"Catcher In The Rye" - Discussions

[JDA]

This song is so good it's fucking wrong. ?Should easily be the first single. ?This song would reach a very broad audience. ?I really like this song.

[Spirit]

It definately has its roots in the 60/70s... It's like a 21st century Beatles song! ?

[Timothy]

All I want to say right now (tears ) I love this monent with you guys

Hold me.....................

Thrill me..

Kiss me...

[SLCPUNK]

This song is so good it's fucking wrong.  Should easily be the first single.  This song would reach a very broad audience.  I really like this song.

I can not stop listening to it!

Feels so good. I can't believe it is a demo!!!!

[F*ck Fear]

VERY curious to hear what young gunners (under 22-25ish) will think of this tune.? I really can't recall a modern rock song in the last decade that has sounded anything like this song.

Yeah. It should be interesting to see. Well beings Guns fans they shouldnt hate it. But non GNR fans who are younger may just turn the other way.

Because they need to be educated,and fix their ears after years of listening to that fucking bullshit "yo,yo,ya mama"

[Bono]

People on mygnr have been posting about the bannings of Dave and Bono but the thread was deleted. Why were they banned? I thought Bono was a moderator?

I was a moderator at mygnr. I quit being a moderator. A few months later Madison and I clashed. Our opinions as to why I was banned will be extremely different. I won't get into it. ?It's a great forum and run pretty darn well but there were issues. I didn't agree with everything and was vocal at times. My Bad. Though I think it takes two to tango. Madison might disagree with that but It's all good. ?I'm not the best one to talk to about it though cause obviously I lean heavily towards my side of the story.

[The Dog]

Love the part at 0:45 to 0:57

amazing.

[DunkinDave]

All I want to say right now (tears ) I love this monent with you guys

Hold me.....................

Thrill me..

Kiss me...

Kill me.

[BLS-Pride]

VERY curious to hear what young gunners (under 22-25ish) will think of this tune.  I really can't recall a modern rock song in the last decade that has sounded anything like this song.

Yeah. It should be interesting to see. Well beings Guns fans they shouldnt hate it. But non GNR fans who are younger may just turn the other way.

Because they need to be educated,and fix their ears after years of listening to that fucking bullshit "yo,yo,ya mama"

Agreed 100 percent. Hopefully this song will start the change.

[jameslofton29]

Best song yet!

Hmmm, I cant make that call yet. Unfortunately, my girlfriend is asleep so I cant play it really loud. But the song sounds amazing. I cant wait to play this on my stereo tomorrow morning. From what I can hear, its up there with The Blues as a masterpiece.

[The Dog]

People on mygnr have been posting about the bannings of Dave and Bono but the thread was deleted. Why were they banned? I thought Bono was a moderator?

I was a moderator at mygnr. I quit being a moderator. A few months later Madison and I clashed. Our opinions as to why I was banned will be extremely different. I won't get into it.  It's a great forum and run pretty darn well but there were issues. I didn't agree with everything and was vocal at times. My Bad. Though I think it takes two to tango. Madison might disagree with that but It's all good.  I'm not the best one to talk to about it though cause obviously I lean heavily towards my side of the story.

Whatever dude.....you are more popular then Jesus right now at HTGTH.  Bask in it (But not in a desperate Mr. Intensity way).     

[blasphemer]

VERY curious to hear what young gunners (under 22-25ish) will think of this tune.  I really can't recall a modern rock song in the last decade that has sounded anything like this song.

Yeah. It should be interesting to see. Well beings Guns fans they shouldnt hate it. But non GNR fans who are younger may just turn the other way.

Because they need to be educated,and fix their ears after years of listening to that fucking bullshit "yo,yo,ya mama"

Hey man, take it easy. That stuff is poetry and then they rap it out in rhymes. Its quality art!

[Bono]

Whatever dude.....you are more popular then Jesus right now at HTGTH.? Bask in it (But not in a desperate Mr. Intensity way).? ?

  Alright then.

[BLS-Pride]

Lets not forget out friends, headphones.

[Eazy E]

Best song yet!

Hmmm, I cant make that call yet. Unfortunately, my girlfriend is asleep so I cant play it really loud. But the song sounds amazing. I cant wait to play this on my stereo tomorrow morning. From what I can hear, its up there with The Blues as a masterpiece.

Lofters, break out headphones and listen to it loud... It's the best one yet.

[Luigi]

Shit James I  :woke up my wife and kids and blasted it and still playing

[BLS-Pride]

Yeah headphones bring the song up to another level.

[SLCPUNK]

Bask in it (But not in a desperate Mr. Intensity way).     

His noble response to the departure from mygnr shows that he would never act in such a way IMO. Plenty of couth to go around it seems???

[ItsRDC]

I believe these two lines go like this

That needed comfort from somebody
Needed comfort from someone who cared to be

[Buddha_Master]

So what's this...9...10 tracks we have heard off Chinese Democracy (including the live songs from '02)?

Kind of scary. I can't imagine management no making an official statement now. We will almost have the whole album.

But saying this...every fucking song is great and each one sounds nothing like the other ( I of course am pretending Silkworms doesn't exist much like Godfather 3...and who the fuck knows when Rhiad will ever come o the party).

This is good stuff. So fucking proud to be a GNR fan...and I am so fucking proud of Axl. I mean he did it. He's crafted some awesome music. These 4 demo tracks are real showcases.