Might Sebastian Bach Have a Guest Spot on CD?

[Fortus]

we don't need bach on te cd....probably Izzy on the next?

[give_it_a_rest]

Yeah great man, Baz rules, 18 and life, wasted time skid row ruled back then? ,seen them 2 times back in 1994/1995 or something , can't remember exactly, but baz is cool and he saved axl ass on th 30th in wembley, but baz on the second album in 2007/2008? is also allright with me.?

[Pinball Wizard]

If someone thinks Bach is only a "Hair metal singer" only knows songs like "Sweet Little Sister" and "Rattlesnake Shake", instead of really great songs like "Slave to the Grind", "Mudkicker", "Bonehead" and "Beat Yourself Blind"...and I'm only talking about Skid Row here...if you listen to the version of "Children of the damned" with Sebastian you will think: "Who's Bruce Dickinson?!?"

But there's no way Bach would do a special performance on Chinese Democracy, it's easier to wonder if Axl will do a speical performance on Angel Down...

Please:
No Bach !!
No synthesized voice !!

Just Axl

Bach sings better than Axl...

[KillKurtzKids]

Sebastian Bach sounds like a child dying in a plane crash. No that'd be much nicer. I think technically he doesn't actually sing. Lets hope not. Thank god he didn't show at Manchester.

[Pinball Wizard]

Sebastian Bach sounds like a child dying in a plane crash. No that'd be much nicer. I think technically he doesn't actually sing. Lets hope not. Thank god he didn't show at Manchester.

And Axl Rose is what? The new Pavarotti?

[KillKurtzKids]

Axl has a voice with unbelievable range. Truly one of the all time memorable rock vocalists. Sebastian Bach is a bad impression of a cliche wrapped in a cheese sandwich on the set of Spinal Tap. I think the guy is very nice. Musically, an absolute disgrace. But a nice guy. Now if we were talkin' Thom Yorke? Better.

[knut]

Bach will not be on Chinese Democracy. He hadn't talked with Axl in many years befor they hooked up at that radio-show.

[coolman78SLASH]

Axl has a voice with unbelievable range. Truly one of the all time memorable rock vocalists. Sebastian Bach is a bad impression of a cliche wrapped in a cheese sandwich on the set of Spinal Tap. I think the guy is very nice. Musically, an absolute disgrace. But a nice guy. Now if we were talkin' Thom Yorke? Better.

Actually, most musicians from the same community as Sebastian (fellow musicians,producers, agents, PR people, ex-band members and so on..) say the opposite: That he is not a nice guy, but that he can sing as hell  But I dont know him, but as a musician: I think he is a king on the mic!! And to the dude saying something about Seb being just a hair metal singer from the 80's ...  Dude, you mean the same that Axl did when he started out..?     They're both from the same area, timeframe, and rock genre dude! I love his singing, he is in one of my top 3 lists of greatest singers, but that's just my opinion..

[Pinball Wizard]

Axl has a voice with unbelievable range. Truly one of the all time memorable rock vocalists. Sebastian Bach is a bad impression of a cliche wrapped in a cheese sandwich on the set of Spinal Tap. I think the guy is very nice. Musically, an absolute disgrace. But a nice guy. Now if we were talkin' Thom Yorke? Better.

Actually, most musicians from the same community as Sebastian (fellow musicians,producers, agents, PR people, ex-band members and so on..) say the opposite: That he is not a nice guy, but that he can sing as hell  But I dont know him, but as a musician: I think he is a king on the mic!! And to the dude saying something about Seb being just a hair metal singer from the 80's ...  Dude, you mean the same that Axl did when he started out..?     They're both from the same area, timeframe, and rock genre dude! I love his singing, he is in one of my top 3 lists of greatest singers, but that's just my opinion..

Well, I know Sebastian Bach - I worked for him last year - and he is the niccest guy ever! He wasn't rude with anyone while he was here in Brazil. Everyone that I have talked with that claims to had talked with him someday says the same: he is a very kind guy. Richard Fortus said that. Ron Thal said that.

He is a very nice guy, no doubt about it!

Axl has a voice with unbelievable range. Truly one of the all time memorable rock vocalists. Sebastian Bach is a bad impression of a cliche wrapped in a cheese sandwich on the set of Spinal Tap. I think the guy is very nice. Musically, an absolute disgrace. But a nice guy. Now if we were talkin' Thom Yorke? Better.

