MrVics at mygnr HAS heard studio versions of...

[mrvics]

Alright, Mr Lucky, you are going to be the first one I call out when I'm proven right, either by the actual album or otherwise.? And do us a favor, mark my words in my first post.?

I didn't hear any orchestra at all in any of the songs.? ?The intro to Maddy was hard to make out becaues it just sounded too low...so with that said, all I can say is that the intro to that song was quiet, nothing heavy, so was the intro to The Blues (piano probably).? I think pitman had some added effects at the end of Maddy but it was hard to tell guitar or keyboards...there was traffic flying right in front of me, between myself and the balcony from which the music was playing.?

Also, dont forget that I said that the end to Madagascar and The Blues were pretty much identical, just for that final closing sound effect.? ?

you really dont have to bother...
you cant be proven wrong.
you said all the things anyone with an IQ over 15 would know.

Madagascar has vocals. better has vocals also.
Axl is singing.
madagascar has quotes, in "the blues" axl is singing really high notes... no shit!
last third of better has a solo. solo is the same as we've already heard. obviously! That's what theyve been playing on the tour.
and even if the solo is slightly diferent you can always say,... well I was listening from the outside..

you are in a win win situation. it's not like you came with something revolutionary... like an extra lyrics line, or a new song,...
but you came with the ordinary stuff, made a few educated guesses, and even if you turn out to be full of crap (and by some miracle, Axl isnt the one singing the backups in madagascar), you will always be able to say...
well I was outside, runing around a palm tree, and a dog just happened to bark.

so I dont see the point in you proving anything to me.
I can make a bunch of assumptions, and I bet I'd guess a whole bunch of things that will actually happen on the album, and yet I havent heard it.

no1, guitar solo in madagascar during mlk speech will be higher in the mix
no2, Axl is using his soft voice for madagascar (I've never heard it like that in any live recording)
no3, during better Axl uses his raspy voice more than ever so far
etc, etc
and I'm not even trying.

and even if you are telling the truth, its a lot more possible that it was just a live recording or whatever, like rar, rir3, or the inland show, and you just dont know enough to difernentiate a live/studio recording.

Aren't you the one who guessed there would be orchestra in these songs?? Well there wsa none.?

Me saying that when Axl sings "...were only memories" in The Blues is the HIGHEST note he hits in that song is pretty damn specific AND that he sings it higher than he ever has live.? ? That alone will prove me right.? So will the ending effects to Maddy and The Blues and Axl on the high pitched back up vocals at the end of Maddy.? ?I'm not giving myself and room fro maybes or grey area here, I'm 100% certain on these details I'm giving you.? ?

Those two songs ARE supposed to have orchestra in them....I hope they do.

If there was then it was just too quite for me to make it out as orchestra or it just came acroos to me as keyboards. 

[Lucky]

Aren't you the one who guessed there would be orchestra in these songs?? Well there wsa none.?

Me saying that when Axl sings "...were only memories" in The Blues is the HIGHEST note he hits in that song is pretty damn specific AND that he sings it higher than he ever has live.? ? That alone will prove me right.? So will the ending effects to Maddy and The Blues and Axl on the high pitched back up vocals at the end of Maddy.? ?I'm not giving myself and room fro maybes or grey area here, I'm 100% certain on these details I'm giving you.? ?

nope...
I never said there will be. people on this forum were guessing there will be ochestra. I didnt say there will be orchestra I was asking if there were.

nothing you said is solid. it all can vary depending on the point of view, and is subject to discussion, and you can always use the "I was outisde" excuse.

it's like asking people on this forum, "At what song on afd/uyi is axl singing the highest note?!"
and there would be a discussion because it cant be viewed objectively.


as someone once said it "even a broken clock is showing the right time 2ce a day"

[anythinggoes]

Aren't you the one who guessed there would be orchestra in these songs?? Well there wsa none.?

Me saying that when Axl sings "...were only memories" in The Blues is the HIGHEST note he hits in that song is pretty damn specific AND that he sings it higher than he ever has live.? ? That alone will prove me right.? So will the ending effects to Maddy and The Blues and Axl on the high pitched back up vocals at the end of Maddy.? ?I'm not giving myself and room fro maybes or grey area here, I'm 100% certain on these details I'm giving you.? ?

nope...
I never said there will be. people on this forum were guessing there will be ochestra. I didnt say there will be orchestra I was asking if there were.

nothing you said is solid. it all can vary depending on the point of view, and is subject to discussion, and you can always use the "I was outisde" excuse.

it's like asking people on this forum, "At what song on afd/uyi is axl singing the highest note?!"
and there would be a discussion because it cant be viewed objectively.


as someone once said it "even a broken clock is showing the right time 2ce a day"

do you just come to this board to bitch and argue or what thats all i ever seem to see you doing.

