Q Magazine - 100 Greatest Songs Ever (Full List inc)

[mikegiuliana]

top two are oasis, was this the brothers doing the list

[Stonerose]

What a terrible list, theres some great songs in there, but comon, Angels by robbies williams higher ranked than hey jude by the beatles? Fuck off. Theres so many classic songs missing. I hate Q magazine.

[T_Roxie]

That is a truly awful list.  Comfortably numb, sweet child not as  good as some Oasis song?  What a joke.

[KeVoRkIaN]

typical Q mag style - pumping up the Brit-Pop

[Mr Rage]

typical of people on this board, lets bash oasis, coz there isn't another band as good as GNR! get over yourselfs!

[Gargh!]

What a load of sh1te.

[requiem156]

typical of people on this board, lets bash oasis, coz there isn't another band as good as GNR! get over yourselfs!

Well, let's be honest - even if GNR had never existed there would still be several(read: 100's) of bands that make Oasis look pathetic. The notion that their songs are rated over the Beatles, Queen, U2- well, it isn't really worth listing all of them, but you get the point- pretty much invalidates the entire list as far as I'm concerned.

[ppbebe]

It's only natural a magazine shows big interest in locals.  Seeing joy division at no7 is the utter surreal tho.
How many foreign bands are in the charts in US or in any country?

[Stonerose]

typical of people on this board, lets bash oasis, coz there isn't another band as good as GNR! get over yourselfs!

I love Oasis, there one of my fav bands i just dont think live forever is the greatest song of all time. I dont think GNR should be any were near number one either. I think they should hav had a song like 'A day in the life' or somethin as NO. 1.

[axl_rose_700]

Captan obvious to the rescue, m' lady

Nothing wrong with the Oasis rankings. I think "The Drugs Dont Work" is a better song by The Verve than "Bitterswet Symphony"

Lucky man is better than the pair of em

[Mr Rage]

typical of people on this board, lets bash oasis, coz there isn't another band as good as GNR! get over yourselfs!

Well, let's be honest - even if GNR had never existed there would still be several(read: 100's) of bands that make Oasis look pathetic. The notion that their songs are rated over the Beatles, Queen, U2- well, it isn't really worth listing all of them, but you get the point- pretty much invalidates the entire list as far as I'm concerned.
[/quote


U2 make oasis look pathetic, right-o, when do u see liam gallagher acting like the next jesus christ like bono does? to simpily dismiss all oasis acomplishments coz u don't like them is stupid. It seems the cool thing to bash them now! even if this list has been picked by the Q writers, oasis still top polls when it's just the fans that have voted!

1.beatles
2.sex pistols
3.queen
4.U2
5.Oasis

Oasis are one of the best british bands of all time FACT!

[nonlinear]

OMG that list fucking sucks!  what the fuck is Q magazine.  oasis as # 1 and #2???  where is bob dylan?

[requiem156]

typical of people on this board, lets bash oasis, coz there isn't another band as good as GNR! get over yourselfs!

Well, let's be honest - even if GNR had never existed there would still be several(read: 100's) of bands that make Oasis look pathetic. The notion that their songs are rated over the Beatles, Queen, U2- well, it isn't really worth listing all of them, but you get the point- pretty much invalidates the entire list as far as I'm concerned.
[/quote


U2 make oasis look pathetic, right-o, when do u see liam gallagher acting like the next jesus christ like bono does? to simpily dismiss all oasis acomplishments coz u don't like them is stupid. It seems the cool thing to bash them now! even if this list has been picked by the Q writers, oasis still top polls when it's just the fans that have voted!

1.beatles
2.sex pistols
3.queen
4.U2
5.Oasis

Oasis are one of the best british bands of all time FACT!

Well, Liam seems to act like an arrogant, and occasionally drunken, ass most of the time, and his vocal pitch is terrible.  The lyrics whether written by Noel or Liam are cliched tripe with distressingly nonsensical rhyme schemes. I don't really know what Bono has to do with it, but at least he can sing, write good melodies, and for all his supposed arrogance, he is genuinely devoted to humanitarian causes. If we're talking arrogance, Noel Gallagher is the one who has been quoted as saying his songs are as good or better than songs written by any songwriter of any era.

As far as it being cool to bash them these days, I can honestly say I've thought they were crap since hearing Wonderwall for the first time. It's a matter of opinion - we can agree to disagree.