No. Axl Rose doesn't have a better range than Sebastian has. Axl just screams the higher notes. He can't sing the higher notes without a scream or a falssetto. Sebastian Bach screams high notes? Yes. But only when the song needs a scream, because he can reach those notes without scream, and that's because Sebastian Bach studied Lyric Sing for more than 6 years.

If you show "Slave to the Grind" and "Appetite for Destruction" to a good and serious Singing Teacher, he/she will say: "The guy from the first record is better.", and I'm sorry my friend, but you can't deny this! If you have, ever, had singing lessons with a good teacher(like I do) you will know that Sebastian Bach is a better singer than Axl Rose. It's like math: you can't say that 1 + 1 = 3 just because you want.

You can say that: "You like Axl's voice better than Sebastian's", or that you think that Axl's voice is more "cool", but you can't say that Bach is a bad singer just because you don't like him. That's just a childish and stupid attitude from someone who doesn't know crap about singing techniques.

[spacebrain5000]

Sebastian has one of the greatest metal voices ever. Just an unbelievable talent, truly. And he can actually pull that shit off live too, the really high stuff, unlike, ahem, someone else we know. (sorry Axl)

[TheMole]

Axl has a voice with unbelievable range. Truly one of the all time memorable rock vocalists. Sebastian Bach is a bad impression of a cliche wrapped in a cheese sandwich on the set of Spinal Tap. I think the guy is very nice. Musically, an absolute disgrace. But a nice guy. Now if we were talkin' Thom Yorke? Better.

Actually, most musicians from the same community as Sebastian (fellow musicians,producers, agents, PR people, ex-band members and so on..) say the opposite: That he is not a nice guy, but that he can sing as hell  But I dont know him, but as a musician: I think he is a king on the mic!! And to the dude saying something about Seb being just a hair metal singer from the 80's ...  Dude, you mean the same that Axl did when he started out..?     They're both from the same area, timeframe, and rock genre dude! I love his singing, he is in one of my top 3 lists of greatest singers, but that's just my opinion..

Well, I know Sebastian Bach - I worked for him last year - and he is the niccest guy ever! He wasn't rude with anyone while he was here in Brazil. Everyone that I have talked with that claims to had talked with him someday says the same: he is a very kind guy. Richard Fortus said that. Ron Thal said that.

He is a very nice guy, no doubt about it!

Axl has a voice with unbelievable range. Truly one of the all time memorable rock vocalists. Sebastian Bach is a bad impression of a cliche wrapped in a cheese sandwich on the set of Spinal Tap. I think the guy is very nice. Musically, an absolute disgrace. But a nice guy. Now if we were talkin' Thom Yorke? Better.

No. Axl Rose doesn't have a better range than Sebastian has. Axl just screams the higher notes. He can't sing the higher notes without a scream or a falssetto. Sebastian Bach screams high notes? Yes. But only when the song needs a scream, because he can reach those notes without scream, and that's because Sebastian Bach studied Lyric Sing for more than 6 years.

If you show "Slave to the Grind" and "Appetite for Destruction" to a good and serious Singing Teacher, he/she will say: "The guy from the first record is better.", and I'm sorry my friend, but you can't deny this! If you have, ever, had singing lessons with a good teacher(like I do) you will know that Sebastian Bach is a better singer than Axl Rose. It's like math: you can't say that 1 + 1 = 3 just because you want.

You can say that: "You like Axl's voice better than Sebastian's", or that you think that Axl's voice is more "cool", but you can't say that Bach is a bad singer just because you don't like him. That's just a childish and stupid attitude from someone who doesn't know crap about singing techniques.

Amen to that. Personally, I think Axl sounds 'cooler', but can confirm basically everything you said.
And might I address something you failed to mention in your rebutal: Thom Yorke sucks big floppy donkey dick...

[grabaraxl]

Hell No. Baz is a nice guy, but he's a 80's hair band singer at the end of the day, and it would be pretty lame if he were on Chinese Democracy.

