Perhaps 'the Blues' 2002 radio promo clip is just . .

[jazjme]

at the end of the day, all will be reveiled, oh that many be a few days btw.lol

[Voodoochild]

Judging from a majority of the posts of yours I've read on this forum, you seem to enjoy being the authority on all matters involving GN'R. The simple fact is no, we don't have proof, and just because you have experience editing videos on your computer doesn't mean anything. I worked at NBC in London as an editor - you don't see me tossing that around here, but I'm pretty sure I understand the editing process too.

LOL, so you were checking my history and just didn't care to argue? Cool... You didn't see me tossing where I worked and/or what I did, did you? You just judge me instead by viewing my posts on a message board. Great job!

Don't tell me I "don't have a clue" what I'm talking about. I gave my two cents and that's all it is - my opinion. Judging from the history of this band and secrecy surrounding tracks I find it very hard to believe Axl would give three samples of new songs to editors for promotional material.

Yeah, one would find hard to believe that some demos would leak several months before the release.. Or that they would be back on tour... Or that the album itself really looks like it's gonna be released..

Sorry, it just looks more and more like you really don't have a clue. Give me your two cents about the color of the sky too...

[themovieaddict.com]

LOL, so you were checking my history and just didn't care to argue?[/qute]

No, I didn't check your history. I've seen posts of yours before on this forum. I have been registered here for a while, you see.

Cool... You didn't see me tossing where I worked and/or what I did, did you?

I was referring to your elitist attitude.

[Voodoochild]

So, elitist like this?

Well, considering the fact that it's soundboard, I think it may just be soundboard.

[themovieaddict.com]

So, elitist like this?

Well, considering the fact that it's soundboard, I think it may just be soundboard.

Aside from the fact that I was being sarcastic, do you know what elitism is?

[estrangedpaul]

CD and Maddy are studio but the blues u have to wonder..

Well, in the original clips you posted that started off the thread, the promo had the solo, the Las Vegas one didn't. So that's the most obvious difference between the two.

[Ranma_br]

hmm yeh sounds like theyre pretty much the same thing

CJ

They are completely different...the first was the vegas show.....and the 2nd is ABSOLUTELY a studio clip of The Blues used for promoting the 2002 tour....On the ENTIRE clip there is a part of Chinese Democracy and Madagascar as well....both sound incredible....I have had the ENTIRE clip for 4 years now.

I would like to hear the complete clip, could you put it anywhere ?

[Ranma_br]

And to me they sound diferent :
- The sound of the guitars are different
- The time seems to be a little bit more quick in vegas
- There is a solo in the final isn't in the Vegas version

But all of this things can be worked in studio taking the soundboard recordings of Vegas wich we know they have.

intersting topic !!

[Booker Floyd]

Ive never believed that those snippets were studio versions.  Theres no practical reason for the GNR camp to risk leaks by putting out any form of studio material over a perfect quality soundboard, especially when its a matter of 2-4 seconds.

[Ranma_br]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UeKTTk15Yhk

This is the link for the boston promo 2002, and in it you can hear a Chinese Democracy that REALLY SOUNDS LIKE STUDIO

[jimb0]

You silly fuckers.

It?s Studio.?

[Voodoochild]

Aside from the fact that I was being sarcastic, do you know what elitism is?

I guess you talked about elitism because I talked about musicians... But you was arrogant enough to claim that this is a soundboard recording, even if you failed to prove your point. Maybe I'm fucking things up because english is not my 1st language, but as far as I know, elitism is a matter of putting yourself above others, ignoring facts (like the Richard's outro solo on The Blues).

Ive never believed that those snippets were studio versions.  Theres no practical reason for the GNR camp to risk leaks by putting out any form of studio material over a perfect quality soundboard, especially when its a matter of 2-4 seconds.

If it's just 2-4 seconds of new songs - and I'm pretty sure they gave only samples with this lenght for the ads - what's the risk there?

[daviebuckethead]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UeKTTk15Yhk

here's the tv advert from the promo, you can hear CD and madagascar, im 100% sure these are studio recordings accompanying the vid.

what you think?

[WARose]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UeKTTk15Yhk

here's the tv advert from the promo, you can hear CD and madagascar, im 100% sure these are studio recordings accompanying the vid.

what you think?

of course it?s studio....   

[themovieaddict.com]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UeKTTk15Yhk

here's the tv advert from the promo, you can hear CD and madagascar, im 100% sure these are studio recordings accompanying the vid.

what you think?

I uploaded that.   

[Skinflick]

I don't think anything on those promo spots was studio material, just cleaned-up soundboards that aren't available to us.

Sorry bro, but they ARE ABSOLUTELY STUDIO CLIPS.....trust me......it is easy to figure out when you listen to it....

[daviebuckethead]

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UeKTTk15Yhk

here's the tv advert from the promo, you can hear CD and madagascar, im 100% sure these are studio recordings accompanying the vid.

what you think?

I uploaded that.

yeah i noticed after i posted!! sorry!

[slash2001]

It is 100% studio clips on the Boston radio promo's. Seriously I cant believe you people are argueing over it!!! put up any soundboard clip and it wont sound as good as the radio(studio) clips, seriously people its studio clips end of discussion.

[Skinflick]

It is 100% studio clips on the Boston radio promo's. Seriously I cant believe you people are argueing over it!!! put up any soundboard clip and it wont sound as good as the radio(studio) clips, seriously people its studio clips end of discussion.

What he said....

[Saul]

It isnt studio clips. 

It's , IMHO , (just like saying they're "studio" is ONLY your opinion) just soundboards , micpad mix etc etc ...

either way , nobody here can prove 100% it's either nor or ..