Dizzy

[Christos AG]

Look, it was just an opinion, it's really not a big deal...I don't like him, others do...that's my opinion, I'm happy for you to lock the thread before I get really angry and bite someones leg...probably Dizzy's.

As you can see I decided to leave this thread open for now.

I'll leave it up to Jarmo unless shit happens before he logs in.

I just don't see the point of starting a thread about someone you don't like without a reason.

When I don't like someone I don't talk about him.

[sea of black]

But that's crazy, it was just my opinion...to not talk about things you don't like is madness...all I said is that I don't lika a tiny part of GNR...

Look man, I'm an artist, when I have a show in a gallery and someone says they don't like a piece of my work I talk to them, we have a discussion, I don't get in a strop and storm off, or close down the discussion...that's just life...people don't like the same things...aren't some of the most intersting discussions about things you don't like...i.e. politics, sport, character assasination...

[Chuzeville]

When discussing Dizzy's input, why stop at his solos at the recent shows ? His piano and organ parts are oll over the UYI albums... That has got to amount to something. 

[sea of black]

I personally am not going to comment any further.

It's clear that many people can't listen to any kind of negative critcism on this board, which is strange...oh well, it was just an opinion

[Christos AG]

I personally am not going to comment any further.

It's clear that many people can't listen to any kind of negative critcism on this board, which is strange...oh well, it was just an opinion

Saying that you simply don't like Dizzy is not criticism.

Criticism is to give a few reasons. You don't.

End of discussion for me.

[PJ]

you didnt criticized dizzy...
criticize is not about complain about his hair, or his face... or cuz you say he is a "yes man"
when you dont even know him...
you can criticize his skills as an musician or his atittude.... but not that other things
and clearly his skills or his personality dont any need any shit... cuz he is a great person and ?a great player....

[sea of black]

Sorry Dizzy, I repent

[Mustapha]

So, let me get this one, is playing amazing songs like Ziggy Stardust or Something on the piano boring?
Yeah Silkworms is crap, that's for sure and bongos in Appetite songs are useless, but so are Pittman's "special effects" But what about Estranged piano solo, or many others in the Ilusions?

Anyway, I think he is a really important part of the band's sound and  love his solos