I don't agree. Skid Row is a very underrated band. Slave to the Grind was a great album and in my opinion Subhuman Race was just fantastic. One just has to listen yo Breakdown, Beat Yourself Blind, My ennemy amongst others to realise that Subhuman Race was horribly underrated. Skid Row was not an 80's hair band. Their 1st album might have been that way but the 2 albums that followed were great.

i totally agree. skid row wasn't hair metal. great band - subhuman race is awesome. the first 2 albuns are true classics.

[Pinball Wizard]

Axl has a voice with unbelievable range. Truly one of the all time memorable rock vocalists. Sebastian Bach is a bad impression of a cliche wrapped in a cheese sandwich on the set of Spinal Tap. I think the guy is very nice. Musically, an absolute disgrace. But a nice guy. Now if we were talkin' Thom Yorke? Better.

Actually, most musicians from the same community as Sebastian (fellow musicians,producers, agents, PR people, ex-band members and so on..) say the opposite: That he is not a nice guy, but that he can sing as hell  But I dont know him, but as a musician: I think he is a king on the mic!! And to the dude saying something about Seb being just a hair metal singer from the 80's ...  Dude, you mean the same that Axl did when he started out..?     They're both from the same area, timeframe, and rock genre dude! I love his singing, he is in one of my top 3 lists of greatest singers, but that's just my opinion..

Well, I know Sebastian Bach - I worked for him last year - and he is the niccest guy ever! He wasn't rude with anyone while he was here in Brazil. Everyone that I have talked with that claims to had talked with him someday says the same: he is a very kind guy. Richard Fortus said that. Ron Thal said that.

He is a very nice guy, no doubt about it!

Axl has a voice with unbelievable range. Truly one of the all time memorable rock vocalists. Sebastian Bach is a bad impression of a cliche wrapped in a cheese sandwich on the set of Spinal Tap. I think the guy is very nice. Musically, an absolute disgrace. But a nice guy. Now if we were talkin' Thom Yorke? Better.

No. Axl Rose doesn't have a better range than Sebastian has. Axl just screams the higher notes. He can't sing the higher notes without a scream or a falssetto. Sebastian Bach screams high notes? Yes. But only when the song needs a scream, because he can reach those notes without scream, and that's because Sebastian Bach studied Lyric Sing for more than 6 years.

If you show "Slave to the Grind" and "Appetite for Destruction" to a good and serious Singing Teacher, he/she will say: "The guy from the first record is better.", and I'm sorry my friend, but you can't deny this! If you have, ever, had singing lessons with a good teacher(like I do) you will know that Sebastian Bach is a better singer than Axl Rose. It's like math: you can't say that 1 + 1 = 3 just because you want.

You can say that: "You like Axl's voice better than Sebastian's", or that you think that Axl's voice is more "cool", but you can't say that Bach is a bad singer just because you don't like him. That's just a childish and stupid attitude from someone who doesn't know crap about singing techniques.

Amen to that. Personally, I think Axl sounds 'cooler', but can confirm basically everything you said.
And might I address something you failed to mention in your rebutal: Thom Yorke sucks big floppy donkey dick...

Well, I don't know who this Thom Yorke fella is so...

[TheMole]

Well, I don't know who this Thom Yorke fella is so...

Radiohead's lead singer/songwriter...

[Pinball Wizard]

Well, I don't know who this Thom Yorke fella is so...

Radiohead's lead singer/songwriter...

Oh yeah, he sucks!!!

[bazgnr]

Hell No. Baz is a nice guy, but he's a 80's hair band singer at the end of the day, and it would be pretty lame if he were on Chinese Democracy.

I don't agree.? Skid Row is a very underrated band.? Slave to the Grind was a great album and in my opinion Subhuman Race was just fantastic.? One just has to listen yo Breakdown, Beat Yourself Blind, My ennemy amongst others to realise that Subhuman Race was horribly underrated.? Skid Row was not an 80's hair band.? Their 1st album might have been that way but the 2 albums that followed were great.?

Breakin' Down?


Bach is great, I'd welcome him guesting on future GN'R albums, but for God's sake, release CD without recording/rerecording parts of it! I'm 100% sure that Bach hasn't done anything with Nu-GN'R in the studio.

Breakin' Down is a killer song, even if it's one of the most over-used chord progressions in the history of rock.  As for the topic, that last thing GnR needs is a slew of guest-spots like the UYI tracks...they need to first re-establish themselves as a modern rock force, in my opinion.  Then they can invite friends to play...