Supernova, rock star is on now

[Eric]

I think it's safe to say if they pick a guy it will be Lukas-no one has really blown me away

[pasnow]

That chick that sang Its My LIfe FUCKING SUCKSSSSSSSSSSSSS


Please get rid of her, I cringed and was so embarrassed watching her sing that.

Oh man!!!

Watching that performance, I was like DAAAAAAAMN! even D would fuckin' hate this version...

Sure Bon Jovi is pretty tame for Rock n' Roll, but that was just too damn funny..

The dude who did White Rabbit was pretty damn shitty too...

I was mighty stoned at the time and was hoping for something great, but unfortunately it was not mean't to be..

But the worst hands down was the dude who covered Come As You Are...

Holy shit Kurt would be rolling around in his grave if he could have seen that kid playin' his song..

That performance wasn't awful enough.. Ughhh, they showed  a clip of Tommy or Dave {I forget which} during it & I could just see him saying to himself "Kurt Cobain is turning over in his grave right now"..

Overall I think the chick who sang 'Drive' was worst.. Just not what they are looking for.

That said, these guys suck as judges though, every performance they either respond "You rocked" or "I'm just not feeling it, next week you gotta bring it. Next week." Fuck next week, how about tonight how about "That sucked, I did not like that" I think Gilby said something close, and the chick mocked him in a "I care about you the least" kindof way. Newstead seems on completely different pages than everyone else, he gets into the one's they hate, and hates the one Tommy & Dave like. He seems to fall for the 'fake' people. 

[AxlsMainMan]

Well, based on tonights performances alone, I have to say they sent the right person home..

Not much of a show otherwise to comment on..

[Goldie]

Could someone help me out?
Zayra?? WTF?? The guys keep telling everyone to really crank it out, rock it! Well, she does a crappy REM song and they love it?? Am I missing something?
I think they are going to pick Mr. Arrogant (can't think of his name). He's okay, but he seems too much like a poser for me.
I'm still wanting Dilana. She's awesome!

[Neemo]

Dana has to go...and Zayra, and Ryan, and Jenny, and Josh

got lucky last night and actually guessed the bottom 5

Dana is so green they can mould her...the band played heartshaped box so loud that you couldn't hear josh's nasaly voice but he's gott work on singing from his diapragm and not his nose...it sounds like shit IMO and whats with the little Boy band vocal runs....stop that shit

[AxlsMainMan]

I think it's funny Dave called that Ryan asswhipe out for bad-mouthing Dana's performance...

Even after hearing him out, I was hoping Dave would have just been like: "She may be a little poppy for us, but at least she can sing butthole..."

Like that guy had zero right badmouthing her...dumb fuck couldn't even cover a CCR song...and Gilby was right, he does look in pain when he performs..

[pilferk]

I'd say, so far, Lukas, Storm Large, and Dilyana are my front runners.  That Toby guy might and/or the Moby looking guy MIGHT sneak in, too...but I don't know.

Is it just me or do the girls seem to actually be more talented than the guys this year?  For the INXS version, from what little I saw of it, it seemed the other way around.  But this year...most of the girls have some serious chops.

[AxlsMainMan]

I'd say, so far, Lukas, Storm Large, and Dilyana are my front runners.? That Toby guy might and/or the Moby looking guy MIGHT sneak in, too...but I don't know.

Is it just me or do the girls seem to actually be more talented than the guys this year?? For the INXS version, from what little I saw of it, it seemed the other way around.? But this year...most of the girls have some serious chops.

You're picks are identical to mine Pilferk

I don't think the Toby guy really has much of a voice to speak of, or maybe it's just the accent, or maybe it's just his annoying exageration of almost every note he sings..

Im no singer, but I can hands down sing a better version of Runaway Train than that guy pulled off..

As for Moby's twin...I was pretty shocked when they asked him for an encore peformance...

He's a good singer, but nothing mindblowing, much alike Scott Weiland...but I would have taken Scott over than dude...

You're correct about the talent of the girls vs. the guys though...

Every week I tune in knowing one of the girls will blow one out of the park, while simultaneously also knowing that 90% of the guys are going to make me cringe..

[Neemo]

IMO Patrice is another favorite

[AxlsMainMan]

IMO Patrice is another favorite

I dunno dude....Helter Skelter is a rock song..

I think it's funny Pilferk brought up Toby though...

I was just remembering that high note he hit in Runaway Train...

Sounded like someone hitting a cat with baseball bat...

[Neemo]

IMO Patrice is another favorite

I dunno dude....Helter Skelter is a rock song..

I think it's funny Pilferk brought up Toby though...

I was just remembering that high note he hit in Runaway Train...

Sounded like someone hitting a cat with baseball bat...

haha...Toby should sing "land down under"

Dana's fart note was the worst...she really fucked up that tune good

[Malcolm]

I really like Magni...I think hes picked some awsome tunes and is really ghood

[oldgunsfan]

I only saw three out of the five cellar dwellars perform on the second day of the show this week...they axed the right person but that dude's gotta go sometime as well....does he have an unhealthy mancrush on Curt Cobain, or does he have limited vocal range like Cobain

[Krispy Kreme]

Too bad they can't get rid of 2 people at once. This thing is going to drag on for 9 more weeks. I still like the show, but it is kind  of getting old already. The Puerto Rican chick has got to go, she does not fit into a rock band. She only stayed because the guy who got booted (Week 3) has no stage  presence.

Did anyone notice how Lucas is totally into himself and seems not to support or even enjoy the other singers when they perform? He just sits there, like he is too cool.

I can't imagine why Supernova would choose to select a lead  singer this way. I guess the network is paying them a lot of money. No one can be that desperate.

[D]

Anyone else find it laughable that Jason and Tommy would question that guys commitment to the band?

Lets see:

Tommy is in Motley Crue bout to start a new tour and release a new album.

Jason basically admitted he was doing the show just to get some free pub for Voivod.

So how the fuck can they question someone's commitment to a band that they themselves are only using for a self promoting vehicle?

[the dirt]

Anyone else find it laughable that Jason and Tommy would question that guys commitment to the band?

What guy?

[D]

Phil

[the dirt]

Oh, hmm. It is a little weird. The contestents are there to perform and be attractive to the guys and what they're looking for. That's it. They're not in the band, there is no commitment to speak of to begin with.

[pilferk]

I agree that the Penelope Cruz lookalike with a name that starts with Z should have gone.  I mean COME ON!  She's been in the bottom 3 for-freaking-ever.  You can call Phil's commitment into question, I guess....but you can give the guy another shot to prove that.  Z-chick has proven she is just NOT going to be a good fit...so why keep her around (as anything other than their eye candy?).

For me, this week, Dilyra and Storm were the highlights, followed by Lukas.  For my money, those are still the 3 to beat.

Storm's stage dive was freaking awesome.

[Neemo]

I agree that the Penelope Cruz lookalike with a name that starts with Z should have gone.? I mean COME ON!? She's been in the bottom 3 for-freaking-ever.? You can call Phil's commitment into question, I guess....but you can give the guy another shot to prove that.? Z-chick has proven she is just NOT going to be a good fit...so why keep her around (as anything other than their eye candy?).

For me, this week, Dilyra and Storm were the highlights, followed by Lukas.? For my money, those are still the 3 to beat.

Storm's stage dive was freaking awesome.

her eyes bother me she is a good performer though...Patrice is good too but she's had an off week

Magni and Toby are a distant 5th and 6th place...the others can fuckoff IMHO

it sucks that there is 2 threads of this...one in ex-gunners I don't know what i've said where