Guns N' Roses - May 12th, 2006 New York City, New York, USA 2 DVD - GNRosas dime

[Liquid Drum]

Maybe someone should take it offline and we can cover this up, as if it never happened? Not to be deceptive, but if someone fucked up by accident and then they corrected the problem, he may not be as upset.? ?

Nah, the damage has already been done.

I know he doesn't 'OWN' the recording or anything, but he may have not wanted it torrented just yet - he might want to get some more trades then torrent it himself.

Its just respectful to ask first imo.

And if GNROSAS did infact say he didn't want it torrented ot trading openly yet then thats just disrespectful and thats why people can be very wary about this when releasing recordings.

[zombux]

well actually I agree with you, the uploader should have asked GNROSAS first. altough I'm sure he wouldn't agree maybe after a few weeks or months.

[timebomb]

i do not care what anyone one says once u trade it openly the cdr or dvdr is mine to do what i see fit

[DeathByFire]

Quote from gnrosas from another site a few weeks back

"My version as you can see it is traded out openly and it is a matter of time to be traded more heavily and possibly be shared. I personally won't upload it on the tracker as now i don't have unlimited bandwidth, so my uploads from now on will be really limited."


In my opinion he traded it openly and the person who has it can do what they want with it.? Now it is being shared what is the problem ??

I say let it roll.

[greendog]

^ if thats a direct quoat from the man himself, then he cant really ocmplain much.

he seems a cool guy, ive always got along with him and hes been quick in responding to my questions about his shows and stuff, so i respect him as a trader.

but if he has said more recently that he doesnt want it to be torrented and stuff, this will be so the value of the show sould remain high so he can milk it for a few rarer trades and such. just a thought.

myself, i cant see him been too bothered... i just hope the guy that uploads something makes sure its ok first. even though my opinion is if you have it, you can do what you want with it... but that would piss some people off and would stop them from trading other stuff in the future.

[Mr. Redman]

i do not care what anyone one says once u trade it openly the cdr or dvdr is mine to do what i see fit

And I've got to agree with this one. Unless I was told SPECIFILY not to do anything with it by the author himself. Even then I'll wait a month n' do what I see fit.

[BluesGNR]

True enough and good points.. once it's traded, its on the market.  Hopefully all is well.  He does seem like a cool guy from what I've seen in dealing with him, it just would have been respectful to ask first. 

[timebomb]

wrong ask no
u trade it it is open season period no questions asked

[uzisuicide2002]

Can someone put this up on Jam To This or The Trader Den? I can't get dime to work. EVER!!!

[agropolus]

Quote from gnrosas from another site a few weeks back

"My version as you can see it is traded out openly and it is a matter of time to be traded more heavily and possibly be shared. I personally won't upload it on the tracker as now i don't have unlimited bandwidth, so my uploads from now on will be really limited."


In my opinion he traded it openly and the person who has it can do what they want with it.  Now it is being shared what is the problem ??

I say let it roll.

From what he said (if those are really his own words), he's trading the DVDs openly and he won't torrent them simply because he doesn't have the bandwidth (and not because he doesn't want them to be torrented at all).

[sjgotnitro]

http://www.gnrotgm.com/forum/index.php?topic=3311.15 link to his comments

[acdcUSSR]

Ok, I will stop seeding until I receive a response from GNRosas about torrenting it. No one has completed an upload yet, so no damage is done, yet.

Sorry to all the leechers!!

Does anyone know when GNRosas will return?

[timebomb]

i now am reporting this bullshit to the dime

[sjgotnitro]

Ok, I will stop seeding until I receive a response from GNRosas about torrenting it. No one has completed an upload yet, so no damage is done, yet.

Sorry to all the leechers!!

Does anyone know when GNRosas will return?

I for one will stand up and say seed the rest of it. If there was no prediscussed terms it is yours to do what you want with it. Take a look at the leechers list the big boys are not Dl it. You know why they already have it. ?My questions what did you have good from 2006 that he traded it to you for it?

[EFISH]

He doesn't own it. He filmed it, so what.. it's a bootleg. I doubt he cares anyway. Also, we already have this show, so... so what? THis is better wuality and no watermark but its not crazy rare, and if he was trading openly, he's not trying to keep it private and such... Keep the seed running, its ridiculous not too...

[agropolus]

That's what I thought, he probably already traded this out to a bunch of people including the "big boys", so I really don't see any problems in everyone else having this now...

[acdcUSSR]

@ timebonb: What bullshit is there to report? I won't be seeding for a few days. I'd like to make sure GNRosas is ok with this before I continue seeding. I probably should have done this BEFORE I uploaded the torrent, but I've learned my lesson now.

@ sjgotnitro: I received this from someone who received it from GNRosas. I did not receive it directly from GNRosas.

[timebomb]

learn little man once u trade something to some one i do not believe in hoarding it once it is in your hands it is yours u do not let people run u or your collection no one tells me what i can or can not torrent.

[Nightfall]

Ok, I will stop seeding until I receive a response from GNRosas about torrenting it. No one has completed an upload yet, so no damage is done, yet.

Sorry to all the leechers!!

Does anyone know when GNRosas will return?

I for one will stand up and say seed the rest of it. If there was no prediscussed terms it is yours to do what you want with it. Take a look at the leechers list the big boys are not Dl it. You know why they already have it.  My questions what did you have good from 2006 that he traded it to you for it?

he also traded it for older guns shows he didn't have yet...

[sjgotnitro]

Now that is really crazy you got it second hand and your worried about seeding it. That is crazy. They guy you traded with if he is ok then that is all that matters actually once you trade openly it is out ther for others. So if he traded with someone and then they traded with you how many poeple have got it by now. I'm sure more than you know. It has been advertised publicly for 7 weeks, and how many weeks secrectly before that.?