Rock am Ring on GERMAN TV!! confirmed!

[Will]

Mistakes: WTTJ (Axl didn't sing "My serpentine"), My Michelle (Axl starts song with second verse, corrects himself), Patience (Axl sings second verse instead of first, corrects himself), Paradise City (Axl starts his opening verse before he's supposed to)

I love these little mistakes, that's what make concerts a real good experience. I'm not there to listen to the CD. It also shows everybody makes mistakes, it's just part of the experience in my opinion.
I loved it in Dublin when Axl started the last verse of The Blues a bit too early and had to improvise a little.

[jazjme]

Mistakes: WTTJ (Axl didn't sing "My serpentine"), My Michelle (Axl starts song with second verse, corrects himself), Patience (Axl sings second verse instead of first, corrects himself), Paradise City (Axl starts his opening verse before he's supposed to)

I love these little mistakes, that's what make concerts a real good experience. I'm not there to listen to the CD. It also shows everybody makes mistakes, it's just part of the experience in my opinion.
I loved it in Dublin when Axl started the last verse of The Blues a bit too early and had to improvise a little.

I absolutly agree on that point, I dont go to ashoe wanting to hear a  play by play of tunes, I go to shows to hear it all,the amzing  sonics that didnt get caught on tape, and the imperfections that take tunes to  doffernt levels.this isnt MEMOREXafter all!

[bromle]

The quality is fuckingfantastic

And axls voice sounds very very good.

And the clip of better made me see that I need to see the rest of the show. I have to. Looks so awsome.

And with good quality It will be e nice day. (to bad I cant sig up for dime)

so if anyone that is signed up could download the torrent file, and upload that. Its a very small file so it wouldnt take to long.

thanks !

[Syd Vega]

I saw the whole thing on tv.

My opinion:

First, Axl was great, he sounded great,he looked great, lost a litte edge though...but he still has that aura ! ?

On the other hand...I got used to the idea of a "new band" before I saw this...but man, this band can't rock 'n' roll at all, especially brain ruins it, he doesn't have the groove and the feel to do it. The guitarists, with the exception of Fortus still suck really bad, now I miss the old band more than ever. I couldn't stop myself from thinking: "This is ALL wrong" during the entire show. It's simply not working. During the new songs, to me it looked like Axl felt the same way, you can see a difference there...the new songs weren't written by a functioning rock 'n' roll band, that's why they don't work live. When "better" came up the quality (song-wise) dropped so much after the great first songs...sad. Robin hurried to get through the opening riff of "sweet child" and realized it, you can see that as well...he's still scared to play that...but who wouldn't ? And so on....
My conclusion:
This is ALL wrong.
It's just not working.

I'm not a hater, I so wanted to enjoy this and everybody who truly does enjoy it, more power to you ! ?
But really, if you're ?REALLY, REALLY honest about it....oh well !
 

[estranged.1098]

About Dime: nobody can sign up. On the first try.

You have to keep refreshing the page for a while, and hopefully after 15 minutes of doing that you'll see the registration page. Don't hit refresh then.

(sorry for the slightly OT).

[wells]

I saw the whole thing on tv.

My opinion:

First, Axl was great, he sounded great,he looked great, lost a litte edge though...but he still has that aura ! 

On the other hand...I got used to the idea of a "new band" before I saw this...but man, this band can't rock 'n' roll at all, especially brain ruins it, he doesn't have the groove and the feel to do it. The guitarists, with the exception of Fortus still suck really bad, now I miss the old band more than ever. I couldn't stop myself from thinking: "This is ALL wrong" during the entire show. It's simply not working. During the new songs, to me it looked like Axl felt the same way, you can see a difference there...the new songs weren't written by a functioning rock 'n' roll band, that's why they don't work live. When "better" came up the quality (song-wise) dropped so much after the great first songs...sad. Robin hurried to get through the opening riff of "sweet child" and realized it, you can see that as well...he's still scared to play that...but who wouldn't ? And so on....
My conclusion:
This is ALL wrong.
It's just not working.

I'm not a hater, I so wanted to enjoy this and everybody who truly does enjoy it, more power to you ! 
But really, if you're  REALLY, REALLY honest about it....oh well !
 

Did You see them live on this tour?... With all the respect, but this band CAN rock 'n' roll and they do it great. Brain and Frank later were amazing, nothing but amazing. As all of them was. I saw them only twice and I didn't notice a single band member having bad time or not grooving...

To be honest with you, I think your big expectaions and un-fairness to this new Guns ruined it big time for you.