[mrvics]

Aren't you the one who guessed there would be orchestra in these songs?? Well there wsa none.?

Me saying that when Axl sings "...were only memories" in The Blues is the HIGHEST note he hits in that song is pretty damn specific AND that he sings it higher than he ever has live.? ? That alone will prove me right.? So will the ending effects to Maddy and The Blues and Axl on the high pitched back up vocals at the end of Maddy.? ?I'm not giving myself and room fro maybes or grey area here, I'm 100% certain on these details I'm giving you.? ?

nope...
I never said there will be. people on this forum were guessing there will be ochestra. I didnt say there will be orchestra I was asking if there were.

nothing you said is solid. it all can vary depending on the point of view, and is subject to discussion, and you can always use the "I was outisde" excuse.

it's like asking people on this forum, "At what song on afd/uyi is axl singing the highest note?!"
and there would be a discussion because it cant be viewed objectively.


as someone once said it "even a broken clock is showing the right time 2ce a day"

It sounds to me like YOU are the one trying to find a "exit plan" if every claim I've made in this thread is found to be spot-on correct.   

That high note I'm referring to WILL be that obvious and NOT open for debate.   That's my claim.

[Lucky]

do you just come to this board to bitch and argue or what thats all i ever seem to see you doing.

well I noticed that too.
and I guess I do come to this forum to argue/bitch.
there's no point in posting happy posts/optimistic posts/agreeing when there's 10000 other users doing that for me.

I like to be the devils advocate, and give a diferent oppinion than that of the majority.
I'm not into intentional fighting, but like to make sure that what I'm reading/believing has some grounds.

I've been on the GNR boards/groups for 6/7 years. I've been fooled a lot of times with fake news, and I aint letting it happen again.
I also want to help new guys from learning something I learned the hard way, and that is "news dont fall from the sky, and if it smells like a shit, it most probably will be shit".

It sounds to me like YOU are the one trying to find a "exit plan" if every claim I've made in this thread is found to be spot-on correct.   

That high note I'm referring to WILL be that obvious and NOT open for debate.   That's my claim.

like I'll give a fuck if you were right or wrong once the CD is out?
I'll probably forget your user name by the next time I log off.

[Skinflick]

Aren't you the one who guessed there would be orchestra in these songs?? Well there wsa none.?

Me saying that when Axl sings "...were only memories" in The Blues is the HIGHEST note he hits in that song is pretty damn specific AND that he sings it higher than he ever has live.? ? That alone will prove me right.? So will the ending effects to Maddy and The Blues and Axl on the high pitched back up vocals at the end of Maddy.? ?I'm not giving myself and room fro maybes or grey area here, I'm 100% certain on these details I'm giving you.? ?

nope...
I never said there will be. people on this forum were guessing there will be ochestra. I didnt say there will be orchestra I was asking if there were.

nothing you said is solid. it all can vary depending on the point of view, and is subject to discussion, and you can always use the "I was outisde" excuse.

it's like asking people on this forum, "At what song on afd/uyi is axl singing the highest note?!"
and there would be a discussion because it cant be viewed objectively.


as someone once said it "even a broken clock is showing the right time 2ce a day"

It sounds to me like YOU are the one trying to find a "exit plan" if every claim I've made in this thread is found to be spot-on correct.? ?

That high note I'm referring to WILL be that obvious and NOT open for debate.? ?That's my claim.

Yo MRVIC...you're gonna be a fuckin' HEADLINER on here before the day is out......so anyway, did anyone call that new phone number for UNIVERSAL yet or wwhhhaaaat?

[HamsterDemocracy]

Aren't you the one who guessed there would be orchestra in these songs?  Well there wsa none. 

