Slash on Chinese Democracy ?

[Jim Bob]

some of you people live in such a diluted fantasy world.   

[Slashead]

some of you people live in such a diluted fantasy world.? ?

And so do those who think nugnr has a future.

[kaasupoltin]

some of you people live in such a diluted fantasy world.   

And some of us are just curious to know who has worked on CD..

[The Legend]

some of you people live in such a diluted fantasy world.? ?

Thank you.

Slash doesn't sound dated at all (blues doesn't age!),

Average does...

And a big thank you from Robin Finck's mum for her incredible unbiased opinions....

Slash average? Lol, get a life.

How is it bias? I own the fuckin' album. I paid for it with my fuckin' money. Imo, it sounds dated, and Slash's work sounds like the same old shit, just recycled. That's my opinion. I gave it a chance, and it sucked.

some of you people live in such a diluted fantasy world.? ?

And so do those who think nugnr has a future.

We'll see.

Last time I checked VR wasn't doing so hot, and were swirling in rumors of break-up, despite only being together for a few years.

Plus, 99.9% of their marketing success for Contraband can be attributed to the fact that they advertised the Guns N' Roses name & Stone Temple Pilots name. Not because they worked on their own merits.

Not to mention, publicity was shoved down our fuckin' throats on it.

Last time I checked, at least 'Nu-GNR' are not publicizing themselves, and are letting the music do the talking, instead of being media whores.

[Slashead]

Last time I checked, at least 'Nu-GNR' are not publicizing themselves, and are letting the music do the talking, instead of being media whores.

Playing the original members' material, that's what you call "letting the music do the talking" ?

Please.

[Slashead]

Those who don't want Slash on CD are haters.

[The Legend]

Last time I checked, at least 'Nu-GNR' are not publicizing themselves, and are letting the music do the talking, instead of being media whores.

Playing the original members' material, that's what you call "letting the music do the talking" ?

Please.

Axl was an original member, he's playing his material also.

Those who don't want Slash on CD are haters.

No, maybe we would just like to have a new & original album from GN'R, and not a poorly written & performed turd like Craptraband.

[Slashead]

The Legend, you are not discussing, you are insulting because you know you're wrong.

So I won't answer your post.

[The Legend]

The Legend, you are not discussing, you are insulting because you know you're wrong.

So I won't answer your post.

Then why'd you reply?

What a dumbass...

[Slashead]

What if Slash is on Chinese Democracy ? Do you think it is possible that he recorded something for CD ?

Having Slash on a couple of songs with Izzy would be so great ! It would give a new dimension to CD.

On topic please.

[The Legend]

What if Slash is on Chinese Democracy ? Do you think it is possible that he recorded something for CD ?

Having Slash on a couple of songs with Izzy would be so great ! It would give a new dimension to CD.

On topic please.

Seeing how he quit before it was envisioned, I doubt it. Although I did hear Duff laid down a little work, in the very very early stages of the album's production. Though it could be rumor. Even though Axl did that 1999 interview with Loder and talked about all of the songs, I believe at that time alot of it had been done as demos with various 'new' people, such as Dave Navarro, Zakk Wylde, Tommy Stinson, Paul Huge, Josh Freese, etc.

Personally I wouldn't be shocked if Izzy might pop up with some work on the second album, who knows.

But I think Slash would make it sound dated. His guitar work in Velvet Revolver has a very 'old' sound to it. I thought with VR he'd at least modernize his sound some, but it sounds the same, and obviously from what we've heard of CD, would not work at all.

[Slashead]

and obviously from what we've heard of CD, would not work at all.[/i]

A GN'R record without Slash is like a Rolling Stones without Keith Richards, not really a GN'R record, not really a Rolling Stones record.
And if Slash's sound doesn't adapt to CD, that means CD is not a GN'R record.

Slash=GN'R.

[CheapJon]

Slash=GN'R.

your opinion and only your and opinions aint facts

[Slashead]

By the way, I'm just saying that it would be cool if Slash played on a couple of songs. I don't know why some people are getting so angry.

A lot of people are going to play guitars on CD anyway, not just Finck and Fortus.

[Dr_Sweden]

hahahaha no way.........maybe izzy is on chinese on a track or two ...but slash?  not on this records ... maybe it will happen in the future ....
......

[The Legend]

Slash=GN'R.

your opinion and only your and opinions aint facts

Ditto! 

By the way, I'm just saying that it would be cool if Slash played on a couple of songs. I don't know why some people are getting so angry.

A lot of people are going to play guitars on CD anyway, not just Finck and Fortus.

Nobody's getting angry man. I don't have a problem with you loving Slash.

But to prove your point, everytime you ATTACK the new band. That's not fair, and I feel I have to defend them.

Personally I feel Slash on CD wouldn't work, you feel different. No biggie.

[Slashead]

But to prove your point, everytime you ATTACK the new band. That's not fair, and I feel I have to defend them.

Personally I feel Slash on CD wouldn't work, you feel different. No biggie.

If the songs on CD are as Silkworms or Oh My God, Slash wouldn't be interested in playing that kind of thing anyway.

And I didn't ATTACK Axl's new band. You are paranoid.

It's just that I'm not sure guys as Finck, Fortus, Stinson or Brain were even fans of Guns N'Roses... That's my concern.

[The Legend]

But to prove your point, everytime you ATTACK the new band. That's not fair, and I feel I have to defend them.

Personally I feel Slash on CD wouldn't work, you feel different. No biggie.

If the songs on CD are as Silkworms or Oh My God, Slash wouldn't be interested in playing that kind of thing anyway.

And I didn't ATTACK Axl's new band. You are paranoid.

It's just that I'm not sure guys as Finck, Fortus, Stinson or Brain were even fans of Guns N'Roses... That's my concern.

Actually if I wanted to spend time on it, I could show you countless posts you have made attacking the new band man. It happened. 

As for the songs you mentioned, you're not alone. I wouldn't see Slash playing on those, and even Robin Finck himself publicly bashed and said he didn't care for Oh My God. That's probably the reason we haven't heard it since  very early 2001.

[Malkav]

Slash=GN'R.

Dude Slash is not GNR, did you listened Slash's Sankepits or VR?, the music is completely different, and quite boring if you ask me

[Smoking Guns]

What if Slash is on Chinese Democracy ? Do you think it is possible that he recorded something for CD ?

Having Slash on a couple of songs with Izzy would be so great ! It would give a new dimension to CD.

Seeing how he quit before it was envisioned, I doubt it. Although I did hear Duff laid down a little work, in the very very early stages of the album's production. Though it could be rumor. Even though Axl did that 1999 interview with Loder and talked about all of the songs, I believe at that time alot of it had been done as demos with various 'new' people, such as Dave Navarro, Zakk Wylde, Tommy Stinson, Paul Huge, Josh Freese, etc.

Personally I wouldn't be shocked if Izzy might pop up with some work on the second album, who knows.

But I think Slash would make it sound dated. His guitar work in Velvet Revolver has a very 'old' sound to it. I thought with VR he'd at least modernize his sound some, but it sounds the same, and obviously from what we've heard of CD, would not work at all.

Slash's guitar can't sound dated.. It is timeless...

He is more of  a metal player on Contraband.  Very Micheal Sheneker....