"Catcher In The Rye" - Discussions

[GnFnR87]

ummm its great but... it doesnt sound like the whole song....

but anyway i love it, cool synth work, cool guitar work, awesome lyrics as? usual from axl.

theres alot of stuff going on, it needs to be mixed. the final product is gonna kick ass.

[The Dog]

It is my belief this track leaked once the person collected Prostitute in trade for it, I imaging Prostitute is the next song that is going to be held for trade. I would watch out though now....

It is my belief you are a dip shit.  You're boring dude.  Now be quiet so I can listen to this track..... 

[SLCPUNK]

listen to the guitar at 2:27   that IS Brian May!!

Well, ya know..........that really does sound like him.

May help create that Queen sound too........lol

[blasphemer]

This is gonna be one of those albums where it stays in the top 20 for well over a year with hit after hit.  Its gonna have something for everyone just like all his previous albums.   KICK ASS

[ZRO]

I guess I'll go with the unpopular route..

This is the Worst leak so far, narrowly edging out I.R.S.

The song just does nothing for me. It sounds like it's trying to be an "epic", trying to reach that November Rain and Estranged status, but it falls extremely short.

One thing that annoys me about this song is that it seems to keep building to something, like you're waiting for the big November Rain-esque solo, or the unforgettable riffs in Estranged and SCOM, but it just.. never happens. There's a decent little solo in the middle, but this song keeps dragging you and leading you to expect this spine tingling solo (like in TWAT), or a trademark Axl scream (also like in TWAT) that gives you goosebumps and it just never happens.

And I don't know WHAT the deal is with Axl's voice, but it sounds horrible. I'm not expecting the scratchy voice of the G'n'R heyday but I wasn't planning on hearing a guy who sounds like he's trying to impersonate Axl either.

[SOLGER]

" every time i see them makes me wanna have a gun..." ? hmmmmmmmmm slash n duff??

[BLS-Pride]

If May is on the Axe then damn.. The final clear version will be great. Anyone out of the loop.. PM me and I can get ya back in.

[SLCPUNK]

It is my belief this track leaked once the person collected Prostitute in trade for it, I imaging Prostitute is the next song that is going to be held for trade. I would watch out though now....

It is my belief you are a dip shit.  You're boring dude.  Now be quiet so I can listen to this track..... 

True dat.

Go run along and pretend to be somebody else........somewhere else.

[alexh0618]

listen to the guitar at 2:27 ? that IS Brian May!!

Fuck yea it is!

[1badapple]

It is my belief this track leaked once the person collected Prostitute in trade for it, I imaging Prostitute is the next song that is going to be held for trade. I would watch out though now....

It is my belief you are a dip shit.? You're boring dude.? Now be quiet so I can listen to this track.....?

i'll 2nd that!!

[DunkinDave]

The hiss in the background and the error at 4:37 means this track was probably sourced from a cassette tape.

[BLS-Pride]

I guess I'll go with the unpopular route..

This is the Worst leak so far, narrowly edging out I.R.S.

The song just does nothing for me. It sounds like it's trying to be an "epic", trying to reach that November Rain and Estranged status, but it falls extremely short.

One thing that annoys me about this song is that it seems to keep building to something, like you're waiting for the big November Rain-esque solo, or the unforgettable riffs in Estranged and SCOM, but it just.. never happens. There's a decent little solo in the middle, but this song keeps dragging you and leading you to expect this spine tingling solo (like in TWAT), or a trademark Axl scream (also like in TWAT) that gives you goosebumps and it just never happens.

And I don't know WHAT the deal is with Axl's voice, but it sounds horrible. I'm not expecting the scratchy voice of the G'n'R heyday but I wasn't planning on hearing a guy who sounds like he's trying to impersonate Axl either.

Maybe the point of the song is too be mellow and not to be an epic.. Just a mellow piano driven song.

[SLCPUNK]

The hiss in the background and the error at 4:37 means this track was probably sourced from a cassette tape.

I noticed that..........

[Timothy]

On the third listen off it now .Song  just gets better and better.

now if only the album would come out so we could hear the finished version.

[ShotgunBlues1978]

Brian May's on this one?  Can't wait to hear it.  For those of you who've heard it, do you think it's Axl or Dizzy on the pianos?

[Mr.Intensity]

I think the studio version of this song will be incredible...

[SLCPUNK]

On the third listen off it now .Song  just gets better and better.

now if only the album would come out so we could hear the finished version.

Yea, it may be one of the best so far.

I am sorry I doubted Axl's vision here................

[DunkinDave]

Brian May's on this one?

We're just assuming - but yeah, it sounds like him.

[Steel_Angel]

http://www.mygnrforum.com/index.php?s=ea618cbd811fa42f6174f71a0261a3be&showtopic=63878

great song. i wouldnt post links if i was yall.

[The Dog]

I guess I'll go with the unpopular route..

This is the Worst leak so far, narrowly edging out I.R.S.

The song just does nothing for me. It sounds like it's trying to be an "epic", trying to reach that November Rain and Estranged status, but it falls extremely short.

One thing that annoys me about this song is that it seems to keep building to something, like you're waiting for the big November Rain-esque solo, or the unforgettable riffs in Estranged and SCOM, but it just.. never happens. There's a decent little solo in the middle, but this song keeps dragging you and leading you to expect this spine tingling solo (like in TWAT), or a trademark Axl scream (also like in TWAT) that gives you goosebumps and it just never happens.

And I don't know WHAT the deal is with Axl's voice, but it sounds horrible. I'm not expecting the scratchy voice of the G'n'R heyday but I wasn't planning on hearing a guy who sounds like he's trying to impersonate Axl either.

Maybe the point of the song is too be mellow and not to be an epic.. Just a mellow piano driven song.

I agree...not every tune has to reach for the stars...i think the pace and style of this song fits the tone perfectly.  Would LOVE IT if I can get the lyrics to this, I think that will even add more to the style. 

I can just picture an AMAZING video for this song.  I can see this appealing to a lot of people.  See you don't need robot noises to appeal to a mass audience...just good, classic rock

keep in mind its a demo, I can picture a soaring guitar outro backing the vocals towards the end at 4:18

nevermind, there is a cool guitar part at the end