Me saying that when Axl sings "...were only memories" in The Blues is the HIGHEST note he hits in that song is pretty damn specific AND that he sings it higher than he ever has live.    That alone will prove me right.  So will the ending effects to Maddy and The Blues and Axl on the high pitched back up vocals at the end of Maddy.   I'm not giving myself and room fro maybes or grey area here, I'm 100% certain on these details I'm giving you.   

nope...
I never said there will be. people on this forum were guessing there will be ochestra. I didnt say there will be orchestra I was asking if there were.

nothing you said is solid. it all can vary depending on the point of view, and is subject to discussion, and you can always use the "I was outisde" excuse.

it's like asking people on this forum, "At what song on afd/uyi is axl singing the highest note?!"
and there would be a discussion because it cant be viewed objectively.


as someone once said it "even a broken clock is showing the right time 2ce a day"

Well, we know you're always right, Lucky. Just like you were right when you said "Universal has nothing to do with GN'R." 

Let's put together a Lucky Encyclopedia. It can be full of useless, erroneous pieces of trivia that, even if they were true, no one would care about!   

[ppbebe]

Being a godzilla fan, I love his recent metalic screeches but not that 'rasp' developed by the overuse of throat during UYI tour.

Just that one line was higher.  Not flat-sounding as he often does live.

well I think the flat-sounding is due to the recording.

So the falsetto intro on better was still there?

Intro?  If you read my original post, you'd know that I started listening from the last third of that song so I can only confirm that the outro seemed the same from what we've all heard.  At this point, though, I was walked across the street a few times in an effort to find the best spot to listen from so I missed some of Better and some of CD, since I ran back to the DMV looking for a pen to take notes since my cell phone had died.

(I have a feeling I'm going to be repeating myself a hell of a lot...


V

If you ever listen to the demo you'd know the same falsetto to the intro on the outro. 

[HamsterDemocracy]

Being a godzilla fan, I love his recent metalic screeches but not that 'rasp' developed by the overuse of throat during UYI tour.

Just that one line was higher.  Not flat-sounding as he often does live.

well I think the flat-sounding is due to the recording.

So the falsetto intro on better was still there?

Intro?  If you read my original post, you'd know that I started listening from the last third of that song so I can only confirm that the outro seemed the same from what we've all heard.  At this point, though, I was walked across the street a few times in an effort to find the best spot to listen from so I missed some of Better and some of CD, since I ran back to the DMV looking for a pen to take notes since my cell phone had died.

(I have a feeling I'm going to be repeating myself a hell of a lot...


V

If you ever listen to the demo you'd know the same falsetto to the intro on the outro. 

There is no Blues demo. 

[Skinflick]

do you just come to this board to bitch and argue or what thats all i ever seem to see you doing.

well I noticed that too.
and I guess I do come to this forum to argue/bitch.
there's no point in posting happy posts/optimistic posts/agreeing when there's 10000 other users doing that for me.

I like to be the devils advocate, and give a diferent oppinion than that of the majority.
I'm not into intentional fighting, but like to make sure that what I'm reading/believing has some grounds.

I've been on the GNR boards/groups for 6/7 years. I've been fooled a lot of times with fake news, and I aint letting it happen again.
I also want to help new guys from learning something I learned the hard way, and that is "news dont fall from the sky, and if it smells like a shit, it most probably will be shit".

It sounds to me like YOU are the one trying to find a "exit plan" if every claim I've made in this thread is found to be spot-on correct.? ?

That high note I'm referring to WILL be that obvious and NOT open for debate.? ?That's my claim.

like I'll give a fuck if you were right or wrong once the CD is out?
I'll probably forget your user name by the next time I log off.

Wow dude, you're a scarred and abused HTGTH member with awful memories...... .....actually I see your point......

[Steel_Angel]

Hellooo, earth to jarmo, can you answer my question, mate?

[HamsterDemocracy]

Hellooo, earth to jarmo, can you answer my question, mate?

What question? 

[mrvics]

do you just come to this board to bitch and argue or what thats all i ever seem to see you doing.

well I noticed that too.
and I guess I do come to this forum to argue/bitch.
there's no point in posting happy posts/optimistic posts/agreeing when there's 10000 other users doing that for me.

I like to be the devils advocate, and give a diferent oppinion than that of the majority.
I'm not into intentional fighting, but like to make sure that what I'm reading/believing has some grounds.

I've been on the GNR boards/groups for 6/7 years. I've been fooled a lot of times with fake news, and I aint letting it happen again.
I also want to help new guys from learning something I learned the hard way, and that is "news dont fall from the sky, and if it smells like a shit, it most probably will be shit".

It sounds to me like YOU are the one trying to find a "exit plan" if every claim I've made in this thread is found to be spot-on correct.? ?

That high note I'm referring to WILL be that obvious and NOT open for debate.? ?That's my claim.

like I'll give a fuck if you were right or wrong once the CD is out?
I'll probably forget your user name by the next time I log off.

