Greatest Rock&Roll Album of All Time" Survivor (The HTGTH Top 5 Albums)

[Neemo]

Well ladies and gents It's been a fun time running this for you guys...pretty successful I'd say, the first thread for it was posted January 23rd, 2006 and 64 threads later 111 different posters we have our top 5 Albums.

First I wanna give a shout out to all who participated, the #1 participant was Mikkamakka (although he didn't take part at all in the finals...hope all is well ). Mikka was followed closely by Genesis, I have a good title, Ignatus, Stoned, Hillel Slovak and EazyE

the rest of those who posted over the duration of the competition are Jamie, supaplex, kujo, Skeletor, Backslash, kupirock, mrlee, Timothy, axl_rose_700, Lithium, Thorazine Shuffle, Evolution, AxlsMainMan, moonchild, 2NaFish, Malcolm, Sakib, Acquiesce, *Izzy*, gnrgnr06 , D? , Mr. Dick Purple, Rob, Thorned_Rose, Walk, FortusGNR21, mallrat, Aava, Grouse, Izzy, Jimmy?, BLS-Pride, carlosmontana, chineseblues, Refused, spacebrain5000, vietnow138, Emilie, MR.BROWNSTONE, WeHeldTogether, Woz, GeorgeSteele, grendood, Markus Asraelius, josh85, No Left Turns, Brownstone, Rubber Bullets, BA, Bono, Communist China, Cornell, drama_qween, Eduardo, Estranged One, estrangedpaul, gunnerdownunder, JAC185, jameslofton29, journey, Karma_Police, nevermore, Nytunz, ppbebe, W. Botaxl Rose, WhosGilby?, adry, Almost Famous, Ana Vader, Axl Rose Child, Better, bh339, ClintroN - Rise Of DemocracY, csny, DEAD HORSE, Doc Emmett Brown, Drew, GnFnR87, gnr1967, gnrbaby, gunners92, I'mnotAxlRose, imsorry, jimmythegent, johnnythunders24, Judge Dredd, lald04, Lucs, madagas, Mama Kin, metallex78, Metallifuck, mikegiuliana, muffinass, Origen, purplehaze1988, RichardNixon, Rocksteady, rr1683, SpUd_Jr, The New Fiona Apple, Walapino, WARose, WAT-EVER i'm totally buggin.

I think i got everyone if i missed ya I'm sorry. I had a couple requests to do another...i dunno what to do though for the subject though....if you want me to do another one let me know and maybe post an idea and i'll think about it

here is the Excel file i used to keep track of everything if anybody is interested
http://www.megaupload.com/?d=5E38V6BS

[Neemo]

5th Place

Pearl Jam - Ten



Release Date: August 27, 1991
Producer(s): Rick Parashar, Pearl Jam

1. Once
2. Evenflow
3. Alive
4. Why Go
5. Black
6. Jeremy
7. Oceans
8. Porch
9. Garden
10. Deep
11. Release

[Neemo]

4th Place

Led Zeppelin - Led Zeppelin II



Release Date: October 22, 1969
Producer(s): Peter Grant, Jimmy Page

1. Whole Lotta Love
2. What Is And What Should Never Be?
3. The Lemon Song
4. Thank You
5. Heartbreaker
6. Living Loving Maid (She's Just A Woman)
7. Ramble On
8. Moby Dick
9. Bring It On Home

[Neemo]

3rd Place

Metallica - Master Of Puppets



Released: February 21, 1986
Producer(s): Flemming Rasmussen, Metallica

1. Battery
2. Master Of Puppets
3. The Thing That Should Not Be
4. Welcome Home (Sanitarium)
5. Disposable Heroes
6. Leper Messiah
7. Orion (Instrumental)
8. Damage, Inc.?

