Petition?

[Brody]

WTF!! I guess your were one of those people that havent been waiting years on end!!! FUCK NO!!!

[2NaFish]

and whilst i enjoy bumblefoot, i've waited a long time hoping to hear buckethead on chinese democracy.

[slashmyballs]

Just a little trivia that I know is fact.  I have incredibly reliable resources.   If you go to www.bumblefoot.com and go to the tribute cds listed under "discogaraphy", you'll see The Lounge Below - an Outkast tribute CD.  Bumblefoot learned the Outkast songs, re-arranged them, sang and played every single instrument except drums, and produced that entire cd in less than one weeks time.  I think it was actually 4 days.  Not sure the details on why exactly it was done, nor why in that time space - but I don't know another person in the world capable of something like that.  Check out the mp3 sampler on that CD.

[slashisvr]

BBF is a cool guy, but BH is a better player and i was looking forward to his parts.realy sad he left

[Tonrey]

I still don't see the point of three guitarists. What parts does the third (I take its Richard) play?

[Mr.Intensity]

this has got to be a joke

[faldor]

Absolutely not.  I don't feel like waiting around another 10 years.  Bumble can learn as he goes along just like Gilby Clarke did when he replaced Izzy.  The "new" tracks kick ass as they are, no need to mess with them too much.

[RancidPunx]

I don't care if Jimi Hendrix were brought back from the dead, I still wouldn't want Buckets parts redone. Enough is enough. If Pittman is canned should Gn'R do an all out search for a replacement to re-record his parts too?

[nonlinear]

as if axl would give a fuck about some lame ass internet petition

someone else tried a petition to get axl to play at his wedding

[TrueRock&Roll]

This would definately be the worst idea that I have heard so far.  That would only add another couple of years to this album.  Fuck that

[jameslofton29]

BBF cant even properly play BH's material, so basically some of you would rather wait longer so we can have an inferior product?

[jimmythegent]

BBF cant even properly play BH's material, so basically some of you would rather wait longer so we can have an inferior product?

perhaps peeps can boycott CD if BBF isnt on it??

[AxlsMainMan]

BBF cant even properly play BH's material, so basically some of you would rather wait longer so we can have an inferior product?

Perhaps it's not so much that Bumblefoot cant play Buckethead's parts, as it is more, Bumblefoot adding his own licks and touches to Bucket's parts, much like what Bucket did with Slash's parts.

If you play a FLAC of TWAT from May 12th back to back with the TWAT demo, Bumblefoot essentially nails Bucket's solo note for note, and trust me, I was at that show and saw him only a few feet away

[jameslofton29]

BBF cant even properly play BH's material, so basically some of you would rather wait longer so we can have an inferior product?

Perhaps it's not so much that Bumblefoot cant play Buckethead's parts, as it is more, Bumblefoot adding his own licks and touches to Bucket's parts, much like what Bucket did with Slash's parts.

If you play a FLAC of TWAT from May 12th back to back with the TWAT demo, Bumblefoot essentially nails Bucket's solo note for note, and trust me, I was at that show and saw him only a few feet away

I need this FLAC of TWAT. BBF's situation isn't the same. When it comes to rehash, it is. But when playing CD songs, he should be playing them how they are meant to be played.

[AxlsMainMan]

BBF cant even properly play BH's material, so basically some of you would rather wait longer so we can have an inferior product?

Perhaps it's not so much that Bumblefoot cant play Buckethead's parts, as it is more, Bumblefoot adding his own licks and touches to Bucket's parts, much like what Bucket did with Slash's parts.

If you play a FLAC of TWAT from May 12th back to back with the TWAT demo, Bumblefoot essentially nails Bucket's solo note for note, and trust me, I was at that show and saw him only a few feet away

I need this FLAC of TWAT. BBF's situation isn't the same. When it comes to rehash, it is. But when playing CD songs, he should be playing them how they are meant to be played.

That's the very thing...

I really dont think any of us will have a definate clue as to how they songs are supposed to be played, until we heal the final, polished versions of the album.

You think Bumblefoot's IRS solo sucks, but I dont essentially think it sucks, so much as it's been reworked or rewritten since Bucket left, because it sounds nothing like the demo version we've heard..

[jameslofton29]

If BBF's IRS solo is the one on the finished album, then it dropped in quality. BH's solo redeemed the song.

[LookingThruThisPOV]

I got a better idea! ?Why not a petition for Bumblefoot to give Axl a swift kick in the ass, so he'll finally release the damn album his fans have been waiting over a decade for???

 

[AxlsMainMan]

If BBF's IRS solo is the one on the finished album, then it dropped in quality. BH's solo redeemed the song.

I dont even really care at this point

Axl could in all honesty sell the leaks plus a few live versions of the '02 songs and it would sell a few million at this point...

What's got my curiousity are the songs Axl is yet to debut, or the "Big Guns" if you will...

Polished versions of the demos, plus a few Axl epics will be one hell of an album, there is no doubt...

Whether Bumblefoot's IRS solo be included or not...

[Ignatius]

Useless thread?