Ron Won't Be On CD!

[-Jack-]

Has anyone heard TWAT from Spain? Bumblefoot nails that solo. Hes only getting better.

People need to complain about something I guess.. from Brain (dude hes in it for the money. I hope Frank stays) to Bumblefoot (he sucks at buckets parts even though I've only heard half of a boot) to "whats going on in the band" (Dude Richard hates Bumble because Axl chose him to be lead instead!)

Whatever.

[Buddha_Master]

The question is no to play the Buckethead's parts... Richard can do it easily... the problem is to know when Richard or Robin will re-write completely his awfull shred solos. The one on IRS is terrible. Buckethead completely ruined the song. His solo is too fast. a usually...

Guns N' Roses is about the Rock, the Roll, the Bluesy element and the feeling, it's not about a pointless shredder who looks like an Alien ad play like a robot with a Bucket on his head. THAT is not what Guns N' Roses is about. THAT is what Slipknot is about however...

This is just flat out bullshit. Buckethead if anything elivated every song he touched. He makes the shit interesting and his abilities are right there in your face. Listening to him playing with GNR, and to these Demos and there is guitar work that just flat out shows up everything else I am currently hearing from other bands. Bucket brought much needed credentials to GNR in Slash's absence.

Someone doesnt like his image? Who gives a fuck. Some people thought a tophat wearing guitarist was gimmicky as shit for RNR. Remember Axl's kily, or his catchers protection outfit? Really if anything, Bucket fits perfect with his bizarre style. Having a bizarre style but being the top musician in your field is so ridiculously GNR that Bucket couldnt fit in any better if he tried.

GNR is never, NEVER normal. But they will kick your fucking ass and are second fiddle to no band!

[Neemo]

The question is no to play the Buckethead's parts... Richard can do it easily... the problem is to know when Richard or Robin will re-write completely his awfull shred solos. The one on IRS is terrible. Buckethead completely ruined the song. His solo is too fast. a usually...

Guns N' Roses is about the Rock, the Roll, the Bluesy element and the feeling, it's not about a pointless shredder who looks like an Alien ad play like a robot with a Bucket on his head. THAT is not what Guns N' Roses is about. THAT is what Slipknot is about however...

This is just flat out bullshit. Buckethead if anything elivated every song he touched. He makes the shit interesting and his abilities are right there in your face. Listening to him playing with GNR, and to these Demos and there is guitar work that just flat out shows up everything else I am currently hearing from other bands. Bucket brought much needed credentials to GNR in Slash's absence.

Someone doesnt like his image? Who gives a fuck. Some people thought a tophat wearing guitarist was gimmicky as shit for RNR. Remember Axl's kily, or his catchers protection outfit? Really if anything, Bucket fits perfect with his bizarre style. Having a bizarre style but being the top musician in your field is so ridiculously GNR that Bucket couldnt fit in any better if he tried.

GNR is never, NEVER normal. But they will kick your fucking ass and are second fiddle to no band!

that is a great fucking post buddha masater..and very true....but IMO it kinda sucks that the band that exists isn't the band that is on the album

[ppbebe]

Well said WARose. 

nes I fed up with all the RnR bullshits. Do your homework. RnR is not about the musts/must nots.
I don't care whatever you want GNR to be about as far as the music kickass.
do you know the fact that many rock critics categorise GNR as a pop metal? Do you really want richard to sub for BH on stage instead of showing his own specialities?

[Mattattack]

At the end of the day i'm happy Buckets parts are staying on CD. I'm quite confident that Footie will never record with GnR and will be shown the door at the end of this tour. Once Bucket comes back, I will enjoy hearing you guys say, "Yeah that dork with the Foot Guitar, I never liked him anyway. I was just kissing Axl's ass because whatever Axl says or does is right. Why think for myself, when I can have others tell me what to think.". Time to lock this thread as it's pointless.

[WARose]

The question is no to play the Buckethead's parts... Richard can do it easily... the problem is to know when Richard or Robin will re-write completely his awfull shred solos. The one on IRS is terrible. Buckethead completely ruined the song. His solo is too fast. a usually...

Guns N' Roses is about the Rock, the Roll, the Bluesy element and the feeling, it's not about a pointless shredder who looks like an Alien ad play like a robot with a Bucket on his head. THAT is not what Guns N' Roses is about. THAT is what Slipknot is about however...