[Neemo]

2nd Place

AC/DC - Back In Black



Released: July 21, 1980
Producer(s): Robert John "Mutt" Lange

1. Hells Bells?
2. Shoot To Thrill
3. What Do You Do For Money Honey?
4. Given The Dog A Bone
5. Let Me Put My Love Into You?
6. Back In Black? ?
7. You Shook Me All Night Long? ?
8. Have A Drink On Me? ?
9. Shake A Leg
10. Rock And Roll Ain't Noise Pollution

[Neemo]

The Ultimate Greatest Rock&Roll Album of All Time Survivor

Led Zeppelin - Led Zeppelin IV



Release Date: November 8, 1971
Producer(s): Peter Grant, Jimmy Page

1. Black Dog
2. Rock and Roll
3. The Battle Of Evermore
4. Stairway To Heaven
5. Misty Mountain Hop
6. Four Sticks
7. Going To California
8. When The Levee Breaks

[Izzy]

Kudos on ur efforts - u actually counted and recorded all the people who participated? Gotta love that commitment to the cause.

[Neemo]

Kudos on ur efforts - u actually counted and recorded all the people who participated? Gotta love that commitment to the cause.

thanks it didn't start out that way...it just kinda evolved into being like that

I got a request for an ultimate movie survivor...hows that sound? I think it would be pretty good....

any other ideas?

[pasnow]

Kudos on ur efforts - u actually counted and recorded all the people who participated? Gotta love that commitment to the cause.

thanks it didn't start out that way...it just kinda evolved into being like that

I got a request for an ultimate movie survivor...hows that sound? I think it would be pretty good....

any other ideas?

Maybe seperate movie's into genre (Action, Comedy, Drama, Horror) as opposed to decades, then in the final four match up the best of each.. Otherwise, it's kinda tough to compare "Pulp Fiction" to "Vacation" or "Dumb & Dumber"

[Neemo]

I dunno i kinda still wish that i woulda done this one a bit different even though it seems alright in the end...but I almost wish i would taken say top 4 for each decade and grouped them in a big pool of 20 and voted off one at a time...but like i said this turned out ok...nice mix of release dates in the top 5.

if the movie one goes ahead i may do that we'll see

as far as dumb and dumber...talking best movies i wouldn't think a comedy or horror would generally be in the top running...the results, I think, will be drama heavy...there will be the odd exception though I'm sure....it's a good idea for sure pasnow, but it would be hard to pull off i think

Lets get some survivor ideas for a few days then I'll post the idea in the Jungle for ironing out the bugs...fuck it I'll post now

[Thorazine Shuffle]

Neemo you make it alot of fun doing these threads.  I've been enjoying them for a long time.

Keep up the good work!

[Butch Français]

thanks for doing all this work Neemo, it's been an awesome journey!

[Neemo]

thanks you guys...I'm voting in the next one i do though It was killing me to just stand by

[Ignatius]

Great job Neemo!

A movie survivor is a good idea. It'd probably create lot's of debates (even more than the music survivor). I think we nominations should follow the same pattern as the music survivor (nominate per decade) but maybe limit the number of genres. For example, 10 movie nominations; a maximum of 3 drama, 2 comedy, 1 western...

[mrlee]

many thanks neemo for your fun game on the forum.

and much thanks to your efforts recording nearly everyone that joined in, i wasnt aware you were doing that so 10/10 on your efforts!!!!!

i hope you can think of a new survivor game sometime!!!!

[Genesis]

You actually entered statistics in an excel sheet? Now that's commitment! 
Excellent work, Neemo. You'll have ur hands full with a movie survivor, though. The no. of participants are going to double...

[AxlsMainMan]

Thanks alot Neemo, all you're Survivor threads have been alot of fun

I can't wait for the Movie Survivor threads if that's what you decide to do...so many gems in my collection that deserve nomination

[Walk]

HTGTH needs to learn about more new bands. 

[vietnow138]

If you want to do another music related one you could do greatest debut album, greatest debut single, greatest album released in a certain time period, greatest gnr song (by album) and so on...
The movie one sounds really interesting,  and thanks for spending all the time to put this game on for us!

[mrlee]

If you want to do another music related one you could do greatest debut album, greatest debut single, greatest album released in a certain time period, greatest gnr song (by album) and so on...
The movie one sounds really interesting,  and thanks for spending all the time to put this game on for us!

have we already done a frontmen one?