"Catcher In The Rye" - Discussions

[gnrkid03]

Probably reminds you of VR's "Loving the Alien"... which is a great song

[BLS-Pride]

VR? Not at all.

[Dont Try Me]

VR?? wahahhahahaha

This is fucking axl rose......this has fucking great melodies and great elements....the synths breakdown...Brian May's geeetaar. great!!! Comparing this too VR is rediculous to say the least. This one is surperior to anything what VR have down till now. (And I do love VR too by the way)

[Neemo]

VR?? wahahhahahaha

This is fucking axl rose......this has fucking great melodies and great elements....the synths breakdown...Brian May's geeetaar. great!!! Comparing this too VR is rediculous to say the least. This one is surperior to anything what VR have down till now. (And I do love VR too by the way)

You sure it's Brian May? Guitar sounds like the same writer as the Blues to me, which, btw, is apparently Robin

Lets not get into the whole VR vs GnR ting again, it's a tired subject

[Dont Try Me]

VR?? wahahhahahaha

This is fucking axl rose......this has fucking great melodies and great elements....the synths breakdown...Brian May's geeetaar. great!!! Comparing this too VR is rediculous to say the least. This one is surperior to anything what VR have down till now. (And I do love VR too by the way)

You sure it's Brian May? Guitar sounds like the same writer as the Blues to me, which, btw, is apparently Robin

Lets not get into the whole VR vs GnR ting again, it's a tired subject

yes, sorry  wont go into the VR subject.....but when some people make weird claims I'm gonna respond,,thats all.

And I'm 89% sure it's Brian May......if it's Robin then I take my hat off for him ofcourse. Brilliant solo's great feel. love it.

(i do like VR by the way, i wasn';t bashing them, but comparing them to this is song is...weird you know )

[Sakib]

i think its a pretty good song. 9/10

[gnrkid03]

I think it's Brian May, and isnt it funny now we hear CITR and Brian May had that date with GNR on his website.  But fi it does happen to be Robin somehow, I will tip my cap to Robin cuz this is his best work by far. 

[JB9988]

i think this song proves axl doesnt need slash or izzy. Nobody should bitch about the old band after hearing theses three amazing songs.

[Dont Try Me]

The lyrics on this are brilliant by the way

[BLS-Pride]

Yeah he hasnt lost anything in the lyrics department.. thats for sure.

[Buddha_Master]

"i think this song proves axl doesnt need slash or izzy. Nobody should bitch about the old band after hearing theses three amazing songs."

You mean 4.

[ARC]

Like "TWAT", it gets better with every listen - but it doesn't blow me away like "TWAT" does.

I'd say its my least favourite of the four, but its still a good song.

[Dont Try Me]

the lyrics blow me away........the melodies and synth breakdown too.

[mikegiuliana]

I just picture axl running through the weeds with a tie dye shirt on.... Reminds me of oasis for some reason, very un gnr like..  Very different, sounds like a lot of vocal effects..... It's very pop rock radio likability

[Fortus]

stinson said...pop, rock, heavy all the kind of influences are there....he was so right!!!

[mikegiuliana]

stinson said...pop, rock, heavy all the kind of influences are there....he was so right!!!

I still can't belive this is a gnr tune or axl rose singing..

[mikegiuliana]

if blackhole sun and wonderwall/wheel (i forget the oasis title) took a shit this might be the turd..

[ARC]

if blackhole sun and wonderwall took a shit this might be the turd..

It must be your American ears, because this sounds nothing like Oasis, my friend.

[just_one]

not a bad song but there is something puzzling me.

this is gnr we are talking about so where are the motherfuckin ROCK anthems?

[littleredcorvette]

Ah, that'll Be Brian May then.