This is just flat out bullshit. Buckethead if anything elivated every song he touched. He makes the shit interesting and his abilities are right there in your face. Listening to him playing with GNR, and to these Demos and there is guitar work that just flat out shows up everything else I am currently hearing from other bands. Bucket brought much needed credentials to GNR in Slash's absence.

Someone doesnt like his image? Who gives a fuck. Some people thought a tophat wearing guitarist was gimmicky as shit for RNR. Remember Axl's kily, or his catchers protection outfit? Really if anything, Bucket fits perfect with his bizarre style. Having a bizarre style but being the top musician in your field is so ridiculously GNR that Bucket couldnt fit in any better if he tried.

GNR is never, NEVER normal. But they will kick your fucking ass and are second fiddle to no band!

good post mate

@mattattack: yeah  his solo spots suck, but he`s not that bad on the songs....

his version of don?t cry is cool anyways....

[Hanoi_Guy]

Well, just to make it short...

One great guitar player...and one soulful heart!!!!

I saw him twice in Helsinki and I must say...after that, he became my favorite member! I just love the guy 

[GNROSAS]

Ron's playing detracts from the songs, where as Bucket's playing added something unique to the songs.

Apart from Don't cry solo, this is exactly what i think about Ron & bucket.
Bucket was a lot more creative on the actual songs & solo compared to Ron...
at least from what i have heard so far...Maybe Ron will impress me in the future...

[heinous]

1. Buckethead is an absolutely incredible guitarist.  Period.  There's a reason why Axl recruited him.  100% for sure his playing will be on Chinese Democracy.

2. Bumblefoot is certainly good enough for the time being, as well as possible work on further records.

[killingvector]

1. Buckethead is an absolutely incredible guitarist.  Period.  There's a reason why Axl recruited him.  100% for sure his playing will be on Chinese Democracy.

2. Bumblefoot is certainly good enough for the time being, as well as possible work on further records.

Good post heinous. I agree fitfully with this.

I would fully embrace a return of the Bucket but Ron is a damn fine replacement.

[slash666]

At the end of the day i'm happy Buckets parts are staying on CD. I'm quite confident that Footie will never record with GnR and will be shown the door at the end of this tour. Once Bucket comes back, I will enjoy hearing you guys say, "Yeah that dork with the Foot Guitar, I never liked him anyway. I was just kissing Axl's ass because whatever Axl says or does is right. Why think for myself, when I can have others tell me what to think.". Time to lock this thread as it's pointless.

get the picture, hes not coming back

[jameslofton29]

At the end of the day i'm happy Buckets parts are staying on CD. I'm quite confident that Footie will never record with GnR and will be shown the door at the end of this tour. Once Bucket comes back, I will enjoy hearing you guys say, "Yeah that dork with the Foot Guitar, I never liked him anyway. I was just kissing Axl's ass because whatever Axl says or does is right. Why think for myself, when I can have others tell me what to think.". Time to lock this thread as it's pointless.

get the picture, hes not coming back

You would have said the same damn thing about Izzy before Hammerstein.

[Communist China]

At the end of the day i'm happy Buckets parts are staying on CD. I'm quite confident that Footie will never record with GnR and will be shown the door at the end of this tour. Once Bucket comes back, I will enjoy hearing you guys say, "Yeah that dork with the Foot Guitar, I never liked him anyway. I was just kissing Axl's ass because whatever Axl says or does is right. Why think for myself, when I can have others tell me what to think.". Time to lock this thread as it's pointless.

get the picture, hes not coming back

You would have said the same damn thing about Izzy before Hammerstein.

While I accept BH's return as a possibility, BH likes to make a lot of music. I don't think he'll stay in GN'R that long if he rejoins. He wouldn't be satisified with CD being "it". He'd want to get back in the studio and make another new album, when Axl might not want to for some reason or another.

[Slashead]

At the end of the day, I just hope Slash is coming back soon. It's such a mess without him.

[Tomorrows]

At the end of the day, I just hope Slash is coming back soon. It's such a mess without him.

Oh yeah ... things were fine until Slash left. 

[nesquick]

With Buckethead, this band failed. Now he is gone, this band succeeds. Everything is clear like pure water for me.
Buckethead in GN'R was like a virus in a computer. Just something to destroy.

[Slashead]

With Buckethead, this band failed. Now he is gone, this band succeeds. Everything is clear like pure water for me...

Let's see what happens in the US...