[bolton]

I will please you don't move my topic on excisting topic about rock am ring tv,because i think this the best gnr live video ever deserve topic about impresions

I think better is the song of the night.
i haven't heard better sobg for a 10 years!!!
show was excelent,but everything was in shadow of "better"
guitar parts are excelent,rhytam is brilliant,axl voice is amazing!!!
this song will be huge hit

Other songs are amazing,anfd there were a lot lof energy in the crowd

[bolton]

this band are amazing live,i saw them in budapest

and this band have had a great support from fans (300000 were on gnr shows,don't count festivals),and thatis amazing

[zombux]

fucking massacre too bad it was one of the first shows, the band was improving during the tour

[Jim Bob]

I saw the whole thing on tv.

My opinion:

First, Axl was great, he sounded great,he looked great, lost a litte edge though...but he still has that aura ! 

On the other hand...I got used to the idea of a "new band" before I saw this...but man, this band can't rock 'n' roll at all, especially brain ruins it, he doesn't have the groove and the feel to do it. The guitarists, with the exception of Fortus still suck really bad, now I miss the old band more than ever. I couldn't stop myself from thinking: "This is ALL wrong" during the entire show. It's simply not working. During the new songs, to me it looked like Axl felt the same way, you can see a difference there...the new songs weren't written by a functioning rock 'n' roll band, that's why they don't work live. When "better" came up the quality (song-wise) dropped so much after the great first songs...sad. Robin hurried to get through the opening riff of "sweet child" and realized it, you can see that as well...he's still scared to play that...but who wouldn't ? And so on....
My conclusion:
This is ALL wrong.
It's just not working.

I'm not a hater, I so wanted to enjoy this and everybody who truly does enjoy it, more power to you ! 
But really, if you're  REALLY, REALLY honest about it....oh well !
 

Did You see them live on this tour?... With all the respect, but this band CAN rock 'n' roll and they do it great. Brain and Frank later were amazing, nothing but amazing. As all of them was. I saw them only twice and I didn't notice a single band member having bad time or not grooving...

To be honest with you, I think your big expectaions and un-fairness to this new Guns ruined it big time for you.

exactly. Its time to move on from the old days!.   Not to take this thread in that direction but with comments like that..   This is an amazing show and anyone who says otherwise is just biased against this band and will ridicule anything they do. 

Thanks to everyone who had a hand in gettin this show out so quick.. Sladdi, Limulus, Will..

[Butch Français]

damn dime site ain't working

[greendog]

its ok... too much reverb on axls voice. but im just been picky

[Jim Bob]

damn dime site ain't working

do you mean signing up? just keep trying untli it lets you in.

[Liquid Drum]

fucking massacre too bad it was one of the first shows, the band was improving during the tour

+1

Although this show kicks ass, his voice and the band got better and better as the tour went on. This is still top stuff and a great performance - a DVD to treasure in any fans collection for many years to come.

 

[DazRose85]

Could someone pretty please upload I.R.S. to youtube??!   Just to keep me going till I get the DVD!

[Will]

The DivX/ MPEG2 versions of The Blues and IRS would be really appreciated, thanks folks!

[blaqktiger]

I only have the MP3.. But DAMN!!! This is amazing!

[WARose]

SERIOUSLY guys....   i saw gnr on 2nd of june and 2nd of july....

his voice at rock am ring was far superior to his voice in holland, which was a month later. so i don?t know about his voice improving during the tour. i mean yeah.... maybe he had an off night in holland, because they played the day before in zurich, but you definitely can?t say in general that his voice is better because the concert was later on the tour

[Jim Bob]

SERIOUSLY guys....   i saw gnr on 2nd of june and 2nd of july....

his voice at rock am ring was far superior to his voice in holland, which was a month later. so i don?t know about his voice improving during the tour. i mean yeah.... maybe he had an off night in holland, because they played the day before in zurich, but you definitely can?t say that his voice is better because the concert was later on the tour

ya but if you look at his voice on some of those UK gigs it was stronger than both of those shows.   Its just a matter of having on and off nights.

[suzypi]

well i just saw the brodcast, first it is great to see GNR on TV it is so rare especially here in europe (compared to lucky south americans).

secondly i am glad that i didnt go to see this shitty live band on their last european tour this year.

axl is ok even good but oh god the rest of the nobodies as i like to call them i cant believe how they shit songs a lot especially that fucking very bad drummer, pleaze man just go back to learn the intro of brownstone, you play it so wrong, same for you could be mine, please MATT come back thats an emergency.

plus 3 guitarists is probably too much one start a solo the second continues it & the 3rd ends it, what a mess to follow, the cameramen were all lost & i can understand that.
about the guitarist who plays the intro of paradise, please go back & practice a lot, you dont have the sound the notes & the rythm. ?

about finck he was supposed to be the best guitarist of those nu gnr, well he is the one who respects the less the notes of the soli, all soli he does are almost all fucked.
just a big thanks to bumblefoot for the final solo of novelmber rain, really well played, but almost the only one in 90 minutes of broadcast.

well i still love axl voice & will alwqays love that guy but he is not very helped with those nobodies around, I WANT THE REAL GNR BACK, or just dont call that shitty band GNR but only axl & boyz band.