Catcher In The Rye Instrumental?

[theillusion]

The way most songs are produced, the vocals are another "level" than the music itself, so the program picks up on that, and can take the vocals off. As for rough demo's such as CITR, and it goes the same for just about all live material ive run through this program, it just doenst pick up on it.

what about the cleaned up catcher verison called "catcher dehissed" ? that doesnt sound rough so can you do it with the clearer sounding catcher dehissed version?

[EFISH]

That's the one I originally tried it with

[theillusion]

That's the one I originally tried it with

 

[gunner mad]

this is the best i could do
http://www.megaupload.com/?d=9EMZRNA1

[theillusion]

Okay. I'll check it out 

[theillusion]

gunner mad, what you've done is close to being fully silent instrumental with no axl vocals but I still can faintly hear him in the backround. That means you just need to fully punch out his vocals so you can't hear them at all. Can you do it? Because you're close on this. 

[EFISH]

Yeah but it totally messed up the sound, no offense. I'm telling you, you cant strip the vocals from this CITR without messing up the music. It sounds horrible, no offense, cuz its not your fault, its just going to happen, its inevitable.

[theillusion]

but let's hear it with vocals fully stripped. I want to be the judge if it sounds bad or not if you do it this way.