Would you go and see this band without Axl?

[ClintroN]

Just wondering... a few people have commented that (flying in the face of all the evidence) Axl's current band is just a placeholder; he'll release Chinese Democracy and will then get back together with Slash, Duff and the rest "once he's got it out of his system." Leaving aside the fact that these people are living in a dream world, in the unlikely event that Axl were to leave Ron, Dizzy, Tommy and the others high and dry to get back together with people he hasn't seen for 10 years and doesn't like very much... where would that leave the rest of GN'R? Ron/Tommy/Richard/the others have clearly got chemistry together... Are they enough of a musical draw for you guys that you'd go and see them with a new lead singer? (Scott Weiland? )

SG

just wanna say that this IS my fav. band, this line up, ALL THE WAY!!!


but your thread sux dude, what has Scott Weiland got to do with this

shut up

[BKinNYC]

Hell no.

What makes this "band," what has ALWAYS made the band is Axl's voice.  And like someone said earlier, you can't say anything about this current lineup until something from the studio is actually released.

[estranged2006]

Just wondering... a few people have commented that (flying in the face of all the evidence) Axl\\\'s current band is just a placeholder; he\\\'ll release Chinese Democracy and will then get back together with Slash, Duff and the rest \\\"once he\\\'s got it out of his system.\\\" Leaving aside the fact that these people are living in a dream world, in the unlikely event that Axl were to leave Ron, Dizzy, Tommy and the others high and dry to get back together with people he hasn\\\'t seen for 10 years and doesn\\\'t like very much... where would that leave the rest of GN\\\'R? Ron/Tommy/Richard/the others have clearly got chemistry together... Are they enough of a musical draw for you guys that you\\\'d go and see them with a new lead singer? (Scott Weiland? )

SG

just wanna say that this IS my fav. band, this line up, ALL THE WAY!!!


but your thread sux dude, what has Scott Weiland got to do with this

shut up

scott weiland replaced Axl in the 90\\\'s era guns n roses line up. ?he doesnt suck either. he is a good singer too.

[mick]

HAHA! OF COURSE NOT.

Psychedelic Furs - NIN - Primus - Replacements - WhateverBumblefoot did prior


I own exactly -0- albums from the above.
I have been to exactly -0- concerts from the above.

[pasnow]

HAHA! OF COURSE NOT.

Psychedelic Furs - NIN - Primus - Replacements - WhateverBumblefoot did prior


I own exactly -0- albums from the above.
I have been to exactly -0- concerts from the above.

Haha, good point. Although I own 2 Replacements ablums & 1 NIN, I do like all the bands & did see Primus at Lollapalooza '94 (I was more there to see AIC among others) Anyway, to answer the original question, well it depends on the singer. If it was Weiland, no way.. I can put up with VR but still think they could have gotten a better singer, I never liked him from day 1 with STP.

Also depends how good their album was I might buy the CD. Don't think I'd see them in concert though. One sidenote: I don't think this combo would ever have formed had it not been for Axl & the chance to play in GnR. So it's kindof a moot point.

[estranged2006]

I don\'t think this combo would ever have formed had it not been for Axl & the chance to play in GnR. 

and all the axl rose money.

[Neemo]

No i wouldn't go see them if they didn't have Axl with them but I'd go see a buckethead show or a bumblefoot show if they ever came near me

[AdZ]

If they had a good singer. Yes.

If they didn't, obviously not, because then it would be a goodband with a sucky singer.

But yeah, they're an amazing band.

[Miggy]

I don't know.  I should hear some music first.

[dizzy68]

 I wouldn't waste my Money to see this Band without Axl. He's the star of the show. Frankly I would be hesitant to see the Band as it is now since in my eyes it's barely Guns n Roses. But without Axl you've REALLY got nothing!

[blueheart]

I guess I would... but not with Scott... I went to see VR last year and I didn t like that guy... If they ever play again I guess I ll go ... but not for him... just to see Slash and Duff once more...

[Where is Hassan Nasrallah ?]

who would sing ?
what would be the band ?
there are a lot of parameters

but if you're implying, in a world where
these guys have never been involved with gnr
and one day i get to an ad saying " Robin Finck from Nine Inch Nails and bumblefoot and tommy stinson are playing live at ... "
no i would go.


the people who didnt go see VR live are not GNR fans. that's for sure.

[Shirell]

In short No.  I really rate the band.  But for me, the band without Axl would not induce me to pay the price of the ticket.

[Krispy Kreme]

Not as Guns n Roses.

[Lord Kayoss]

That's gonna be a negative.  I wouldn't have seen the old band without him.  Hence me not giving two shits about Velvet Revolver.

[Jimmy?]

After seeing them in London on the 7th, i'd have to give a resounding YES! Great guys, great chemistry....would definately go see them w/out Axl. If I'd have been asked before the gig however......

[the dirt]

I brought up this idea in a thread long ago.

The band would be called No Rose

 

http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?topic=18125.0

[GNR estranged]

i would see buckethead live. as far as the new band goes, it depends. i definatly wouldnt pay over $30 to see them. ill tell you one thing ,if somebody said i had to pick one band to see between them, linkin park, yellowcard, coheed, or any of those new bands out today, hands down i would pick the new band.

[ppbebe]

I brought up this idea in a thread long ago.

The band would be called No Rose

 

http://www.heretodaygonetohell.com/board/index.php?topic=18125.0

And like I said in that thread, I would. An original band name would be preferable.

And not with scott plz. He just wouldn't fit.

[Bono]

I think I'd go see any band that Richard was playing in as long as I liked the music the band was playing. That guys fucking rocks. He was awesome at Hammerstein. To be honest I dont' really care about any of the other guys really. I think Tommy should just go to Soul Asylum.