SO LETS SAY CHINESE DEMOCRACY COMES OUT....AND IT SUX..THEN WHAT

[jaypayton]

we are all assuming it is going to be a classic...but what if, just what if it is weak and not on par with appetite or even illusion for that matter...Will Axl still be living off of Appetite or be disregarded...I mean there is a certain other band that no longer writes good music but continues to live off their past even though their new stuff is regarded as a joke (Metallica)..I would hate to see Axl join that company as a washed up artist living in his past...

[mr. moustache]

First off, I like the illusions more than appetite. If it bombs he'll be disregarded I think. Metallica arn't a joke, a lot of metallica fans I know have hope that the new album will be better since they changed producers and stuff.

EDIT: new gnr are a bigger joke than metallica, it's true whether we like it or not. ACCEPT IT

[Steel_Angel]

i dont think it matters... we havent even heard the best of CD, it wont sux. unless gnr wants it to suck 

[Steel_Angel]

EDIT: new gnr are a bigger joke than metallica, it's true whether we like it or not. ACCEPT IT

yea, sux for them 

[grog mug]

Just listen to the demos...it obviously won't suck

[PrettyTiedUp763]

i dont think it matters... we havent even heard the best of CD, it wont sux. unless gnr wants it to suck?

  What a scary thought! Well, I've liked everything I have heard so far, so I know that CD will have at least some good songs. I'm sure it will knock us on our ass. I'm keeping my fingers crossed.

[EccoTides]

Considering most of the demos and live tracks rock (save for IRS, in my opinion), I think that the album is going to rock. And even the "worst" of those songs, IRS, isn't even a bad song in my eyes, just an average one. Which means that the album is already ahead of either UYI in my eyes.

[dave-gnfnr2k]

its not going  to suck if the blues, maddy, chin dem, twat, better and citr are on the album.

[user FKA webmoster]

Personally I think that if it does suck Axl still could live off of AFD, cause the new band simply plays the shit outta it

[theillusion]

If it BOMBS it'll be the end of Guns N Roses 

[Layne Staley's Sunglasses]

If it BOMBS it'll be the end of Guns N Roses 

You think so? 

[WARose]

what a weird thread

IRS, rhiad, maddy, better, the blues, citr, twat and chinese democracy are awesome songs in my opinion... and if the majority of those are on the record + some other songs on that level, i`ll be seriously happy with it

so basically,  it`s impossible for it to suck 

[Axl_GNR]

even if its not as good as Appetite for Destruction and the Illusion albums, it'll still be way better than anything else out there today. 

[Gordi]

Judging by what we've heard it would take something big for this album to suck. It's really unlikely though, there's just too many top quality songs.

[GNRBABY]

EDIT: new gnr are a bigger joke than metallica, it's true whether we like it or not. ACCEPT IT

Don't excuse Metallica's crappy music on GNR breaking up and not putting out an album. Axl has transformed the band and it has taken some time. CD will be better than any of the last 3 Metallica records= CONFIRMED. The media will probably not go crazy fot it, but the fans will love and new fans will love it.

[F*ck Fear]

Dude all of what I heard has been good enough to be on the album.

Better
The Blues
Madagascar
There Was A Time
Catcher In The Rye
IRS
Chinese Democracy

Fuck even if Rhiad is on it, it would be a solid record so far.

[ShotgunBlues1978]

We've heard enough material to know it won't suck

[tHeElEcTrIcSiNtAr]

It aint gonna suck and thats the bottom line.

[themovieaddict.com]

i dont think it matters... we havent even heard the best of CD, it wont sux. unless gnr wants it to suck 

According to Axl, we HAVE heard the best of CD.

He said he considers his three favorite "Big Guns" to be The Blues, TWAT and Better.

[MrBrOwNsToNeR]

WAIT AND SEE.

nobody knows.

if CD sucks ... then it will not change my life ...

my life is not devoted to GNR . It's just a rock band ... it's not so important.