Bas takes a shot at Slash, Duff, and Weiland and defends the new lineup...

[Falcon]

This thread is not about VR vs GNR, one more comparison reference and it's headed to Dead Horse.

Clear enough?

[mdttkk]

to those saying baz cannot sing, you are 100% WRONG.  i dont even care what argument u put up, hes one of the most talented singers ive ever heard, im so glad i got to see him live.

[axlrosehunny]

Woo you people take something so personally.

Here are the facts.  Neither band is a "Cover Band".  Guns N Roses play there own music and others and so does VR.  Bodies, etc...

All I said was that at least this Axl lead Guns N Roses sounds like Guns N Roses.  When VR plays gnr songs they sound nothing like what gnr sounds like, ok mabey Its So Easy...    But, you are right when you say that they shouldnt sound like GNR because they are a different band.  No shit...

I was just agreeing with what Baz stated.   Dont bash me, bash him..  Or just look in the mirror.

Oh ya.   Sorry about this.   Out of the 6 1/2 hrs of concert gnr played 2 1/2hrs.   pretty fucking good

When I saw VR they played at most 90 mins..  At most..    I know it was there first album, but how many albums have they put out between the lot of them??   A fucking lot.  So if you cant play more than 90mins, fuck..    I ont ever see them live again.     lol, ok i probably will, but i will expect a lot less that go around.

peace out mother fuckers

[SADIS]

Oh ya.? ?Sorry about this.? ?Out of the 6 1/2 hrs of concert gnr played 2 1/2hrs.? ?pretty fucking good

When I saw VR they played at most 90 mins..? At most..? ? I know it was there=their first album, but how many albums have they put out between the lot of them??? ?A fucking lot.? So if you cant play more than 90mins, fuck..? ? I ont ever see them live again.? ? ?lol, ok i probably will, but i will expect a lot less that go around.

Relatively seen VR played more than GnR due to the fact that GnR have 5 albums worth of material and VR just 1. Since VR are a new band you can't count in their collective back catalogue.

SO again; your arguments are full of shite.

[Megaguns]

Hadn't seen it yet...? Here's the excerpt:

On those who say the 2006 version of Guns N' Roses isn't the real thing: "You know, you've got Slash and Duff doing Stone Temple Pilots songs with Weiland (in Velvet Revolver). They can't do 'Welcome to the Jungle' because he can't sing it. Let's be honest. Then, you've got Axl doing 'Sweet Child o' Mine' and 'Rocket Queen' with some other dudes. I'd rather see Axl singing Guns N' Roses songs than Slash doing Stone Temple Pilots songs. Nobody can sing 'Paradise City' like Axl Rose."

And here's the link to the full article:? http://www.twincities.com/mld/twincities/16123665.htm

He couldnt be more wrong, VR are playing theyre own songs and a few oldies, they are not looking to flog a dead horse by playing the old gnr tunes,
Axlis doing what he wants to do and so are they, I just dont see how there is still so much bitterness between them all.... like a bunch of fucking 16 year old  girls

[axlrosehunny]

Oh ya.   Sorry about this.   Out of the 6 1/2 hrs of concert gnr played 2 1/2hrs.   pretty fucking good

When I saw VR they played at most 90 mins..  At most..    I know it was there=their first album, but how many albums have they put out between the lot of them??   A fucking lot.  So if you cant play more than 90mins, fuck..    I ont ever see them live again.     lol, ok i probably will, but i will expect a lot less that go around.

Relatively seen VR played more than GnR due to the fact that GnR have 5 albums worth of material and VR just 1. Since VR are a new band you can't count in their collective back catalogue.

SO again; your arguments are full of shite.

Arguments?   You fucking loser..   It is called an opinion.

And who are you to tell me what I can and cant count of a bands current or past catalogue.   When I go to see one of my favourit artist's perform and they fall so short of there potential I can say what ever the fuck I want.

You are one of the guys that is just happy with anything the band does.    Fucking idiot.

Have fun listening to you one album and going to your hr long concerts........

[T_Roxie]

Have fun listening to you one album

One albulm is better than some non-existant one

[The Chad Cometh]

Have fun listening to you one album

One albulm is better than some non-existant one

Oh it exists ... and when it comes out it will put VR to shame ... like seriously

[axlrosehunny]

Have fun listening to you one album

One albulm is better than some non-existant one

You can suck that thumb after you take it out of your ass.

I will take gnr with there 5 albums and countless covers and there upcomming/never comming cd   anytime over
A band with 12 songs.......

Ya and from what it looks like, VR new album isnt going to be seeing the light, anytime soon.

How bout them apples.  Juicy...   Huh

[darkmonth]

Wait ... GnR and their 5 albums?

Sorry ... wait ...

I really like the new GnR... but they only have ... hang on.  0 albums.

The 5 albums you're talking about ... was the old GnR.

So, technically, you can't take the old albums into account ...

You're using the albums that 3 members from Velvet Revolver had a HUGE impact on ... and NONE of the new GnR guys did.

But I'm not starting an argument ... just saying that your argument is quite poor.

[The Chad Cometh]

Sorry chief but they are still the Gunners, no matter how many people leave.
Kiss was still Kiss when Ace Frehley and Peter Criss pissed off.
Guns over Velvet any day of the week.

[darkmonth]

Sorry chief but they are still the Gunners, no matter how many people leave.
Kiss was still Kiss when Ace Frehley and Peter Criss pissed off.
Guns over Velvet any day of the week.

No... I'm not disputing that they're IN the band ...

But they have NO connection to the old material other than the name "Guns N' Roses"....

Can you dispute that?

[The Chad Cometh]

Kiss was still Kiss when Ace Frehley and Peter Criss pissed off.
Guns over Velvet any day of the week.

No... I'm not disputing that they're IN the band ...

But they have NO connection to the old material other than the name "Guns N' Roses"....

Can you dispute that?

Axl is a pretty good connection IMO. 

[pablognfr]

sebastian is a jackass, no doubt about it.