How convenient for you. ? ?

[ppbebe]

Being a godzilla fan, I love his recent metalic screeches but not that 'rasp' developed by the overuse of throat during UYI tour.

Just that one line was higher.  Not flat-sounding as he often does live.

well I think the flat-sounding is due to the recording.

So the falsetto intro on better was still there?

Intro?  If you read my original post, you'd know that I started listening from the last third of that song so I can only confirm that the outro seemed the same from what we've all heard.  At this point, though, I was walked across the street a few times in an effort to find the best spot to listen from so I missed some of Better and some of CD, since I ran back to the DMV looking for a pen to take notes since my cell phone had died.

(I have a feeling I'm going to be repeating myself a hell of a lot...


V

If you ever listen to the demo you'd know the same falsetto to the intro on the outro. 

There is no Blues demo. 

there is no blues talk in the quotes.

[Lucky]

It sounds to me like YOU are the one trying to find a "exit plan" if every claim I've made in this thread is found to be spot-on correct.? ?

That high note I'm referring to WILL be that obvious and NOT open for debate.? ?That's my claim.

See?! This is how rumors start!!!
I never said "UNIVERSAL HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH GNR"

here's what I said:

GREAT!
This puts an end to this lame episode.
the author of the rumor should be punished.

people make their own interpretations and post them for a fact.

most of the people here still think axl said "we have 26 songs finished and 6 to go" when he actaully said "we have 26 songs ALMOST finished,...."
people here have low atention, and chose to ignore things that they dont like, and make up stuff that suits them.

[EFISH]

Did the Blues have the 2006 or 2002 piano intro, and also durring the outro.. Does he say "Ahh AhhAh Ahh Ahh (where we go) *or whatever that quick phrase it that was used in HOB '01 and Boston Ad* 

[Steel_Angel]

Hellooo, earth to jarmo, can you answer my question, mate?

What question??

DID merck or anyone who works for GNR confirm 'the blues' clip was studio or not. Jarmo himself said he had to take them down ?cuz they're considered leaks..

[HamsterDemocracy]

It sounds to me like YOU are the one trying to find a "exit plan" if every claim I've made in this thread is found to be spot-on correct.   

That high note I'm referring to WILL be that obvious and NOT open for debate.   That's my claim.

See?! This is how rumors start!!!
I never said "UNIVERSAL HAS NOTHING TO DO WITH GNR"

here's what I said:

GREAT!
This puts an end to this lame episode.
the author of the rumor should be punished.

people make their own interpretations and post them for a fact.

most of the people here still think axl said "we have 26 songs finished and 6 to go" when he actaully said "we have 26 songs ALMOST finished,...."
people here have low atention, and chose to ignore things that they dont like, and make up stuff that suits them.

OH RLY?

I think you did.

Geffen is owned by Universal, dummy.  Roll Eyes  hihi
------------

universal has nothing to do with GNR.
they are not involved with GNR decision making.
even bumblefoot had to listen to the songs with earphones, while sitting in a wault, and some "out of the loop" universal guy will be blasting them through an open window...

Check again, wise guy.

Two pages back.

[killingvector]

do you just come to this board to bitch and argue or what thats all i ever seem to see you doing.

well I noticed that too.
and I guess I do come to this forum to argue/bitch.
there's no point in posting happy posts/optimistic posts/agreeing when there's 10000 other users doing that for me.

I like to be the devils advocate, and give a diferent oppinion than that of the majority.
I'm not into intentional fighting, but like to make sure that what I'm reading/believing has some grounds.

I've been on the GNR boards/groups for 6/7 years. I've been fooled a lot of times with fake news, and I aint letting it happen again.
I also want to help new guys from learning something I learned the hard way, and that is "news dont fall from the sky, and if it smells like a shit, it most probably will be shit".

It sounds to me like YOU are the one trying to find a "exit plan" if every claim I've made in this thread is found to be spot-on correct.   

That high note I'm referring to WILL be that obvious and NOT open for debate.   That's my claim.

like I'll give a fuck if you were right or wrong once the CD is out?
I'll probably forget your user name by the next time I log off.

How convenient for you.   

May I ask approximately how far away from the source of the sounds you were? Did you see an open window?

[Lucky]

How convenient for you. ? ?

nope. thats convenient for you, because once the CD is out, nobody will give a fuck if you were telling the truth or not, just like with 100s of other spammers, fake news spreaders out there.