[Evan442]

i like the new version better

the old one was too muddy and muffled sounding

this sounds a lot more crisper and well....mixed